Axis Infoline P. Ltd. Vs PCIT (ITAT Delhi)
Summary: ITAT Delhi allowed the assessee’s appeal and held that the PCIT could not invoke Section 263 merely because he preferred 100% disallowance of bogus purchases over the 25% disallowance consciously adopted by the Assessing Officer. The AO had examined purchases of Rs.1,49,86,000/- from M/s Diwakar Enterprises, concluded that they were bogus, rejected the assessee’s offer to surrender 12.50% and, after considering judicial precedents, disallowed 25%, amounting to Rs.37,46,500/-, under Section 69C. The PCIT, relying principally on N.K. Proteins and Kanak Impex, considered the entire bogus purchases liable to disallowance and consequently treated the assessment order as erroneous and prejudicial to Revenue.
The Tribunal held that the relevant question was not whether the AO’s 25% estimate or the PCIT’s 100% view was ultimately preferable, but whether Section 263 could be exercised where two possible views existed and each had support from judicial decisions. It noted that even the Delhi High Court decision in La Medica supported a treatment broadly comparable to the view relied upon by the PCIT. Nevertheless, relying on Malabar Industrial Company Ltd., the Tribunal held that where two views are possible and the AO adopts one legally sustainable view, the Commissioner cannot revise the assessment merely because he disagrees with it.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






