Raj Auto Wheels (P) Ltd Vs ACIT (ITAT Jaipur)
Introduction: In the realm of income tax disputes, the case of Raj Auto Wheels (P) Ltd versus ACIT before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) in Jaipur serves as an illustrative example of the intricate challenges that often arise. The case, primarily centered around the estimation of sales, deferred sale, and the validity of additions made by the assessing officer, saw divergent contentions from the tax authorities and the assessee. The subsequent rulings by the Tribunal provide significant insights into the nuanced aspects of tax assessments.
1. Addition based on Advances from Customers: The crux of the matter revolved around the addition made by the assessing officer concerning the amount credited under ‘advances from customers.’ The assessing officer raised questions about the genuineness of the advances received, asserting that the assessee failed to provide necessary details and proofs regarding the identity of customers and the receipt of advances.
1.1 Tribunal’s Decision: Upon careful consideration of the material, rival contentions, and legal precedents, the Tribunal pointed out a critical flaw in the assessing officer’s approach – the absence of a specific provision cited to justify the addition. This, the Tribunal held, rendered the addition legally unjustified.
Emphasizing the well-established legal principle that the initial onus lies on the assessee and shifts to the assessing officer once discharged, the Tribunal found that the assessee had successfully demonstrated the nature of transactions. The applicability of Section 68 was firmly rejected, with the Tribunal asserting that the advances were legitimate and part of the normal business practices expected from a Maruti Suzuki dealer.
Crucially, the Tribunal highlighted the documentary evidence provided by the assessee, including ledger accounts and sales bills for over 1400 cases, which unequivocally supported the authenticity of the transactions. It noted the inconsistency in treating similar transactions differently in other assessment years, raising questions about the assessing officer’s approach.
2. Allegation of Deferred Sale: Parallel to the questioning of advances, the tax authorities alleged that the assessee deferred sales from the current year to later years, thereby impacting the revenue. The assessing officer’s working was critiqued for its lack of a concrete basis and for not providing the assessee with an adequate opportunity to respond.
2.1 Tribunal’s Decision: The Tribunal scrutinized the claim of deferred sale and, in alignment with its earlier stance, rejected it. Noting the absence of substantial proof and the revenue’s changing stance across different years, the Tribunal held that the revenue failed to establish any suppression of sales.
Emphasizing the consistent practice of the assessee in deferring sales even before the assessment year in question, the Tribunal dismissed the notion that the sales were deliberately deferred to later years. The hasty assessment process also came under scrutiny, with the Tribunal criticizing its inadequacy in thoroughly examining the details of around 1500 customers. This raised doubts about the validity of the conclusions reached by the assessing officer.
Conclusion:
The Raj Auto Wheels case before the ITAT Jaipur stands as a testament to the intricacies involved in income tax assessments, particularly concerning issues like the estimation of sales, deferred sale, and additions based on advances from customers. The Tribunal’s meticulous analysis and emphasis on the consistent application of legal principles contributed to the deletion of the contested addition, underscoring the importance of a fair and thorough assessment process.
In conclusion, the case not only sheds light on the complexities inherent in tax disputes but also underscores the significance of a judicious and unbiased approach by assessing officers. It highlights the need for a consistent application of legal principles across different cases and the importance of providing adequate opportunities for assessees to present their case. The ruling serves as a valuable precedent, offering guidance for future assessments and ensuring that the pursuit of tax compliance is just and equitable.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT JAIPUR
This is an appeal filed by the assessee against order of the ld. CIT(A), Ajmer dated 31-03-2015 for the assessment years 2010-11 wherein the assessee has raised the following grounds of appeal.
ITA NO. 396/JP/2015 – A.Y. 2010-11
‘’The ld. CIT(A) has erred in confirming the addition for:-
1. 42,988/- for prior period expenses for interest & telephone as claimed in profit & loss account.
2. 20,28,74,955/- being advance received from customer against sales.
3. 2,16,000/- being alleged excess commission paid and thus disallowed.’’
2.1 First of all, we take up the appeal of the assessee in Ground 1, wherein the Disallowance of Rs. 42,988/- on account of Prior Period Expenses is under challenge.
2.2 Brief facts of the case are as noted by the AO are that on perusal of statement (I) of 3CD (PB-23), it is seen that Prior Period Expenses of Rs.42,988/- pertaining to A.Y. 2008-09 on account of Interest and Telephone expenses were When asked, the assessee submitted the details (PB 26) but allegedly did not explain the same and hence the AO disallowed the same.
2.3 In the first appeal the ld. CIT(A) also confirmed the disallowance vide order dated 03.2015 in appeal no. 09/2013-14, alleging that there is no evidence showing that such liability crystalized this year.
2.4 The AR of the assessee submitted the following arguments
“1. Firstly, we strongly rely upon our written submission filed before the ld. CIT(A) reproduced at Pg- 3 to 4 of his order at Pr. 4.2 The same is reproduced hereunder for the sake of convenience:
“(1) PRIOR PERIOD EXPENSES OF RS. 42,988 00.
The A.O. noticed that a sum of Rs. 42.988.00 (Schedule I to Form 3CD) has been debited to Profit and Loss account details below:-
(a) Interest Rs 12,696 00 (Pertains to Year.2008-09)
(b) Telephone expenses Rs. 30.292 00 (Pertains to Asst. Year 2008-09 (Page 2)
Since these expenses do not pertains to the current assessment year, hence not allowed. No other reason given by A.O for his disallowances.
Whereas the facts are:-
(1) That certain expenses and Income being in the nature of prior period were claimed for expenses (net) in normal accounting norms and prudence on the belief that certain expenses though belonging to the previous year are only admissible in the year in which it crystallized and accounted for on the basis of system of accounting regularly followed by the
(2) Merely since assessee following “MERCANTILE SYSTEM OF ACCOUNTING” and thus no previous year expenses are to be allowed in the year under consideration is a wrong
Since accounting standard (AS-5) relating to “PRIOR PERIOD AND EXTRAORDINARY ITEMS AND CHANGES IN ACCOUNTING POLICES” states that:-
“PRIOR PERIOD ITEMS ARE DEFINED AS MATERIAL CHARGES OR CREDIT WHICH ARISE IN THE CURRENT PERIOD AS A RESULT OF ERRORS OR OMISSIONS IN THE PREPARATION OF THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS OF ONE OR MORE PRIOR PERIODS” “EXTRAORDINARY ITEMS” are gains or losses which arise from events or transactions that are distinct from the ordinary activities of the business and which are both material and expected not to recur frequently and regularly.”
“2. It is submitted that under mercantile system, the expenditure may pertain to the earlier year but liability having crystalized during the year the same, has to be booked in that year only. The ld. CIT(A) rejected the contention saying that there was no evidence in support however, he ignored that the accounts were audited by the Statutory Auditor under the Companies Act and has certified the accounts showing true and fair view. Though as per tax audit requirement, the auditor has reported prior period expenses but the statutory auditor nowhere opined that the liability relating to such expenditure was not ascertained or quantified and hence did not crystalized in this year. Thus claim of the assesse directly supported by statutory audit report and in absence of any contrary evidence AO should not have disallowed.
3. Kindly refer-
3.1 In the case of Bharat Earth Movers v/s CIT (2000) 162 CTR 325/245 ITR 428 (SC), it was held that
“The law is settled: if a business liability has definitely arisen in the accounting year, the deduction should be allowed although the liability may have to be quantified and discharged at a future date. What should be certain is the incurring of the liability. It should also be capable of being estimated with reasonable certainty though the actual quantification may not be possible. If these requirements are satisfied the liability is not a contingent one. The liability is in praesenti though it will be discharged at a future date. It does not make any difference if the future date on which the liability shall have to be discharged is not certain.—Metal Box Co. of India Ltd. vs. Their Workmen (1969) 73 ITR 53 (SC) and Calcutta Co. Ltd. vs. CIT (1959) 37 ITR 1 (SC) : TC 16R.197 applied.”
3.2 In the case of CIT vs. Indian Transformers Ltd. (2004) 192 CTR 0216/270 ITR 0259 (Ker HC)
Business expenditure—Allowability—Provision for warranty—Both the appellate authorities came to the conclusion that the provision created was towards a definite liability which had accrued at the time of supply of transformers by the assessee—Two instances of defects came to the notice of the assessee where in one case all the ten transformers supplied by assessee failed within one year of purchase—Also, Tribunal found that the actual expense incurred in one year was Rs. 7,98,958, as against the provision of Rs. 3,50,000—Thus, the Tribunal found as a fact that the liability towards after sales services is an ascertained liability—No illegality in said finding— Provision is made on a reasonable basis—Hence, the provision cannot be treated as a contingent liability—Same allowable as deduction
3.3 In the case of CIT vs. Vinitec Corporation (P) Ltd. (2005) 196 CTR 0369/ 278 ITR 0337 (DelHC)
Business expenditure—Allowability—Provision for warranty—Warranty clause is a part of sale transaction and, therefore, liability for warranty expenses is a committed liability at the very initial stage of sale—Figures of past years exhibit a direct nexus between the claim for provision made by the assessee and the obligation arising under the warranty clause—It is a liability which has arisen in the relevant year though its actual quantification and discharge is deferred to a future date—There is nothing on record which can even remotely suggest that the change in accounting system effected by assessee was motivated or improper—It has been accepted as bona fide even by the AO and the CIT(A)—Thus, assessee was entitled to deduction of provision made by it—No substantial question of law arises
3.4 The difficulty in the estimation of value would not convert an accrued liability into a conditional one – Calcutta Co. Ltd. v/s CIT (1959) 37 ITR 1 (SC).
3.5 In the case of an assessee maintaining his accounts on mercantile system, a liability already accrued, though to be discharged at a future date, would be a proper deduction while working out the profits and gains of his business, regard being had to the accepted principles of commercial practice and accountancy. It is not as if such deduction is permissible only in case of amounts actually expended or paid. Just as actual receipts as well as those accrued due are brought in for income – tax assessment, so also liabilities accrued due would be taken into account while working out the profits and gains of the business – Metal Box Co. of India Ltd. v/s Their Workmen (1969) 73 ITR 53 (SC).
3.6 Chambal Fertilisers& Chemicals Ltd. v/s ACIT (2014) 112 DTR 140 (JP)
Hence the disallowance kindly be deleted in full.
2.5 On the other hand the DR strongly relied upon the findings recorded by the authorities below and justified the additions made and confirmed by the ld. CIT(A) and prayed to upheld the addition/disallowance.
2.6 We have carefully considered the facts of the case, finding recorded in the impugned orders, the rival contentions raised by both the parties as also the material placed on record, we have also gone through the judicial pronouncements cited by the parties. There is no dispute that in the accrual basis of accounting the expenditure may pertain to an earlier year but corresponding liability relating thereto has crystallized during the current year, wherein such expenditure can be booked and However, the evidence supporting the fact of crystallization of the liability in a particular year has to be produced by the assessee. But in the instant case, there appears no evidence placed on record to support this contention and therefore, we are in agreement with the CIT(A) who rightly confirmed the disallowance. Thus Ground No. 1 of the assessee is dismissed.
3.1 As regards Ground of Appeal No.2 of the assessee wherein the Unexplained customer Advanced of 20,28,74,955/-is under challenge.
3.2 Brief facts of the case are that during the assessment proceedings, the AO noticed that as per Schedule-6 of current liability and provisions in the balance sheet, there are advances of Rs.44,87,96,115/- outstanding from customers. The assessee was asked to file details of the same e. name and addresses etc. in response to which the assessee filed ledger accounts for the year under consideration of 1449 customers to whom advances were taken along with Bills of the customers. On verification of ledger accounts of the customers for the end sale bills, the AO noticed that in majority of the cases cash and cheques were received as advance and entry regarding sale of vehicles was made in the ledger account. In the list 80% of the customers, there are opening balance and part payments were also shown to have returned by way of cash. There apart the assessee was asked to file ledger accounts of last year i.e. For AY 2009-10 and cash book, which assessee failed to furnish. The AO vide order sheet dated 19.03.2013 asked the assessee to produce receipt book for verification and Temporary Registration Certificate Book issued by the RTO, which the assessee failed to furnish. With regard to the Temporary Registration Certificate the assesse submitted that no such certificates are compulsory. The AO finally, issued show cause dated 25.03.2013, in response to which the assessee filed addresses of 253 customers however, the AO alleged that the assessee intentionally not submitted the same earlier and now the assessment is getting time barred so no enquiry can be made. Accordingly, the AO applying the case of Mcdowell added the advances of Rs.20,28,74,955/- (Closing balance of Rs.44,87,96,115/- less Opening Balance Rs.24,59,21,160/-) to the total income of the assessee alleging that assessee has failed to furnish any evidence except sale bills which are also defective, to prove the actual sale was taken place and advances were actually received from customers. Assessee has failed to bi-furcate financial year wise advances received.
3.3 In the first appeal the ld. CIT(A) confirmed the action of the AO vide order dated 03.2015 in appeal no. 09/2013-14 holding as under:
“I have considered the contentions of the appellant as well as assessment order. It is seen that assessee had claimed to have received advances from customers off Rs. 20,28,74,955/- (opening balance being Rs. 245921160/- and closing balance being Rs. 448796115/-) during the year against the sale of cars. This amount has been shown as ‘advance from customers’. The AO required the assessee to furnish names, details and addresses of the customers from whom advances were shown to have been received by letter dated 22.10.2012 and 222.02.2013. Further the confirmations as well as the ledger accounts of the said creditors were called for by questionnaire dated 17.03.2013 along with the copy of cash book and bills regarding the sale of vehicles claimed to have been sold against the said advances.
In response to above queries, assessee has only filed ledger accounts of the customers and sale bills. The AO noted that there was no such heavy demand for the Maruti Vehicles that such substantial amount of advances will be given by the customers for booking of the vehicles.
The assessee has not produced receipt book as well as the cash book in support of having received the above amount as the ‘advance from customers’. The AO also noted that incomplete address were submitted in 253 cases out of total customers shown at 1449 as reproduced on the page 7 of the assessment order. Hence it was not possible to make any enquiry from the customers and assessee has not furnished any conformations from the said customers.
The AO also noted that assessee has earned commission income from insurance. So the address and ID proof should have been available with the assessee. Further the similar details are also required for the registration of the vehicles. Inspite of above, assessee has not submitted the complete addressees of such customers.
The AO mentioned that the sale bills produced by the assessee contains various deficiencies regarding buyers order and date, terms of delivery, mode and terms of payment etc. and engine no. and chasis no. of the vehicle are also not mentioned on the bills.
The AO sent such five bills submitted by the assessee to the RTO for verification regarding the registration of the vehicles. However the RTO mentioned that above vehicles have been registered in the said names of the customers.
From above facts, it is apparent that for the amount shown to have been received during the year as ‘advance from customers’, assessee has not been able to establish the identity, creditworthiness of the customers and genuineness of the transactions inspite of repeated opportunities given to the assessee by the AO. In fact assessee has not even submitted the receipt book and cash book for verification of the advance claimed. At the same time, as per the enquiries made from thee RTO, it was found that vehicles claimed to have been sold were not found to have been registered with RTO and the bills of the assessee suffer from various defects.
During appeal, assessee has not been able to shoe that the advances from customers are genuinely advances and it has not been explained as to why the details as required by the AO regarding the identity of the said customers and proof of having received the advance in the form of receipt book and cash book was not submitted to the AO. Obviously the assessee has not been able to discharge onus which lies on him regarding the advances shown in the books of accounts.
The assessee’s claim that AO’s view is that there is deferment of sales is not correct as AO has added the advances from customers claimed to have been received during the year of Rs. 202874955/- due to the inability of the assessee to prove the source of advances as well as sale of the goods against the said advances as is in the contention that GP rate may be applied in respect of above advances is without any basis.
Further the assesee’s claim that in the later assessment year i.e. A.Y. 2011- 12, the AO has held that assessee has indulged in deferment of sales and GP has been applied. In this context, it may be mentioned that findings of the later assessment year which is based on enquiries and evidences gathered during that year can not be applied in the case off assessee in the earlier year. The every assessment year is separate unit for taxation purposes and conclusions have to be drawn based on the facts gathered by the AO in the year concerned. The assessee has submitted a chart claiming the deferment of sales. However no such claim was made before the AO of any such deferment of sales. The quantification made in the said chart is without any supporting evidences. As such the claim regarding the deferment of sales rejected.’’
3.4 During the course of hearing, the ld. AR of the assessee placed following
“1. In the present case, the impugned addition has been made by considering the advances from customers received this year as unexplained credits by comparing the closing balances in the account head Advance from Customers, as on 31.03.09 (AY 09-10) with the opening balances as on 31.03.10 (AY 10 -11). Accordingly, the AO made the addition of the differential amount of Rs. 20,28,74,955/- (though not specified but u/s 68 only) after making certain allegations which have been dealt with individually.
2. Only initial onus to be discharged:
2.1 At the outset it is submitted that the way the impugned addition has been made is a result of the purported misconception and ignorance assumed by the AO.
The law u/s 68 are well settled that it is only initial onus which lay upon the assessee and once, it is discharged the same shifts to the AO. In other words, the assessee is not required to prove the source of the credits till the hilt. Kindly refer CIT vs. First Point Finance Ltd 286 ITR 477 (Raj.) (DPB- 31- 35), holding that once the initial burden has been discharged in respect of the identity of investors, about their existence, and the confirmation from such investors has been obtained, the burden shifts to the Revenue to prove otherwise not only that the invested amount did not belong to the creditors but further it has to prove the said amount belonging to the assessee only.
However, in this case the facts and material available on record clearly prove that the assessee has discharged the initial burden but the AO completely failed to discharge the burden when shifted to him.
2.2.1 The case of the assesse is that it is in the line of automobile trade and acted as a dealer of Maruti Suzuki in Ajmer District where under, as a matter of practice, such advances were received from various customers towards the booking of vehicle and ultimately to whom vehicles were sold. The identity of the creditor (the customer) and the nature and the source both, were evidently available before the AO when the sale bills were raised and ledger accounts containing the details of the receipts (which was in cash and cheque both). The AO clearly admitted that:
“it is noticed that in majority of the cases cash and cheques were received as advance and entry regarding sale of vehicles was also made in the ledger account.” Therefore, the fact behind receipt of such advances was self-explanatory. Trade creditor cannot be treated like cash creditors which being loans are separate (schedule 2) (PB-8).
2.2.2 3 S.68 can be applied w.r.t a particular sum. Receipt by cheque could not be covered u/s
2.2.2 On this aspect direct decision and very relevant in the present context was in the case of Harshila Chordia vs. ITO (2008) 298 ITR 0349 (Raj.) (DPB 1-8).
“Apparently when the Tribunal has found as a fact that the assessee was receiving money from the customers in hands against the payment on delivery of the vehicles on receipt from the dealer the question of such amount standing in the books of account of the assessee would not attract s. 68 because the cash deposits become self-explanatory and such amount was received by the assessee from the customers against which the delivery of the vehicle was made to the customers. The question of sustaining the addition of Rs. 6,98,000 would not arise. Therefore, no addition was required to be made in respect of the amount which was found to be the cash receipts from the customers and against which delivery of vehicle was made to them.(Paras 15 & 16)
2.2.3 Kindly refer CIT Supertech Hospital & Research Centre Ltd. (2007) 211 CTR 360 (Bom) held that:
“ Income-Cash credit-Genuineness-Addition made on the basis that the amount in the name of D was unexplained loan-Assessee has established that it has not taken any loan from D but is liable to pay the impugned amount to D for the project consultancy work done by him-Addition rightly deleted by the Tribunal.”
2.2.4 Also refer CIT vs. Navendram Ahuja (2007) 290 ITR 453 (MP) (DPB- 47-53)
2.2.5 In the case of CIT vs. Jai Kumar Bakliwal(2014) 101 DTR (Raj) 377 / 366 ITR 217 (Raj) it was held that:
“There is no clinching evidence in the present case nor the AO has been able to prove that the money actually belonged to none but the assessee himself. Action of the AO appears to be based on mere suspicion”
2.2.6 In the case of CIT vs. Kulwinder Singh (2018) 99 taxmann.com 449 (P & H) (DPB 62-64) it was held that:
“Section 68 of the Income-tax Act, 1961 – Cash credit (Scope of provision) – Assessment year 2009-10 – Provisions of section 68 are not attracted to amount representing purchases made on credits [In favour of assessee] ”
2.3 During asst. proceedings, the assessee admittedly filed copies of the ledger account and the copies of the invoices in all the cases vide letters dated 12.03.2013 & 15.03.2013 (AO Pg. 5 – middle). Having analyzed the same, the AO recorded a categorical finding of fact in the assessment order that in the cases of 80% customers, there were opening balances coming from the preceding year/s. The assessment for the current year was framed on 28.03.2013 and by that time, assessment for the immediately preceding year i.e. A.Y. 2009-10 was only processed u/s 143(1) accepting the declared income as such. (The scrutiny assessment was made later on vide order dated 30.03.2015 u/s 143(3)/147 of the Act, after passing of the impugned asst. order dated 28.03.2013 of the current year). Thus, the 80% of the customers who continued from the preceding year/s were found genuine and existing in as much as no addition was made in that year (kindly refer AO Pg-10 Last Para) then how suddenly they could be considered unexplained for want of their confirmations, cash receipts, cash book, etc. In any case, such a large number of Creditors-Customers (1449 customers) whose credit balance of advances are under consideration, could not be treated as unexplained. The AO even examined the invoices (AO pg. 8 Last).
2.3.2 Pertinently, during the course of the assessment proceeding for AY 2011-12, the assesse submitted the various supporting evidences being the copy of the temporary registration certificate (TRC), copy of insurance etc. with respect to the particular amount of the advance received in AY 2010-11 but booked as a sale in AY 2011-12 and onwards.
3. All advances adjusted in sales: 3.1 Otherwise, the various allegations raised by the authorities below is nothing but a suspicion over the identity of the customers booking the vehicle and providing advance of 20.28 Cr. and as regards the genuineness of the transaction, the AO and ld. CIT(A) has completely ignored the detailed charts submitted by the assessee, (during assessment proceedings) showing the fact that the advances received in A.Y. 2010-11 were adjusted in sales in 3 different years i.e. A.Y. 2011-12, 2012-13/so on, shown as under:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




