MVAT on PAN card printing for Income Tax Dept – HC set-aside non-speaking order

NSDL E-Governance Infrastructure Ltd. Vs State of Maharashtra (Maharashtra Sales Tax Tribunal at Mumbai) The assessee was printing PAN cards for the Income Tax Department, Government of India. Service tax was paid on such activity. Sales tax authorities held that it is a works contract liable to VAT. The Tribunal, examining the subject, held that the order passed by the Deputy Commissioner of Sales Tax was non-speaking one and remanded the matter back for examining the claim on merits. FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF MAHARASHTRA SALES TAX TRIBUNAL AT MUMBAI These are appeals filed against o...