Rameshwar Finvest Private Limited Vs DCIT (ITAT Kolkata)
Section 68 Proviso Not Retrospective—ITAT Quashes Huge Share Capital Addition – ₹32.04 Cr Share Capital Addition Falls: No Cross-Examination, No 68 Addition:
Kolkata ITAT ‘D’ Bench in Rameshwar Finvest Pvt Ltd vs DCIT, Central Circle-3(3), Kolkata (ITA No.2107/Kol/2025, AY 2008-09, order dated 23-12-2025) allowed the assessee’s appeal and deleted the entire addition of ₹32.04 crore made u/s 68, holding that the assessee had duly discharged the onus of proving identity, creditworthiness and genuineness of share subscribers, and that the addition was made in gross violation of principles of natural justice.
The case involved share capital and share premium of ₹32.04 crore (₹10 face value + ₹190 premium). In the first round of reassessment u/s 147, AO had examined the issue in detail, issued notices u/s 133(6), invoked Explanation 3 to s.147, and accepted the share capital without making any addition. Subsequently, PCIT invoked section 263, leading to a second round of assessment, where AO treated the entire share capital/premium as bogus u/s 68, primarily relying on statements of two directors recorded u/s 131 and alleged non-compliance by some subscribers.
ITAT noted that:
- All primary evidences—PAN, ITRs, audited accounts, bank statements and confirmations—were filed both in first and second rounds
- 23 share subscribers complied with summons u/s 131 and others had responded to notices u/s 133(6)
- Statements relied upon were never confronted to the assessee, and no opportunity of cross-examination was granted, rendering the assessment void for breach of natural justice (relying on Andaman Timber Industries, SC)
- Non-appearance of some subscribers cannot justify 68 addition once documentary evidence is on record (Orissa Corporation, SC; Crystal Networks, Cal HC)
- Proviso to section 68 (source of source) inserted by Finance Act, 2012 is prospective and not applicable to AY 2008-09 (Gagandeep Infrastructure, Bom HC)
- AO also violated sections 142(2) & 142(3) by using material gathered behind the assessee’s back without confrontation
Distinguishing Nipun Builders (Del HC) on facts, ITAT held that the assessee’s case stood on much stronger footing, as subscribers existed, responded to statutory notices and transactions were routed through banking channels.
Accordingly, ITAT set aside the order of CIT(A) and directed deletion of the entire addition of ₹32.04 crore, allowing the appeal in full.
Key takeaway:
For pre-2013 assessment years, once the assessee proves identity, creditworthiness & genuineness, section 68 cannot be invoked merely on suspicion or non-appearance. Statements used without cross-examination and material not confronted vitiate the entire assessment.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT KOLKATA
This is an appeal preferred by the assessee against the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals), Kolkata-21(hereinafter referred to as the “Ld. CIT(A)”] dated 06.08.2025 for the AY 2008-09.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.
Author Info
- Builder’s Excel Sheet Alone Cannot Prove On-Money Payment: Rajkot ITAT November 18, 2026
- Bogus Purchase Addition Restricted to 5% as Sales Undisputed: ITAT Delhi November 18, 2026
- Section 153A Addition for an Unabated Year Requires Incriminating Material Found in Search: ITAT Dehradun November 18, 2026
Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

Gratuity Tax Exemption 2026-27: New Income Tax and Labour Laws
November 18, 2026
Delay in Filing Form 67 Cannot Deny Foreign Tax Credit: ITAT Rulings
November 18, 2026
Builder’s Excel Sheet Alone Cannot Prove On-Money Payment: Rajkot ITAT
November 18, 2026
F&O Loss in ITR: A Small Calculation Error, Big Tax Trouble!
November 18, 2026
Bogus Purchase Addition Restricted to 5% as Sales Undisputed: ITAT Delhi
November 18, 2026
Section 153A Addition for an Unabated Year Requires Incriminating Material Found in Search: ITAT Dehradun
November 18, 2026Subscribe Our Newsletter
Join the professionals, businesses and finance teams who rely on TaxGuru's morning digest of notifications, judgments and analysis. Curated by editors, free forever.
