Banarsi Lal Vs ITO (ITAT Agra)
Summary: ITAT Agra quashed the reassessment proceedings for Assessment Year 2014-15 after holding that the approval obtained under Section 151 of the Income-tax Act for reopening the assessment was mechanical and did not demonstrate application of mind by the sanctioning authority. The assessee had filed his return on 07.06.2016 declaring total income of Rs.1,85,440, which the Assessing Officer treated as non-est. Based on information that the assessee had sold agricultural lands and derived agricultural income, the AO initiated reassessment proceedings under Section 147 and issued notice under Section 148 on 02.02.2017.
The assessee filed a return in response on 27.03.2017. The crucial jurisdictional issue arose from the approval granted by the Additional CIT, Range 2(2), Firozabad under Section 151. The sanctioning authority had merely recorded that he was satisfied that it was a fit case for reopening. The Tribunal held that such approval was mechanical and without proper application of mind. It relied on CIT v. S. Goyenka Lime and Chemicals Ltd., 56 taxmann.com 390 (MP), where mechanical satisfaction for reopening was disapproved and the Revenue’s SLP was subsequently dismissed by the Supreme Court.
The Tribunal also relied upon PCIT v. N.C. Cables Ltd., 391 ITR 11 (Delhi), SBC Minerals P. Ltd. v. ACIT, 475 ITR 360 (Delhi) and Vodafone India Ltd. v. DCIT, 464 ITR 385 (Bombay), which supported the requirement that the statutory sanction reflect meaningful application of mind. Revenue relied on Experion Developers P. Ltd. v. ACIT, 422 ITR 355 (Delhi), Virbhadra Singh v. DCIT, 88 taxmann.com 88 (HP) and Sonia Gandhi v. ACIT, 407 ITR 594 (Delhi) to contend that the sanctioning authority was not required to record elaborate reasons. Noting conflicting decisions of non-jurisdictional High Courts, the Tribunal applied CIT v. Vegetable Products Ltd., 88 ITR 192 (SC) and adopted the construction favourable to the assessee. It consequently held that valid approval under Section 151 had not been obtained in the manner known to law, quashed the entire reassessment proceedings and left the remaining legal and merits grounds open. The assessee’s appeal was allowed.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





