Anil Kumar Agarwal Vs DCIT (ITAT Agra)
Cash Deposits Fully Explained Through Cash Book & Bank Withdrawals—CIT(A)’s Partial Confirmation Reversed; Entire ₹11 Lakh Addition Deleted
The Assessee filed return declaring ₹2,29,550. Based on AIR information showing ₹13 lakh cash deposit in HDFC Bank, AO reopened the assessment u/s 147 and treated the entire ₹13 lakh as unexplained income u/s 68, stating that the Assessee’s replies were vague.
CIT(A) examined the sources and accepted only ₹2 lakh as explained (cash received on sale of property to Smt. Gashkin Begum), rejecting explanations regarding commodity-trading receipts from Adroid Securities and treating cheque withdrawals of ₹6 lakh as non-cash withdrawals. CIT(A) therefore confirmed ₹11 lakh as unexplained.
Before Tribunal, the Assessee produced:
- HDFC Bank certificate proving the ₹6 lakh withdrawal (21-02-2011) was a self cheque and therefore a cash withdrawal,
- Cash Book for FY 2010-11 showing all daily cash movements, speculative income receipts, drawings & cash deposits,
- Ledger & supportive entries demonstrating cash availability throughout the year.
Tribunal noted that:
- The Cash Book showed no negative cash balance on any day,
- All cash deposits aggregating ₹13 lakh were fully covered by recorded cash availability,
- Cash withdrawals remain a valid source unless Revenue proves diversion for other purposes—which Revenue failed to show,
- Books (including Cash Book) were never rejected,
- Cash receipts from speculative transactions were already offered to tax as speculative income.
Relying on S.R. Venkata Ratnam vs CIT (127 ITR 807, Kar.), Tribunal held that earlier-year or earlier-date cash withdrawals must be presumed to be available unless shown otherwise.
Accordingly, Tribunal held that the entire ₹13 lakh was satisfactorily explained, and the CIT(A) erred in restricting relief to ₹2 lakh.
Result
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


