Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah Vs Kamal Dayani & Ors. (Supreme Court of India)
Summary : The Supreme Court, comprising Justices B.R. Gavai and Sandeep Mehta, held a Surat police inspector and an Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate guilty of contempt for seeking and granting police custody remand despite its subsisting interim anticipatory bail order. The judgment dated 7 August 2024 was delivered in Contempt Petition (Civil), Diary No. 1106 of 2024, in SLP (Criminal) No. 14489 of 2023, together with SLP (Criminal) Nos. 537 and 1116 of 2024. The petition invoked Section 12 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 and Article 129 of the Constitution.
The dispute arose from FIR No. 11210068230266 dated 21 July 2023 at Vesu Police Station, Surat. The complainant alleged that Shah had received ₹1.65 crore in cash under an oral agreement for the sale of 15 shops and had failed to deliver possession. The Sessions Court and the Gujarat High Court refused anticipatory bail. On 8 December 2023, the Supreme Court directed that Shah be released in the event of arrest on a personal bond of ₹25,000 with one or more sureties in the like amount. It required him to cooperate and report to the investigating officer whenever directed.
Shah appeared at the police station with the order on 11 December 2023. Inspector R.Y. Raval arrested him and released him on the required bonds. The officer served a notice under Section 41A CrPC for further questioning and subsequently served a notice dated 12 December requiring Shah to appear before the Magistrate for remand. On 13 December, the inspector sought seven days of police custody. Shah’s counsel produced the Supreme Court order and objected. The 6th Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Deepaben Sanjaykumar Thakar, read the order as leaving remand open and granted police custody until 16 December.
When produced on 16 December, Shah alleged that he had been beaten and pressured in custody to settle the property dispute. The Magistrate questioned him, personally examined his feet and recorded that she saw no signs of beating. She entertained a regular bail application under Section 437 CrPC and required fresh bonds, although Shah had already furnished bonds under the Supreme Court’s order. Regular bail was granted on 16 December and Shah was released on 18 December. The Supreme Court found that no order authorised his detention for nearly 48 hours after the remand expired.
After his release, Shah complained to the Commissioner of Police and sought preservation of the station’s CCTV footage. He then filed a private complaint against police personnel and the original complainant. The duty Magistrate took cognizance, found that the alleged acts fell outside official duties for purposes of sanction under Section 197 CrPC and posted the matter for verification. The 6th ACJM dismissed the complaint on 6 January 2024 without recording the complainant’s and witnesses’ statements. On 22 February 2024, the Gujarat High Court set aside that dismissal in Criminal Revision Application No. 273 of 2024 and directed the Magistrate to record the witnesses’ statements before deciding whether sufficient grounds existed to proceed.
Shah argued that the interim order was unequivocal and that the remand and continued detention wilfully defeated it. The investigating officer claimed that Shah had given evasive replies and that custody was necessary to recover incriminating evidence. The Magistrate attributed the remand to a bona fide interpretation of the order. Submissions on behalf of the Gujarat High Court and the State authorities pointed to a local practice, based on Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari v. State of Gujarat, of permitting investigating officers to seek police custody even after anticipatory bail. The officer and Magistrate tendered unconditional apologies.
The Supreme Court held that the order of 8 December required Shah’s release upon arrest and remained operative until modified or the SLP was finally decided. The cooperation condition allowed the investigation to continue. If the officer genuinely considered custody necessary, he had to seek directions from the Supreme Court. Applying Ashok Kumar v. Union Territory of Chandigarh, the Court also noted that the State must substantiate a request for custodial interrogation with reasons beyond a bare assertion of necessity.
The Court examined the remand application against the investigation record. Shah had attended when called and had been questioned for only a few hours on 12 December. The notice for remand did not indicate non-cooperation. The Court found that the allegation of non-cooperation used to support the application was fabricated. It also explained that an accused’s police confession is inadmissible under Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, and referred to Sanuj Bansal on keeping such confessions in interrogation notes out of the charge sheet. No information leading to discovery under Section 27 was identified, and criminal antecedents could be checked through the Crime and Criminal Tracking Network System.
The Court also found that the remand application reversed the FIR’s account of the cheques. The FIR said the complainant had given Shah cheques of about ₹54 lakh, whereas the remand application stated that Shah had signed cheques for the complainant and that these had to be recovered. The Court said the police should have demanded strict proof of the alleged cash payment and examined it in light of the Income-tax Act, 1961 and the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. It found that the officer relied on the unverified allegation to give a dispute over an oral property agreement the appearance of a criminal case.
The Court rejected the Magistrate’s explanation of a bona fide misunderstanding. Shah’s counsel had specifically objected to remand by relying on the Supreme Court’s order. Requiring a fresh regular bail application and another set of bonds after remand compounded the breach. The Court also said that a complaint of custodial torture called for a medical examination under Section 54 CrPC. It treated the handling of the complaint and the failure to follow Sections 200 and 202 CrPC as indications of bias in the Magistrate’s conduct.
On CCTV compliance, the Court referred to Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh. The authorities attributed the missing footage to a recording-equipment problem. The record also showed that the interrogation room itself lacked a camera. The Court left those shortcomings to departmental consideration and held that the Commissioner of Police and Deputy Commissioner of Police could not be held in contempt of the bail order on that basis. The judgment’s operative findings concern disobedience of the bail order, while the allegations of custodial torture were the subject of the separate complaint.
Examining Section 438 CrPC and its counterpart, Section 482 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, the Court explained that a court granting anticipatory bail may impose suitable conditions or limit its duration where the facts warrant it. The Constitution Bench ruling in Sushila Aggarwal v. State (NCT of Delhi) permits continued investigation and allows the investigating agency to approach the court for appropriate relief. The Supreme Court held that a routine clause giving blanket permission to seek police custody frustrates the protection granted by anticipatory bail and declared the Gujarat High Court’s decision in Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari impliedly overruled. It also cited P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement for the care required in exercising pre-arrest bail jurisdiction.
The Supreme Court held Inspector R.Y. Raval and 6th ACJM Deepaben Sanjaykumar Thakar guilty of contempt of its 8 December order. It discharged the notices against Commissioner Ajay Kumar Tomar, Deputy Commissioner Vijaysinh Gurjar and complainant Abhishek Vinodkumar Goswami. The judgment recorded the findings of guilt without fixing a sentence.
In the three connected SLPs, the Court made absolute the interim anticipatory bail orders dated 8 December 2023, 11 January 2024 and 23 January 2024, respectively. The protection continues until the culmination of proceedings arising from the FIR dated 21 July 2023. The Court disposed of the special leave petitions and pending applications.
Cases Discussed
- SLP (Criminal) No. 10536 of 2023, order dated 12 July 2024 (Supreme Court) — Sanuj Bansal v. State of Uttar Pradesh & Anr. The Court cited this order on excluding police confessions recorded in interrogation notes from a charge sheet.
- 2024 SCC OnLine SC 274 — Ashok Kumar v. Union Territory of Chandigarh (Supreme Court). A bare assertion of the need for custodial interrogation is insufficient.
- R/Criminal Revision Application No. 273 of 2024, order dated 22 February 2024 (Gujarat High Court) — Tusharbhai Rajnikantbhai Shah v. State of Gujarat. The High Court set aside the dismissal of the separate private complaint and directed the recording of witness statements.
- (2022) 10 SCC 51 — Satender Kumar Antil v. Central Bureau of Investigation & Anr. (Supreme Court). The remand order reproduced in the judgment referred to this decision when discussing the permissible limits on police custody.
- (2021) 1 SCC 184 — Paramvir Singh Saini v. Baljit Singh & Ors. (Supreme Court). The Court examined compliance with the directions on functional CCTV coverage at police stations.
- (2020) 5 SCC 1 — Sushila Aggarwal & Ors. v. State (NCT of Delhi) & Anr. (Supreme Court, Constitution Bench). This decision governed the duration and permissible conditions of anticipatory bail and informed the rejection of Gujarat’s routine remand clause.
- (2019) 9 SCC 24 — P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement (Supreme Court). The Court cited it for the circumspect exercise of anticipatory bail jurisdiction.
- 2014 SCC OnLine Guj 14451 — Sunilbhai Sudhirbhai Kothari v. State of Gujarat (Gujarat High Court, Division Bench). The Supreme Court held that it stood impliedly overruled by the Constitution Bench ruling in Sushila Aggarwal.
- (2011) 5 SCC 244 — Rekha v. State of Tamil Nadu through Secretary to Government & Anr. (Supreme Court). The Court cited it on the importance of personal liberty under Article 21.
- (2011) 1 SCC 694 — Siddharam Satlingappa Mhetre v. State of Maharashtra & Ors. (Supreme Court). Shah relied on this decision in opposing remand, and the Gujarat High Court’s counsel addressed the effect of the later Constitution Bench ruling on its observations about bail duration.
Alternative SEO Titles
1. Police Remand Despite Unmodified Anticipatory Bail Amounts to Contempt: Supreme Court
2. Routine Conditions Allowing Police Remand After Anticipatory Bail Are Invalid: Supreme Court
3. Police Must Seek Supreme Court Directions Before Remand Under Its Subsisting Bail Order
4. Fresh Bail Bonds After Remand Defied Subsisting Anticipatory Bail Order: Supreme Court
5. Supreme Court Confirms Anticipatory Bail After Finding Inspector and Magistrate Guilty of Contempt





