Sagarmal Mall Vs DCIT (ITAT Kolkata)
Assessment by DCIT Invalid Where Returned Income Placed the Case Within ITO’s Pecuniary Jurisdiction
Background
The assessee challenged a scrutiny assessment on the ground that it had been completed by an officer who lacked pecuniary jurisdiction under CBDT Instruction No. 1/2011 dated 31 January 2011.
The assessment order was passed by the DCIT, Circle-32, Kolkata. However, the assessee’s returned income for AY 2013-14 was ₹19,80,100, placing the case within the monetary limit assigned to an Income Tax Officer for non-corporate assessees in metropolitan charges.
Before examining the jurisdictional issue, the Tribunal condoned a 16-day delay in filing the appeal, after considering the assessee’s affidavit.
Incorrect Income Figure in the Assessment Order
The assessment order recorded that the assessee had filed a return on 9 October 2010, declaring income of ₹89,00,420. The assessee produced the acknowledgement for AY 2013-14 to demonstrate that the actual returned income was ₹19,80,100.
The Tribunal accepted the acknowledgement. It noted that the date and income recorded in the assessment order did not correspond with the assessment year under consideration and treated the recital as a mistake.
This factual correction was decisive because the jurisdictional allocation depended on the income declared in the relevant return, rather than the erroneous figure appearing in the assessment order.
CBDT’s Allocation of Pecuniary Jurisdiction
The Tribunal examined CBDT Instruction No. 1/2011, which allocated cases between ITOs and ACITs/DCITs according to returned income, the category of assessee and the location of the charge.
For non-corporate returns in metropolitan cities, including Kolkata, cases with declared income up to ₹20 lakh were assigned to ITOs. Cases above that limit were assigned to ACITs/DCITs.
Since the assessee’s returned income was ₹19,80,100, the Tribunal held that the DCIT did not possess jurisdiction to complete the assessment in the circumstances before it.
Although one paragraph of the order refers to “corporate returns”, the appellant is an individual, and the ₹20 lakh metropolitan threshold applicable to non-corporate returns corresponds with the instruction reproduced in the order.
Jurisdictional Ground Entertained Before the Tribunal
The Revenue objected that the assessee had not raised this issue before the lower authorities.
The Tribunal nevertheless took up the ground first because it was a legal challenge to the very jurisdiction of the officer passing the assessment order. The relevant returned-income figure was established through the return acknowledgement.
The decision therefore recognises that, in the circumstances considered, the absence of an earlier objection did not prevent examination of the alleged inherent jurisdictional defect.
Reliance on Coordinate Bench and High Court Decisions
The Tribunal relied on R A Realtors Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO, ITA No. 2275/Kol/2025, dated 19 January 2026, which had discussed the decision in Raghvendra Mohta v. ACIT, ITA No. 2416/KOL/2017.
In Raghvendra Mohta, the Tribunal held that an ACIT could not assume jurisdiction over a case assigned to an ITO under the CBDT’s monetary allocation merely because the ACIT was a higher-ranking officer.
The reasoning examined section 120, under which income-tax authorities exercise their powers according to the relevant directions and assignments. A higher rank does not automatically establish jurisdiction over every case allocated to a lower-ranking authority.
The present order also reproduced the Calcutta High Court’s dismissal of the Revenue’s appeal in Raghvendra Mohta, affirming the conclusion that the assessment suffered from lack of inherent jurisdiction.
Section 124 Objection Considered in the Precedent
The reproduced precedent addressed the Revenue’s argument concerning section 124(3) and the assessee’s failure to object within the prescribed period.
It distinguished the Supreme Court decision in DCIT v. Kalinga Institute of Industrial Technology on its facts and held that the pecuniary jurisdictional defect before it was not cured merely by the assessee’s participation in the proceedings.
The present Tribunal adopted that line of reasoning in allowing the jurisdictional challenge.
Decision
The Tribunal held that the assessment had been passed by the DCIT without jurisdiction under the applicable CBDT instruction. It accordingly set aside the assessment and allowed the appeal on the legal ground.
The substantive assessment issues were therefore not decided on their merits.
Author’s Comments
The first question in an assessment is whether the officer has authority to assess that particular case. This order illustrates how an incorrect recital of returned income can obscure a jurisdictional defect until the original return acknowledgement is examined.
The decision provides useful support for checking returned income, the applicable monetary allocation and the officer who issued the scrutiny notice and completed the assessment. A higher designation, by itself, does not answer a specific jurisdictional allocation.
At the same time, the conclusion must be applied to the governing directions and facts of the particular case, including any relevant assignment or concurrent-jurisdiction order. The ruling concerns the allocation applicable to this assessment; it should not be presented as a universal prohibition against a DCIT assessing an individual whose income is below ₹20 lakh.
Cases Discussed
- R A Realtors Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO, ITA No. 2275/Kol/2025, ITAT Kolkata, 19 January 2026 – followed for jurisdictional allocation.
- Rajroop Doshi v. ITO, ITA No. 1838/Kol/2025, ITAT Kolkata, 7 January 2026 – cited by assessee.
- Arjun Rishi v. ITO, [2025] 176 taxmann.com 720 (ITAT Delhi) – cited by assessee.
- PCIT v. Raghvendra Mohta, ITAT/51/2025 (Calcutta High Court) – affirmed the finding of inherent lack of jurisdiction.
- Rupasi Bangla Agro Industries Pvt. Ltd. v. ITO, ITA No. 909/Kol/2023, ITAT Kolkata, 14 December 2023– followed in reproduced precedent.
- PCIT v. Shree Shoppers Ltd., ITAT/39/2023, Calcutta High Court – cited by assessee.
- Bhagyalaxmi Conclave (P) Ltd. v. DCIT, ITA No. 2517/Kol/2019, ITAT Kolkata, 3 February 2021 – relied upon in reproduced precedent.
- DCIT v. Kalinga Institute of Industrial Technology, (2023) 151 taxmann.com 434 (Supreme Court) – distinguished in reproduced precedent.
- ACIT v. Hotel Blue Moon, 321 ITR 362 (Supreme Court) – relied upon for a valid scrutiny notice.
- Raghvendra Mohta v. ACIT, ITA No. 2416/KOL/2017, ITAT Kolkata – followed; reasoning extensively reproduced.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT KOLKATA
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




