CA Harikrishnan R & CA Maneesha M
Summary: The requirement to obtain a tax audit when business profits are declared below the presumptive taxation rate has undergone significant legislative changes. Under the Income-tax Act, 1961, the earlier Section 44AB(d) imposed an audit requirement on eligible businesses declaring profits below the deemed rate under Section 44AD, provided their total income exceeded the basic exemption limit. The Finance Act, 2016, effective from 1 April 2017, altered this framework by introducing Section 44AB(e), which linked the business audit obligation to the applicability of Section 44AD(4). This provision concerns assessees who previously declared income under the presumptive scheme but subsequently departed from it within the specified five-year period. Consequently, merely reporting profits below the presumptive percentage did not, by itself, attract audit under Section 44AB(e) for an assessee who had never opted for Section 44AD, although other audit provisions could still apply. The supplied article identifies a different framework under the Income-tax Act, 2025, effective from 1 April 2026. It explains that Section 58(3) independently requires maintenance of books and audit where an eligible assessee claims actual profits below the prescribed presumptive computation and total income exceeds the applicable exemption threshold. Separately, Sections 58(7) and 58(8) address the five-year restriction and its audit consequences. The distinction is important for businesses assessing their tax audit obligations under the two legislative regimes.
Mandatory Tax Audit in Cases of Lower Profit Declaration under Section 44AD
A Legislative Journey from the Income-tax Act, 1961 to the Income-tax Act, 2025
- Introduction
- The Original Legislative Position under the Income-tax Act, 1961
- Finance Act, 2016: Change with Effect from 1 April 2017
- Understanding Section 44AD(4)
- The Income-tax Act, 2025: A Separate Lower-Profit Audit Trigger
- Section 58(7) and (8): The Separate Five-Year Audit Trigger
- Comparative Position
- Conclusion: A Material Change in the Legislative Approach
Introduction
Section 44AB of the Income-tax Act, 1961 prescribes the circumstances in which a person carrying on business or profession is required to get accounts audited by an accountant. One of the issues arising under the presumptive taxation scheme is whether an assessee declaring profits below the prescribed presumptive rate is necessarily required to undergo tax audit.
A comparison of the provisions before and after 1 April 2017, followed by an examination of the corresponding provisions in the Income-tax Act, 2025, reveals an important legislative distinction.
The central question is: Did the Finance Act, 2016 narrow the audit trigger for business cases under Section 44AD, and has the Income-tax Act, 2025 introduced a separate lower-profit audit requirement?
The Original Legislative Position under the Income-tax Act, 1961
The presumptive taxation scheme for eligible businesses under Section 44AD was introduced by the Finance Act, 2009 with effect from 1 April 2011.
Before the amendments effective from 1 April 2017, Section 44AB(d) covered a person carrying on business where the profits were deemed under Section 44AD, the assessee claimed lower profits, and the total income exceeded the maximum amount not chargeable to income-tax directly attracted tax audit.
The audit trigger was not dependent on a five-year lock-in consequence.
Relevant provision before The finance Act 2016 reproduced below:
“carrying on the business shall, if the profits and gains from the business are deemed to be the profits and gains of such person under section 44AD and he has claimed such income to be lower than the profits and gains so deemed to be the profits and gains of his business and his income exceeds the maximum amount which is not chargeable to income-tax in any previous year; “
Finance Act, 2016: Change with Effect from 1 April 2017
The Finance Act, 2016 restructured the provisions relating to presumptive taxation and tax audit with effect from 1 April 2017. Section 44ADA was introduced for specified professionals. The earlier Section 44AB(d), which referred to business under Section 44AD, was modified to refer to profession under Section 44ADA. A new Section 44AB(e) was inserted for business cases.
Section 44AB(e) made the audit requirement applicable where the provisions of Section 44AD(4) were applicable and the assessee’s income exceeded the maximum amount not chargeable to income-tax.
Sec 44AD(4) is reproduced below:
“Where an eligible assessee declares profit for any previous year in accordance with the provisions of this section and he declares profit for any of the five assessment years relevant to the previous year succeeding such previous year not in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (1), he shall not be eligible to claim the benefit of the provisions of this section for five assessment years subsequent to the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which the profit has not been declared in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (1).”
This was a material drafting change: the specific audit trigger for business under Section 44AB(e) was linked to Section 44AD(4), rather than being expressed simply as every case of lower profit declaration.
Understanding Section 44AD(4)
Section 44AD(4) applies where an eligible assessee declares profits in accordance with Section 44AD(1) for a previous year and, during any of the five succeeding assessment years, declares profits otherwise than in accordance with Section 44AD(1). In that event, the assessee is not eligible to claim the benefit of Section 44AD for the five assessment years subsequent to the assessment year in which the departure occurs.
An assessee who has never declared profits under Section 44AD(1) would not ordinarily fall within Section 44AD(4) merely because actual profits are lower than the presumptive percentage.
Accordingly, for the period governed by the 1961 Act from 1 April 2017, Section 44AB(e), read with Section 44AD(4), did not by itself impose an audit requirement on every first-time or never-opted assessee declaring lower actual profits.
The Income-tax Act, 2025: A Separate Lower-Profit Audit Trigger
The Income-tax Act, 2025 came into force on 1 April 2026. The corresponding provisions are Section 58 for presumptive taxation, Section 62 for maintenance of books of account and Section 63 for tax audit.
A crucial feature of the new Act is Section 58(3). It provides that an assessee mentioned in column C of the table under Section 58(2), who claims that the profits or gains actually earned are lower than the profits or gains computed in the manner specified in column E of that table, and whose total income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, is required to maintain books and get the accounts audited, with the audit report furnished as required under Section 63.
Sec 63(1) Table Sl n 2 is reproduced below:
“If the person is carrying on business or profession, referred to in section 58(2) or 61(2) (Table: Sl. Nos. 4 and 5) and the profits and gains from such business or profession are claimed to be lower than the deemed profits as referred to in the said sections.”
This is a distinct lower-profit audit trigger. It is not expressed as being conditional upon the application of the five-year restriction in Section 58(7).
Importantly, Section 58(2), Table Sl. No. 1 covers an eligible assessee carrying on a business other than the business specified against Sl. No. 2. This is the ordinary presumptive business category corresponding broadly to the business scheme under Section 44AD. Therefore, where such an assessee claims actual profits lower than the presumptive computation and total income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to tax, Section 58(3) requires books and audit.
Consequently, under the 2025 Act, a person need not have previously opted for presumptive taxation in an earlier tax year for the lower-profit audit requirement in Section 58(3) to apply. The relevant question is whether the person is within the assessee category in Section 58(2), Table Sl. No. 1, claims actual profits below the prescribed computation, and satisfies the total-income condition.
Section 58(7) and (8): The Separate Five-Year Audit Trigger
The Income-tax Act, 2025 also retains the five-year lock-in mechanism. Section 58(7) applies where an eligible assessee declares profits under Section 58(2), Table Sl. No. 1, and in any of the five succeeding tax years declares profits contrary to the presumptive provision. The assessee then loses the benefit of Section 58 for the five subsequent tax years.
Section 58(8) separately requires maintenance of books and audit under Sections 62 and 63 where Section 58(7) applies and total income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to income-tax.
Section 58(7) and (8) is reproduced below:
“(7) Where an eligible assessee declares profit for any tax year as per the provisions of sub-section (2) (Table: Sl. No. 1) and he declares profit for any of the five tax years succeeding such tax year in contravention of the provisions of sub-section (1), then he shall not be eligible to claim the benefit of the provisions of this section for five tax years subsequent to the tax year in which the profit has not been declared as per the provisions of the said sub-section.
(8) Irrespective of anything contained in foregoing provision of this section, where provisions of sub-section (7) are applicable to an eligible assessee and his total income exceeds the maximum amount which is not chargeable to income-tax, he shall be required to keep and maintain such books of account and other documents as required under section 62 and get them audited and furnish a report of such audit as required under section 63.”
Thus, Section 58(3) and Section 58(8) are two distinct provisions: Section 58(3) addresses lower actual profits compared with the presumptive computation, while Section 58(8) addresses the consequences of breaking the five-year presumptive continuity condition.
Comparative Position
| Particulars | Income-tax Act, 1961 | Income-tax Act, 2025 |
|---|---|---|
| Relevant presumptive provision | Section 44AD | Section 58(2), Table Sl. No. 1 |
| Specific lower-profit audit provision | Section 44AB(e), linked to Section 44AD(4) | Section 58(3), read with Section 63 |
| Is prior opting necessary for the lower-profit trigger? | For Section 44AB(e), Section 44AD(4) presupposes an earlier presumptive declaration | No. Section 58(3) is a separate trigger for an assessee covered by Section 58(2) |
| Total-income condition | Exceeds maximum amount not chargeable to tax | Exceeds maximum amount not chargeable to tax |
| Five-year restriction | Section 44AD(4) | Section 58(7) |
| Audit following five-year breach | Section 44AB(e), read with Section 44AD(4) | Section 58(8), read with Sections 62 and 63 |
Conclusion: A Material Change in the Legislative Approach
The legislative journey reveals two different approaches. Under the Income-tax Act, 1961, as amended with effect from 1 April 2017, the specific business audit trigger in Section 44AB(e) was linked to the applicability of Section 44AD(4). This supported the view that a person who had never opted for Section 44AD was not automatically liable to audit under that clause merely because actual profits were below the presumptive rate.
The Income-tax Act, 2025 adopts a different structure. Section 58(3) expressly provides for books and audit where an assessee covered by Section 58(2) claims actual profits lower than the presumptive computation and total income exceeds the maximum amount not chargeable to tax. This trigger is independent of the five-year restriction in Section 58(7).
Accordingly, the apparent relaxation under Section 44AB(e) for never-opted assessees under the 1961 Act should not be carried forward as the position under the 2025 Act. For tax years governed by the new Act, Section 58(3) must be specifically examined even where the assessee has never previously declared income under the presumptive scheme.
The key legislative question, therefore, is whether the 2016 amendment narrowed the audit trigger under the 1961 Act, while the 2025 Act has expressly restored a wider lower-profit audit obligation. The statutory text supports this distinction.



