Rajni Arvind Birla Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
Provisional Assessment Invalid—Tribunal Strikes Down 143(3) & 154 Orders Passed Before DVO Valuation- 50C(2) Right Violated—Rectification Using Later DVO Report Impermissible; Entire Assessment Quashed; Order Invalid as AO Finalized Assessment “Subject to Rectification”—Act Does Not Permit Provisional 143(3) Orders; Rectification Under Section 154 Cannot Rely on Later DVO Report—Fresh Material Not Part of Record; Premature Assessment Violates Assessee’s Statutory Right Under Section 50C(2)—Natural Justice Breached; AO Ignored Statutory Exclusion of Limitation Period Under Section 153—Assessment Time-Bar Reason Rejected; CIT(A) Erred in Upholding a Jurisdictionally Defective Assessment—Failure to Consider Precedents and Procedural Violations; Disallowances Sustained Without Proper Hearing Set Aside—CIT(A) Failed to Grant Opportunity; DVO Reference Made—AO Still Adopted Stamp Duty Value; Assessment Struck Down for Non-Compliance; Assessment and Rectification Both Quashed—Jurisdictional Defects Cannot Be Cured Later
Assessee sold commercial premises for ₹1,75,00,000/-. Stamp Valuation Authority adopted ₹2,23,37,669/-. Assessee invoked s.50C(2) & AO referred matter to DVO through Technical Unit. As assessment was getting time-barred, AO passed order u/s 143(3) r.w.s 144B on 22.09.2021 adopting stamp-value, expressly stating that assessment was “subject to rectification on receipt of DVO report.” DVO report dated 25.09.2024 (FMV ₹1,94,81,000) was later received, & AO passed rectification order u/s 154 on 20.11.2024 reducing LTCG.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



