DCIT Vs Koya and Company Construction Ltd. (ITAT Delhi)
TP Adjustment Under 80IA(10) Unsustainable: Delhi ITAT Upholds 2% Margin & Dismisses Revenue’s Appeal
Revenue challenged deletion of TP/80IA(10) adjustment of Rs.2,57,05,203 & deletion of ad-hoc disallowance of Rs.12,72,014. Assessee, engaged in turnkey pipeline & civil infrastructure contracts, had sub-contracted civil works of the APSIDC Choutupalli Lift Irrigation project to AE Megha Engineering & Infrastructure Ltd (MEIL) on a back-to-back basis, retaining only a 2% margin. TPO rejected entity-level TNMM benchmarking, selected the Choutupalli project as tested party, adopted arm’s-length margin at 11.49%, & made an adjustment alleging that Assessee suppressed profits to inflate 80IA deduction.
CIT(A) examined the project bills, sub-contract agreement (including amendment dated 01.03.2015), revenue-recognition charts & year-wise margins & held that:
- MEIL’s billed value (Rs.1,02,91,486) was lower than its allocated scope (Rs.1,05,01,516), showing no under-billing;
- Assessee retained only 2% profit from MEIL’s civil-work portion, which was consistent over years;
- For AY 2017-18, the bulk of Rs.3.36 crore project profit arose from Assessee’s own pipeline & engineering work—not MEIL’s portion;
- 80IA projects without AE-transactions earned higher margin (10.02%) than projects with AE-transactions (5.94%), disproving allegation of profit inflation;
- Revenue failed to show any “arrangement” between Assessee & AE—mandatory pre-condition under 80IA(10).
Relying on judgments including HP Global Soft (Kar HC), Schmetz India (Bom HC) & Honeywell Automation (Pune ITAT), CIT(A) held that mere margin variation cannot trigger 80IA(10) without evidence of manipulation.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




