Ambience Developers & Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd Vs PCIT ( ITAT Delhi)
ITAT Delhi Quashes 263 Orders – Rental Income Reclassified as House Property, Not Business
Background Assessments:
Assessee engaged in real estate development.
AY 2018-19: Return filed showing loss of ₹19.52 Cr (normal) & MAT income of ₹17.09 Cr, processed u/s 143(3).
AY 2020-21: Similar scrutiny completed.
PCIT (Central)-2, Delhi:
- Exercised revisionary jurisdiction u/s 263 (orders dated 29.02.2024).
- Held AO’s orders erroneous & prejudicial to Revenue, citing:
Wrong classification of rental receipts as “Income from House Property” instead of “Business Income”.
Wrong allowance of interest expenses as business expenditure (should have been capitalized).
Wrong standard deduction u/s 24(a).
Assessee’s plea:
- Consistency principle—similar treatment accepted in earlier & later years.
- Change would reduce revenue, not enhance it (due to depreciation entitlement).
- AO made inquiries & applied mind, hence 263 cannot be invoked.
- Relied on SC in Malabar Industrial Co. Ltd. & Calvinator of India Ltd., and Delhi HC in Brahma Centre Development.
Tribunal’s Findings
1. Classification of Rental Income
- Assessee owned shops; rent consistently assessed under “House Property”.
- PCIT’s claim of no ownership factually incorrect- sale deeds produced proved ownership.
- If reclassified as business income, depreciation of ₹60.39 Cr would be allowable, leading to higher loss carry forward, prejudicial to Revenue itself.
- Thus, PCIT’s finding unsustainable
2. Interest Expenses
- Finance cost of ₹87.78 Cr claimed as business expense u/s 36(1)(iii).
- AO examined during scrutiny; assessee explained investment nature.
- PCIT alleged it should be capitalized, but ITAT held:
AO conducted inquiry & adopted a permissible view.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




