Lalitadevi Deepchand Jain Vs ITO (ITAT Surat)
Related to Each Other, Not to the Taxpayer: ITAT Deletes ₹8 Lakh HUF Commission Disallowance
The Disallowance Rested on Incorrect Assumptions
Can commission paid to an HUF be rejected because the Assessing Officer doubts its business setup and assumes that it is related to the taxpayer? In this case, the Surat Tribunal examined the underlying records and found that the factual premises supporting the disallowance were incorrect.
The Tribunal deleted ₹8,00,001 paid to two HUFs after considering the commission details, their connection with loan disbursements, TDS certificates and the recipients’ disclosed business activities. The decision illustrates why the identity and business records of commission recipients must be examined before drawing adverse conclusions.
A Loan-Sourcing Business and Its Commission Expenses
The assessee operated as a Direct Selling Agent, sourcing customers for loans offered by banks and financial institutions. For assessment year 2018–19, she filed her return declaring total income of ₹8,09,070.
Her business turnover was ₹92,94,594, with a declared net profit of ₹8,04,361. She claimed commission expenditure of ₹25,02,434 and consultancy expenditure of ₹8,73,384.
The original scrutiny assessment accepted the returned income. Subsequently, the Principal Commissioner invoked Section 263, holding that the commission claim had not been substantiated during the revision proceedings. The assessment was set aside with directions to undertake a fresh examination.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


