DCIT Vs Artline Vinimay Private Limited (ITAT Delhi)
Summary: ITAT Delhi dismissed the Revenue’s appeal and upheld deletion of a protective addition of ₹2,44,68,000 made in the hands of Artline Vinimay Private Limited for AY 2012-13. The reassessment originated from information received from the Investigation Wing, Kolkata regarding credits in the assessee’s bank account. The Assessing Officer completed reassessment under section 147 by making ₹2.44 crore addition on a protective basis on the allegation that the assessee was an accommodation-entry provider, besides a substantive addition of ₹1,21,323 relating to loss on sale of shares. The CIT(A) sustained the latter but deleted the protective addition.
Before the Tribunal, the assessee contended that the alleged substantive additions against Rajyog Buildtech Pvt. Ltd. pertained to AYs 2013-14 and 2014-15, whereas the present assessment year was 2012-13. It was further pointed out that even those substantive additions had subsequently been deleted by the CIT(A) and ITAT. The Tribunal found that the substantive additions had not survived and reiterated that when the substantive addition fails, the protective addition cannot independently survive. For this proposition, it expressly relied upon the Delhi High Court decision in Pr. CIT (Central)-2 v. Electrical and Electronic India Ltd. Accordingly, the CIT(A)’s deletion was affirmed and all grounds raised by Revenue were rejected.
Cases Discussed
- Pr. CIT (Central)-2 v. Electrical and Electronic India Ltd., (2023) 11 TMI 67 (Delhi High Court), dated 30.10.2023 — Relied upon by the Tribunal for the proposition that an addition made protectively does not survive after deletion of the substantive addition.
- DCIT v. Rajyog Buildtech Pvt. Ltd., ITA Nos. 1518/Del/2020 (AY 2013-14) & 1519/Del/2020 (AY 2014-15) (ITAT Delhi) — The Tribunal noted that the substantive additions relied upon by Revenue had not survived, since the CIT(A) as well as ITAT had deleted them.
- CIT v. Kabul Chawla, (2016) 380 ITR 573 / (2015) 234 Taxman 300 / 61 taxmann.com 412 (Delhi High Court) — Relied upon in the reproduced Rajyog Buildtech order for the principle governing additions in completed assessments under section 153A in the absence of incriminating material.
- Pr. CIT v. Meeta Gutgutia, (2017) 395 ITR 526 (Delhi High Court) — Considered in the reproduced order while applying the settled position concerning section 153A and absence of incriminating material.
- PCIT v. Subhash Khattar, ITA No. 60/2017, dated 25.07.2017 (Delhi High Court) — Relied upon in Rajyog Buildtech while holding the section 153A addition unsustainable in the absence of incriminating material.
- All Cargo Global Logistics Limited v. DCIT, [2012] 18 ITR 106 — Cited in the reproduced Rajyog Buildtech order on the scope of search assessment proceedings.
- ACIT, Central Circle-16, New Delhi v. Vinita Chaurasia, ITA No. 5957/Del/2015, dated 05.10.2018 (ITAT Delhi) — Cited among the precedents relied upon in Rajyog Buildtech.
- ACIT, Central Circle-4, New Delhi v. Moolchand Steels Pvt. Ltd., ITA No. 2544/Del/2015, dated 10.10.2018 (ITAT Delhi) — Also cited in the reproduced Rajyog Buildtech reasoning.
- Lalji Haridas v. ITO, 43 ITR 387 (Supreme Court) — Relied upon by the assessee for the principle governing substantive and protective assessments where the AO is uncertain about the person in whose hands income should ultimately be assessed. The supplied text spells the case as “Lalsi Hardas”; the source wording should remain preserved in the Full Text.
- Andaman Timber Industries v. Commissioner of Central Excise, Civil Appeal No. 4228 of 2006, order dated 02.09.2015 (Supreme Court) — CIT(A) relied upon the decision because the AO used Santosh Kumar Shah’s statement without permitting cross-examination. An exact TaxGuru page containing the Supreme Court order is available. TaxGuru
- Kishinchand Chellaram v. CIT, (1980) 125 ITR 713 (Supreme Court) — Cited by CIT(A), along with Andaman Timber Industries, while dealing with the evidentiary value of material relied upon without cross-examination.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT DELHI
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


