Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Proportionate Discount on Deep Discount Bonds Deductible Before Maturity: Gujarat HC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19043
Case Name
CIT-III Vs Nirma Industries Ltd. (Gujarat High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

CIT-III Vs Nirma Industries Ltd. (Gujarat High Court)

Summary: The Gujarat High Court, in Commissioner of Income Tax-III Vs Nirma Industries Ltd., dismissed the Revenue’s appeal concerning the disallowance of ₹10,98,52,704 towards interest on Deep Discount Bonds (DDBs) and Optionally Fully Convertible Promissory Notes (OFCPNs) for Assessment Year 2004-05. The Division Bench comprising Justice Bhargav D. Karia and Justice Nirzar S. Desai held that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal was justified in allowing the proportionate deduction of discount or interest expenditure attributable to the relevant accounting year. The Court applied the accrual system of accounting and the matching principle, holding that a contractual liability towards discount or interest could be recognised proportionately over the tenure of the debentures even though the actual payment was required to be made upon maturity or redemption.

The Revenue had challenged the order dated 13 July 2009 passed by the Ahmedabad Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in ITA No. 3946/Ahd/2008. The appeal was admitted under Section 260A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 on the substantial question whether the Tribunal was justified in reversing the order of the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals) and deleting the disallowance of ₹10.98 crore relating to the financial instruments issued by the assessee. The Tribunal had followed its earlier decision concerning Nirma Limited for AY 2002-03, in which a similar controversy regarding deduction of accrued discount on Deep Discount Bonds had been examined.

The earlier proceedings concerned the issuance of two series of secured and redeemable Deep Discount Bonds. In July 2000, the assessee had offered Series A DDBs aggregating to ₹350 crore through private placement for refinancing existing short-term borrowings. Each bond carried an issue price of ₹1,00,000 and a deemed face value of ₹1,50,000, with maturity after three years and six months. The instruments also contained put and call options exercisable after one year and eleven months. Subsequently, in October 2001, the assessee issued Series B DDBs aggregating to ₹100 crore to partly finance its normal corporate expenditure. These bonds carried an issue price of ₹1,00,000 and a deemed face value of ₹1,15,000, with maturity after twenty months. Unlike Series A, Series B did not provide put or call options.

The assessee had repurchased and redeemed 7,500 Series A bonds during October 2001 and claimed interest attributable to the redeemed bonds amounting to ₹6,54,33,173. It also claimed accrued but unpaid interest on outstanding bonds. The total deduction claimed in the earlier assessment proceedings amounted to ₹47,27,05,434, comprising ₹6,54,33,173 relating to redeemed bonds and ₹40,72,70,261 relating to outstanding bonds. The Assessing Officer disallowed ₹40,72,70,261, and the Commissioner (Appeals) sustained the disallowance. These figures formed part of the earlier AY 2002-03 proceedings discussed by the Tribunal and were distinct from the ₹10.98 crore disallowance under consideration for AY 2004-05.

The Revenue’s objections in the earlier proceedings included the contention that the assessee was financially strong and had no commercial necessity to raise funds through DDBs. It was also alleged that the bonds had been issued to entities belonging to the same corporate group, that corresponding interest income had not been offered to tax by the bondholders, and that no liability towards interest accrued before maturity. Further objections concerned Section 193 relating to tax deduction at source, the provisions governing zero-coupon bonds, the alleged capital character of the expenditure and the possibility that the arrangement constituted a tax avoidance device. The Revenue had relied upon McDowell & Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, 154 ITR 148 (SC) in support of its objection concerning tax avoidance.

The Tribunal examined the matter from both accounting and statutory perspectives. It observed that under the mercantile system of accounting, revenue and expenditure must be recognised in the accounting periods to which they relate rather than merely when money is received or paid. The matching principle requires expenditure incurred for generating business benefits over multiple accounting periods to be allocated appropriately so that the profits of each period are correctly determined. The Tribunal referred to the principles of accrual accounting, the accounting standards notified under Section 145(2), and the requirement under Section 28 to determine the real profits of the business.

Applying these principles, the Tribunal held that the liability towards discount or interest arose when the bonds were issued because the issuer became contractually bound to pay the difference between the issue price and the redemption value. Although the liability was payable at maturity, the borrowing provided benefits throughout the tenure of the instruments. Consequently, the expenditure was attributable to the period during which the borrowed funds were used in the business. The Tribunal considered that the proportionate discount was deductible under the relevant provisions, including Section 36(1)(iii), since the borrowed capital had been utilised for business purposes and the corresponding interest liability related to the relevant accounting year.

A central precedent was the Supreme Court’s decision in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax, (1997) 225 ITR 802 (SC). In that case, the Supreme Court had considered debentures issued at a discount and held that the discount represented expenditure incurred for obtaining business funds. Where the expenditure secured a continuing benefit over the tenure of the debentures, proportionate deduction over the relevant years was permissible. The Gujarat High Court found that the factual circumstances considered by the Tribunal were substantially similar to those examined in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation. The Court therefore accepted the Tribunal’s application of the matching principle to the discount liability.

The High Court also considered Taparia Tools Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax, (2015) 372 ITR 605 (SC). That decision distinguished between expenditure actually incurred and claimed in full in the year of payment and expenditure which the assessee itself sought to spread over subsequent years. The Supreme Court had explained that ordinarily revenue expenditure is deductible in the year in which it is incurred, while spreading expenditure over multiple years may be permissible where the facts justify application of the matching principle. The High Court considered the distinction relevant because the Nirma Industries controversy concerned a claim for proportionate discount attributable to the relevant accounting year rather than a claim to deduct the entire upfront payment in one year.

The Gujarat High Court noted that the findings of the Tribunal regarding the contractual nature of the liability, the absence of discretion concerning payment, the utilisation of borrowed funds and the allocation of expenditure over the tenure of the bonds had not been displaced. The liability had arisen when the bonds were issued, although its discharge was deferred until maturity. Since the benefit of the borrowing extended over several years, the assessee was justified in claiming the corresponding expenditure on a proportionate basis. The Court specifically observed that actual payment at the time of maturity or redemption was not decisive under the accrual system of accounting.

The High Court concluded that the Tribunal had correctly applied the principles laid down in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. and had not committed any legal error in allowing the proportionate deduction. The Court held that expenditure relating to a particular accounting year should be allocated to that year to avoid distortion of business profits. Accordingly, the substantial question of law was answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue, and Tax Appeal No. 209 of 2010 was dismissed. The ruling recognises the deductibility of proportionate discount on Deep Discount Bonds where a binding liability has arisen, the borrowing serves business purposes and the expenditure is properly attributable to the relevant accounting period.

Cases Discussed

1. McDowell & Co. Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer (Supreme Court); (1985) 154 ITR 148 (SC). Cited in the earlier assessment proceedings in support of the Revenue’s allegation that the issuance of Deep Discount Bonds constituted a tax avoidance arrangement. The Tribunal did not accept that objection as sufficient to deny the deduction where the applicable statutory conditions were satisfied.

2. India Cements Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Supreme Court); (1966) 60 ITR 52 (SC). Discussed in the Supreme Court extract reproduced in the judgment. The decision recognises that expenditure incurred for obtaining a business loan may constitute revenue expenditure rather than capital expenditure.

3. Kedarnath Jute Manufacturing Co. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Supreme Court); (1971) 82 ITR 363 (SC). Referred to in relation to the determination of real business profits and the principle that accounting entries are not conclusive of the treatment required under the Income-tax Act.

4. Madeva Upendra Sinai v. Union of India (Supreme Court); (1975) 98 ITR 209 (SC); AY. Cited in the Tribunal’s discussion concerning the determination of taxable business profits according to recognised principles of commercial accounting.

5. Hindustan Aluminium Corporation Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Calcutta High Court); (1983) 144 ITR 474. Discussed within the reproduced Supreme Court judgment concerning the permissibility of spreading expenditure over multiple years where the expenditure provides continuing business benefits.

6. M.P. Financial Corporation v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Madhya Pradesh High Court); Citation referred to as 1986 Tax LR 171. Mentioned in the Supreme Court’s discussion of the allocation of discount on debentures over their tenure.

7. Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. v. Commissioner of Income Tax (Supreme Court); (1997) 225 ITR 802 (SC). Principal precedent relied upon for allowing proportionate deduction of discount on debentures. The Supreme Court recognised that discount payable upon redemption constitutes expenditure and that allocation over the debenture period may be justified where the borrowing provides continuing benefits.

8. Taparia Tools Ltd. v. Joint Commissioner of Income Tax (Supreme Court); (2015) 372 ITR 605 (SC) Discussed by the Gujarat High Court in relation to the timing of deduction of interest expenditure. The decision distinguishes the ordinary rule allowing expenditure in the year incurred from cases where an assessee seeks to spread expenditure over subsequent years under the matching principle.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF GUJARAT HIGH COURT

1. Heard learned Senior Standing Counsel Mr. Aaditya D Bhatt for the appellant and learned Senior Advocate Mr. S.N. Soparkar with learned advocate Mr. B.S. Soparkar for the respondent.

2. This Tax Appeal is filed by the Revenue under section 260A of the Income Tax Act, 1961 (For short “the Act”) against the judgment and order dated 13.07.2009 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, “A” Bench, Ahmedabad (For short “the Tribunal”) in ITA No. 3946/Ahd/2008 for Assessment Year 2004-2005. Tax Appeal was admitted by this Court vide order dated 04.07.2011 raising the following substantial question of law:

“Whether the Appellate Tribunal is right in law and on facts in reversing the order passed by CIT(Appeals) and thereby deleting the disallowance of interest of Rs.10,98,52,704/- on various DDBs/OFCPNs issued by the appellant company?”

3. The Tribunal while allowing the appeal of the assessee followed its order passed for Assessment Year 2002-2003 in case of Nirma Limited. Therefore, it would be necessary to refer to the facts of Nirma Limited for Assessment Year 2002-2003 where similar disallowance being interest relating to Deep Discount Bonds was deleted by the CIT(Appeals) and upheld by the Tribunal. The facts recorded in case of Nirma Limited for Assessment Year 2002-2003 in ITA No. 1245/Ahd/2006 as recorded by the Tribunal in the impugned judgment and order are as under:

“5. In July 2000, the assessee-company had offered, by way of private placement, secured and redeemable Deep Discount Bonds (DDB Series “A”) aggregating to Rs.350 crores to refinance the existing short-term debt of the assessee-company. Deemed face value and issue price per bond were Rs.1,50,000 each and Rs. 1,00,000 each respectively. They were to mature at their deemed face value after three years and six months from the deemed date of their allotment (i.e., 28.07,2000). It was stipulated that the investors would have the option to “Put” the instrument at the end of one year eleven months from the deemed date of allotment. The assessee-company also had the option to “Call” the instrument at the end of one year eleven months from the deemed date of allotment. The Bonds were listed on Wholesale Debt Market segment of the National Stock Exchange w.e.f. 20.09.2001. Relevant clause dealing with the payment of interest as contained in the Information Memorandum relating to DDBs of “A” Series is available at page 126 of the paper-book filed by the assessee before us which reads as under:

“There will be no interest during the currency of the Bonds. The par value of each Bond, i.e., Rs.1,50,000/- will be payable on maturity or the Deemed Face Value of Rs.1,25,000/- will be payable in case the company exercises the Call Option.

No interest shall accrue on the Bond after the date of the maturity or in case the company exercises the Call option, after the exercise date of the call.”

6. In October 2001 also, the assessee-company offered, by way of private placement, secured and redeemable Deep Discount Bonds (DDB Series “B”) aggregating to Rs.100 crores to part finance the normal corporate expenditure of the company. Deemed face value and issue price per bond were Rs.1,15,000 and Rs. 1,00,000 respectively. They were to mature at their deemed face value after twenty months from the deemed date of their allotment (i.e., 08.10.2001). Unlike DDB – Series “A”, there was no provision in the Information Memorandum for DDB – Series “B” for exercise of “Put/Call” option either by the investors or by the assessee-company.

7. The assessee-company repurchased 7500 DDBs of series “A” on 1.10.2001 @ Rs.1,17,000 per bond and redeemed them on 4.10.2001. The amount of interest allocated by the assessee to the redeemed DDBs, as aforesaid, works out to Rs.6,54,33,173/-. The remaining DDBs of both the series were not redeemed. The assessee sought deduction amounting to Rs.47,27,05,434/- on account of accrued interest relating to DDBs of both the series out of which Rs.6,54,33,173/- relating to redeemed portion of DDBs of “A” Series was claimed as interest accrued and paid while the balance amount of Rs.40,72,70,261/- (Rs. 36,41,30,778 + Rs.4,31,39,483 relating to outstanding DDBs of Series “A” and “B” respectively) was claimed as interest accrued but not paid in respect of outstanding DDBs of both the series. Out of total claim of Rs.47,27,05,434/-, the AO however disallowed the claim of Rs.40,72,70,261/- alone in the original assessment order, which was subsequently confirmed by the learned CIT(A) for the reasons stated at pp.27-35 of his appellate order, which, in brief, are:

(i) The assessee was a cash rich company and hence there was no need to issue the DDBs for raising the funds and that there was no need of funds at the time of issue of DDBs;

(ii) The DDBs were issued to various entities of the Group;

(iii) Interest was claimed as deduction on accrual basis in the hands of the assessee while corresponding interest was not shown as interest receipts in the hands of the holders of DDBs;

(iv) The liability to pay interest arose only at the end of the maturity period and hence there was no accrual of liability towards interest on DDBs;

(v) Since the assessee did not deduct the tax at source in terms of section 193, it could not be allowed to claim deduction on account of interest liability;

(vi) Insertion of Clause (iiia) in section 36 made it abundantly clear that “pro-rata discount” could be allowed in respect of Zero Coupon Bonds alone issued by an infrastructure capital company or infrastructure capital fund or public sector company after 1.6.2005 and therefore such a concession could not be extended in respect of earlier assessment years and that too to the assessee-company which was neither an infrastructure company nor a public sector company;

(vii) The device adopted by the assessee was a tax avoidance device and therefore such device was to be ignored in view of the decision in McDowell’s case, 154 ITR 148 (SC); and

(viii) The impugned expenditure was capital in nature.

8. Aggrieved by the order of the learned CIT(A), the assessee is now in appeal before this Tribunal. At the time of hearing, the learned counsel for the assessee invited our attention to the factual aspects of the case as also to the clauses in the Information Memorandum governing payment of interest relating to DDBs of both the series. We have already narrated them earlier in this Order. He also took us through various findings recorded and the reasons given in the assessment order and the appellate order for making and sustaining the impugned disallowance. He also took us thought the submissions made by the assessee in support of its case before the learned CIT(A) and relied upon them in support of his case.

4. After considering the submissions made by both the sides, the Tribunal upheld the order passed by CIT(Appeals) observing as under:

16. We have carefully considered the rival submissions. The short issue is whether the amount of difference between the issue price and par value/deemed face value of DDBs, which has been treated as interest by the assessee as well as by the Department, is liable to be allowed. The case of the Department for making the impugned disallowance is that the expenditure has not accrued in the year under appeal and that it would accrue only at the time of maturity of the DDBs. The case of the asessee, on the other hand, is that the impugned expenditure deserves to be allowed on proportionate basis in the year under appeal for the reason that it not only relates to the year under appeal but has also been incurred in the year under appeal for the purposes of the business and therefore it should be allowed as deduction. Let us consider the issue first from the accounting point of view and then from the legal point of view.

17. It is not at all in dispute that the assessee maintains its accounts on accrual basis; rather the Companies Act mandates the assessee to do so. Accrual basis of accounting (also referred to as mercantile basis) is the method of recording transactions by which revenues, costs, assets and liabilities are recognised in the accounts in the period in which they accrue, i.e., when transactions occur rather than when they are settled by receipt or payment in cash. This results in matching the accomplishments (i.e., revenues) with the efforts (i.e., costs) in a given period. Therefore, two essential features of accrual basis of accounting are: (a) Revenues are recognized as they are earned; and (b) For determining the periodic income, costs are matched against revenues so recognised or against the time period to which they relate. The matching concept is thus an integral part of accrual accounting. In fact, they are often used interchangeably. The matching concept requires proper allocation of costs into appropriate periods so that relevant incomes and expenses are matched to work out the correct profits in a given accounting period. This view is well fortified by the judgment in Taparia Tools Ltd., 260 ITR 102, 116 (Bom.) in which the Hon’ble High Court has explained the matching concept thus:

“…Therefore, under the mercantile system of accounting, in order to determine the net income of an accounting year, the revenue and other incomes are matched with the cost of resources consumed (expenses). Under the mercantile system of accounting, this matching is required to be done on accrual basis. Under this matching concept, revenue and income earned during an accounting period irrespective of actual cash in-flow is to be compared with expenses incurred during the same period irrespective of actual out-flow of cash.”

18. Pursuant to the provisions of section 145(2), the Central Government has notified Accounting Standards to be followed for income-tax purposes. According to Paragraph 6(b) of the aforesaid Notification, “Accrual” refers to the “assumption that revenues and costs are accrued, that is, recognized as they are earned or incurred (and not as money is received or paid) and recorded in the financial statements of the period to which they relate.” The aforesaid definition has now statutory force and therefore has to be followed. According to the said definition, two conditions must be satisfied to constitute “Accrual”. They are: (i) the revenues and costs are required tis he recognized as they are earned or incurred (and not as money is received or paid); and (ii) the revenues and costs so recognized must be recorded in the financial statements of the periods to which they relate. Thus mere incurrence of liability or cost is not sufficient. The incurrence of liability/cost should be recognized and recorded in the financial statements of the periods to which they relate. The thrust of the aforesaid definition is also on the determination of periodic revenues and costs in order to correctly work out the profits in a given accounting period for income tax purposes.

19. The focus of accounting principles and practices as well as the income-tax law is to ensure that only correct or real profits are worked out in a given accounting period, i.e., previous year and brought to tax. In other words, both the revenues and costs must match and relate to the accounting period. Section 28 of the Income-tax Act also seeks to achieve the same object. Section 28 taxes the profits and gains of the business or profession of the previous year, e.g., accounting period which, in substance, requires matching the accomplishments (i.e., revenues) with efforts/costs/expenses incurred) in a given accounting period. Both the revenues as well as costs/expenses relating to a particular year must be accounted for in that year itself to arrive at the correct or real profits. There is a plethora of authorities, e.g., Kedarnath Jute Manufacturing Co. Ltd. v. CIT, 82 ITR 363 (SC) and Madeva Upendra Sinai v. Union of India, 98 ITR 209 (SC), etc., for the proposition that the profits assessable under section 28 must be real profits to be ascertained on ordinary principles of trading and commercial accounting. If the assessee is under a liability or liability has been incurred in relation to a given period or is bound to make a certain payment from the gross profits, the profits and gains can only be the net amount after the said liability or amount is deducted from the gross profits or receipts.

20. It is evident on bare perusal of the Information Memorandum of both the series of DDBs that the liability towards discount or interest was incurred in that very year in which the DDBs were issued. The assessee was contractually bound to discharge it at the time of maturity of DDBs. The assessee had no element of discretion in this behalf. By issuing the debentures at a discount, the assessee-company incurred the liability in the year of issue of debentures to pay the discount at the time of maturity but such payment was to secure the benefit over a number of years. And therefore such liability was not to be allowed in its entirety in the year of issue of DDBs as the entire liability did not relate to that year. Here comes the relevance of matching principle.

20. (Continued) Since there was a continuing benefit to the business of the assessee over the entire period, the liability was required to be spread over the entire period of the DDBs. Besides, there is no dispute that the funds borrowed through DDBs were used for the purposes of the business in the year under appeal and hence the expenses, e.g., discount/interest, etc., relating thereto would deserve to be accounted for in and allocated to the year under appeal on pro-rata basis. Tested on the aforesaid principles, the assessee is entitled to succeed in its claim as the discount/interest worked out on proportionate basis not only related to the accounting period under appeal but was also incurred to achieve the accomplishments, i.e., the profits of the year under appeal. The mere fact that the impugned liability was to be discharged at the time of maturity/redemption of DDBs will not defeat the claim of the assessee as the factum of actual payment is irrelevant in deciding upon the claim under the accrual system of accounting

21. Now let us turn to the specific provisions of law governing the claim. The focus of Section 37 of the Income-tax Act is to allow deduction in respect of any expenditure not being (i) expenditure of the nature described in sections 30 to 36 (ii) personal expenditure or (iii) capital expenditure laid out or expended wholly and exclusively for the purposes of the business. It is well-established principle of law that the claim of the assessee is liable to be allowed if it satisfies all the ingredients of the section which allows the deduction. The judgment in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation, 225 ITR 802 (SC) comprehensively examines all the aforesaid aspects of the case and lays down the principles governing such claims. In that case, the assessee had issued debentures at a discount on 10th December 1966, redeemable after 12 years. The issue price of debenture of Rs.100/- was Rs.98. The total amount of discount on the entire issue was Rs.3 lakhs while the pro-rata discount, i.e., the proportionate amount of discount for the period of six months ending with June 30, 1967 was Rs.12,500/-, taking the period of 12 years which was the period of redemption and dividing the total amount of discount by 12 years. Relevant propositions laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the aforesaid judgment can be summed up as under:

(i) When a company issues debentures at a discount, it incurs a liability to pay a larger amount than what it has borrowed, at a future date. The liability to pay the discounted amount over and above the amount received for the debentures is a liability which has been incurred by the company for the purposes of its business in order to generate funds for its business activities. The amounts so obtained by issue of debentures are used by the company for the purposes of its business. This would therefore be expenditure.

(ii) The Hon’ble Supreme Court cited, with approval, the observations made in India Cements Ltd., 60 ITR 52 (SC), that (a) the loan obtained is not an asset or advantage of an enduring nature; (b) the expenditure was made for securing the use of money for a certain period; and (c) it is irrelevant to consider the object with which the loan was obtained.

(iii) By issuing the debentures at a discount, the assessee incurs the liability to pay the discount in the year of issue of debentures but such payme is to secure a benefit over a number of years. Since there is a continuing benefit to the business of the assessee over the entire period, the liability should be spread over the period of the debentures.

22. The factual matrix of the case before us is almost identical with the one in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation Ltd. (supra). In this view of the matter, the law as laid down in the aforesaid judgment would squarely cover the issue involved in the case before us as well. In the case before us, the assessee has issued DDBs at a price lower than their par value/deemed face value, i.e., the value at which they were required to be redeemed upon expiry of redemption period. The liability towards proportionate discount incurred by the assessee was a liability not only in praesen although it was payable in future but also related to the accounting period under appeal. Besides, it was not only quantifiable but was also actually quantified by the assessee, which has not been disputed by the Department. The matching principle of accounting also requires that the expenditure relatable to a particular year must be allocated to that year otherwise it would lead to distortion in profits. The assessee is therefore entitled to the deduction of proportionate amount of discount in the year under appeal in terms of the principles laid down in the aforesaid judgment and for the reasons aforesaid.

23. Section 36(1)(iii) deals with the deductibility of interest on capital borrowed for the purposes of the business. The only condition required to be satisfied for claiming the deduction u/s 36(1)(iii) is that the claim of interest should be with reference to the capital borrowed for the purposes of the business. As already stated earlier, there is not even an allegation by the Department that the capital was not borrowed for the purposes of the business. Therefore the claim of the assessee, which remans uncontroverted by the Department, that the capital was borrowed for the purposes of the business has to be accepted and is accordingly accepted. Since the liability incurred by the assessee towards interest is with reference to the borrowed capital utilized for the purposes of its business in the year under appeal and also that it relates to the year under appeal, the assessee, in our view, is entitled to succeed in its claim for deduction on pro-rata basis. We hold accordingly.

The AO and the learned CIT(A) have made various other observations in their respective orders for denying the deduction claimed by the assessee. These are:

(i) The assessee-company is a cash-rich company;

(ii) There was no need to raise the funds through DDBs;

(iii) The investors in the DDBs belong to the same group to which the assessee belongs;

(iv) The investors in DDBs have not offered corresponding income to tax in their respective hands;

(v) Since the assessee did not deduct the tax at source in terms of section 193, it could not be allowed to claim deduction on account of interest liability;

(vi) Insertion of Clause (iiia) in section 36 made it abundantly clear that “pro-rata discount” could be allowed in respect of Zero Coupon Bonds alone issued by an infrastructure capital company or infrastructure capital fund or public sector company after 1.6.2005 and therefore such a concession could not be extended in respect of earlier assessment years and that too to the assessee-company which was neither an infrastructure company nor a public sector company;

(vii) The device adopted by the assessee was a tax avoidance device and therefore such device was to be ignored.

25. It is submitted on behalf of the assessee that all the aforesaid observations have no direct bearing on the issue and therefore are not relevant in deciding upon the claim of the assessee under section 36(1)(iii)/37 of the Income-tax. We are in agreement with the aforesaid submissions. In our view, the assessee is entitled to succeed in its claim for deduction under section 36(1)(iii)/37 so long as he fulfils all the conditions prescribed therein. We have already held earlier that the assessee not only satisfies all the conditions stipulated by the aforesaid provisions but also that the case of the assessee is covered by the principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Madras Industrial Investment Corporation (supra).

26. Having held that the assessee is entitled to proportionately claim the expenditure towards discount/interest on the DDBs on accrual basis in the year under appeal, we direct the AO to correctly work out the amount of deduction to the extent it relates to the year under appeal. In view of the foregoing, ground no.3 taken by the assessee is allowed subject to the aforesaid observations.”

7. In view of above dictum of law and considering the findings of fact arrived at by the Tribunal, it is not in dispute that both the series of Deep Discount Bonds stipulates that liability towards discount or interest was incurred in the very year in which such bonds were issued and the assessee was bound to discharge it at the time of maturity as per the contract. It is also not in dispute that the assessee had no element of discretion and the liability was incurred in the year of issue of debentures to pay the discount/interest at the time of maturity but such payment was to secure the benefit over a number of years. Therefore, such liability was rightly claimed by the assessee by spreading over the entire period of debentures by applying the matching principle relating to the year under appeal on pro-rata basis. Accordingly, the Tribunal has allowed the appeal of the assessee by allowing the claim of discount/interest worked out on proportionate basis. Therefore, merely because the liability was to be discharged at the time of maturity/redemption of the debentures would not defeat the claim of the assessee as the factum of actual payment is irrelevant in deciding upon the claim under the accrual system of accounting.

8. The Tribunal for the year under consideration has followed its findings given for the Assessment year 2002-2003 wherein in similar facts, the Tribunal has applied the decision in case of Taparia Tools Ltd. (supra) which is reversed by the Hon’ble Apex Court in facts of the said case but in view of the decision of Apex Court in case of Madras Industrial Investment Corpn. Ltd.(supra), the Tribunal was justified in holding that the factual matrix of the case is almost identical with one in case of Madras Industrial Investment Corpn. Ltd. and as per the law laid down in the said decision, the liability towards proportionate discount incurred by the assessee was a liability not only in present although it was payable in future but also related to accounting period under consideration and was quantified by the assessee. The Tribunal therefore, followed the matching principle of accounting which requires that any expenditure relatable to a particular year must be allocated to that year otherwise it would lead to distortion in profits and therefore, held that the assessee was entitled to deduction of proportionate amount of discount in the year under appeal.

9. In view of above facts, we are of the opinion that there is no legal infirmity in the impugned decision of the Tribunal and the question of law is therefore answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue.

10. Tax Appeal is accordingly dismissed.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,696

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.