DCIT Vs Ajay Kumar (ITAT Patna)
₹21 Crore Addition on Photocopies: Suspicion Could Not Supply the Missing Evidence
The Allegation: Huge Cash Payments Behind a Real Estate Project
The Patna Tribunal upheld the deletion of a ₹21 crore addition under section 68, holding that uncorroborated photocopies, third-party ledger entries and unsupported valuation assumptions could not establish receipt of undisclosed income. The decision also highlights a fundamental statutory requirement: section 68 applies to sums credited in the assessee’s books, whereas the Assessing Officer himself alleged that these receipts were outside the books.
The dispute arose from information received from the Investigation Wing alleging substantial cash payments by Shri Iqbal Singh Sodhi, Director of Saviour Builders Pvt. Ltd., to the assessee and his related companies in connection with the GreenArch real estate project of New Way Homes Pvt. Ltd.
According to the Department, aggregate payments amounted to approximately ₹53.05 crore, including ₹41.60 crore allegedly paid in cash. For assessment year 2013-14, the Assessing Officer reopened the assessment and added ₹21 crore as unexplained receipts under section 68.
Photocopies Produced, Original Evidence Missing
The assessment rested principally on an investigation report, photocopies of alleged cash receipts and certain ledger extracts. Despite repeated requests, the assessee received only part of the material relied upon. Other documents were withheld on the ground of confidentiality.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





