Alka Ajit Shah Vs ITO (ITAT Mumbai)
Can Reassessment Under Section 147 Bypass Section 153C When Based Entirely on Third-Party Search Material?
The controversy
The Mumbai Tribunal quashed a reassessment involving an alleged cash payment of ₹16,20,000 towards purchase of a flat, holding that the Assessing Officer could not invoke sections 147 and 148 to bypass the applicable section 153C procedure.
The alleged escapement was founded entirely on material emerging from a third-party search. Following the jurisdictional Bombay High Court’s decision in Sejal Jewellary, the Tribunal held that the statutory route chosen by the Department was incorrect. Significantly, it considered the contrary Delhi High Court view in Naveen Kumar Gupta, but followed the binding jurisdictional decision.
The flat purchase and alleged cash component
The assessee jointly purchased Flat No. 2001 in Raj Splendour from Rajesh Estate and Nirman Pvt. Ltd. The agreement consideration was ₹98,55,000. Her return for AY 2011-12 had been processed under section 143(1).
Following a search on the Rajesh Lifespaces Group on 10 March 2016, the Assessing Officer received information from the Central Circle concerning alleged cash receipts on flat sales.
A flat-wise entry named the assessee and Ajit P. Shah as purchasers, recorded the agreement consideration of ₹98,55,000 and specified an alleged cash component of ₹16,20,000.



