Sanjay Kothari (HUF) Vs National Faceless Assessment Centre (ITAT Mumbai)
ITAT Mumbai Restricts 14A Disallowance to Actual Expenses of ₹69,455 & Deletes ₹1.26 Cr Addition Treating Excess Refund of Advance as Capital Receipt
Assessee–HUF filed appeal against the NFAC order sustaining two additions: (i) ₹6,74,600 u/s 14A r.w. Rule 8D, & (ii) ₹1,26,32,970 treating excess refund of advance from its Karta (Mr. Sanjay Kothari, individual) as taxable income.
1. Section 14A / Rule 8D Disallowance – Partly Allowed
The assessee earned exempt income of ₹2.34 crore but made no 14A disallowance. AO recorded detailed satisfaction citing common portfolio, trading activity, & indirect expenses such as demat/STT/interest. Applying Rule 8D(2)(ii), he computed disallowance at 1% of average investments, i.e., ₹6,74,600.
Before ITAT, assessee invoked the proviso to Rule 8D(2), arguing disallowance cannot exceed actual expenditure claimed (₹69,455). ITAT accepted this legal plea & restricted the 14A disallowance to ₹69,455, subject to verification.
2. Addition of ₹1.26 Crore – Fully Deleted
Assessee–HUF had advanced ₹11.70 crore to its Karta in his individual capacity & received ₹12.93 crore back, resulting in an “excess” refund of ₹1.26 crore. AO treated this differential as income, alleging frequent inter-account movements.
ITAT held:
- HUF & its Karta (individual) are distinct taxpayers; inter-se advances retain their nature as capital transactions.
- AO himself accepted the existence of an advance; only the differential repayment was taxed without evidence of income character.
- Utilisation of advance for F&O business does not alter the nature of the receipt.
- Only income can be taxed; here the refund is capital in nature.
- Thus, entire addition of ₹1,26,32,970 was deleted.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT MUMBAI
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



