BHIL Employees Welfare Fund No.4 Vs ITO (Bombay High Court)
Bombay High Court held that income-tax authorities cannot mechanically insist upon payment of a fixed percentage of disputed demand while deciding a stay application without considering the assessee’s prima facie case, merits and hardship. BHIL Employees Welfare Fund No.4 challenged orders requiring payment of a portion of outstanding tax demands for AY 2014-15 and AY 2017-18. The assessee contended that it was a trust created for the benefit of employees but reassessment proceedings had proceeded on the basis of its old PAN, under which its status continued to appear as a firm.
This resulted in technical difficulties in filing the return and allegedly led to assessment and computation of tax on an incorrect status. The Court found that the authorities had failed to properly consider the assessee’s repeated communications requesting correction of its status from Firm to Trust. Following UTI Mutual Fund v. ITO and KEC International Ltd. v. B.R. Balakrishnan, the Court reiterated that an Assessing Officer deciding a stay application acts as a quasi-judicial authority and must balance protection of Revenue with mitigation of hardship to the assessee.
Financial hardship is not the sole criterion; the existence of a strong prima facie case and serious triable issues must also be considered. The Court further relied upon Humuza Consultants v. ACIT, where protection was granted against recovery in a high-pitched assessment involving a prima facie case. Finding that BHIL Employees Welfare Fund had a strong prima facie case and that insisting upon a 10% deposit could itself cause undue hardship to a trust established for employees’ benefit, the High Court remanded the matters for reconsideration in the assessee’s correct status as a Trust, preferably within four months, and directed that no coercive recovery steps be taken meanwhile.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



