Aman Kumar Rathaur Vs State of Punjab and Others (Punjab & Haryana High Court)
Summary: The Punjab & Haryana High Court disposed of four writ petitions filed by Aman Kumar Rathaur challenging interception proceedings concerning consignments of iron scrap and consequential show cause notices. In the lead matter, CWP No. 5902 of 2023, the petitioner, being the consignor, challenged Form GST MOV-02 dated 06.03.2023 and consequential proceedings relating to vehicle No. HR38 W 0782, which had been intercepted by the State Tax Officer-cum-Proper Officer, Mobile Wing, Ludhiana at Bansal Casting, Mandi Gobindgarh. A subsequent show cause notice dated 13.03.2023 alleged that purchases had been made from M/s BN Traders, which had not shown any purchases or paid tax, and tentatively determined tax liability of Rs.76,41,499 for the period 01.03.2023 to 06.03.2023. Instead of replying to the show cause notice, the petitioner approached the High Court contending that the goods had already reached the consignee’s premises and were therefore not “in transit”, depriving the authorities of jurisdiction. The consignment comprised 17,360 kg of iron scrap valued at Rs.8,39,876.80 inclusive of tax and was accompanied by an e-Way bill.
The State relied upon State of Punjab Vs M/s Shiv Enterprises and others, 2023 (96) GST 120 (Supreme Court), and informed the Court that the vehicle had already been released. The High Court observed that it was for the petitioner to explain before the authorities whether the show cause notice had been validly served, how purchases had been made from M/s BN Traders and whether there was substance in the allegations of tax avoidance. The writ Court could not assume the role of the Assessing Authority or determine disputed questions of fact. Following the Supreme Court’s ruling in Shiv Enterprises that interference under Article 226 against a show cause notice concerning alleged tax evasion was premature, the High Court held that the petitioner had an alternative remedy to put forth his case before the respondents. The writ petitions were accordingly disposed of with liberty to pursue that remedy, and all interim orders were vacated.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

