Raj Kumar Daga HUF Vs ACIT (ITAT Delhi)
AO’s Suspicion Not Evidence- Commission Payments Genuine- Section 68 Cannot Apply to Opening Balances
Assessee, proprietor of M/s Gappu Ispat, engaged in trading of iron & steel, filed returns declaring income of Rs.31,20,070 for AY 2013-14. In scrutiny, AO disallowed Rs.49,51,599 out of total commission of Rs.1,25,90,385 alleging bogus payments—seven parties did not appear, notices returned unserved, & explanations of three parties were rejected. AO assessed income at Rs.80,71,670. Ld. CIT(A)/NFAC confirmed the additions.
Before Tribunal, Assessee submitted full details of all agents, including confirmations, invoices, bank statements, ITRs, & in some cases affidavits affirming receipt of commission. All payments were through banking channels with TDS deduction, & recipients declared the income. It was argued that AO accepted sales of ~Rs.13 crores which required middlemen; commission of 2.01% was reasonable. Importantly, identical documentation was accepted for commission of Rs.75,57,786, thus partial disallowance was inconsistent.
Tribunal noted that identity, genuineness & services of agents were established. AO proceeded merely on suspicion without disproving documents or showing commissions were not rendered. Commission percentage was low & commensurate with trade practice. Disallowance was therefore deleted.
For AY 2014-15, AO similarly disallowed commission of Rs.1,05,63,454 (though wrongly enhanced to Rs.1,38,60,230 in computation). Both parties admitted that facts were identical to earlier year. Tribunal held that the same reasoning applied & deleted the entire disallowance.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



