Directorate of Enforcement Vs Poonam Malik (Delhi High Court)
Delhi HC Quashes ED’s “Suspicion-Based” Freezing Orders for Non-Compliance with Mandatory PMLA Safeguards
The Delhi High Court dismissed ED’s appeals & upheld the Appellate Tribunal’s order unfreezing the bank accounts of respondent Poonam Malik. The Court held that the freezing orders dated 05.09.2018 under Section 17(1A) PMLA were illegal, as they were issued only on “suspicion” without recording the mandatory “reasons to believe”, a statutory precondition for any search, seizure, or freezing action. The cryptic order lacked any indication that the authorised officer had material showing the accounts contained proceeds of crime.
The Court found complete non-compliance with Section 17(1), 17(1A), 17(2), & the PMLA (Search & Seizure / Freezing) Rules, 2005. Since freezing is an alternative to seizure, the legal standard cannot be diluted. “Suspicion” is not equivalent to a “reason to believe”, which must be a demonstrable, objective, material-based satisfaction. The ED’s attempt to justify the freezing later through affidavits & arguments was rejected on the basis of Opto Circuit & Mohinder Singh Gill, which prohibit supplementing defective orders by post-hoc explanations.
The Court also faulted the Adjudicating Authority for mechanically confirming the freezing without following the mandatory procedure of Section 8 (notice under 8(1), finding under 8(2), then confirmation under 8(3)). Further, the Authority wrongly used terms like retention, continuation, confirmation interchangeably, showing lack of application of mind.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






