HIGH COURT OF MADRAS
Commissioner of Income-tax
V/s.
Singapore Airlines Ltd.
TAX CASE APPEAL NOS. 15 TO 20 OF 2006
JULY 13, 2012
JUDGMENT
Mrs. Chitra Venkataraman, J.
The Revenue has filed the above Tax Case (Appeals) as against the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal relating to the assessment years 1997-98, 1998-99 and 1999-2000. This Court, by order dated 06.02.2006 admitted the above Tax Case (Appeals) on the following substantial question of law:
“Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Tribunal was right in holding that payment of landing and parking charges is to be treated as payment of contractors under Section 194 C and not as payment of rent under Section 194 I of the Income Tax Act?”
2. The assessee is an international airlines. In the course of the assessment proceedings, for the assessment years 1997-98 to 1999-2000, the assessee claimed that the charges paid to International Airport Authority towards landing and parking charges would not come within the definition of ‘rent’ as defined under Section 194 I Explanation of the Income Tax Act and hence, the liability to deduct tax at source under Section 194 I or under Section 194 J of the Income Tax Act in respect of payment of navigation charges did not arise at all.
3. The Assessing Authority pointed out that the charges paid by the assessee on landing and parking to International Airport Authority of India for the use of runway for landing and take off and also the space in the tarmac of the airport for parking of the aircraft represented ‘rent’. Since the assessee had failed to deduct TDS at 20%, the assessee was liable to be treated as one in default; consequently, an order under Section 201(1) and 201(1A) was made. Aggrieved by this, the assessee went on appeal before the Commissioner of Income Tax (Appeals), who confirmed the order of the Assessing Officer. Aggrieved by this, the assessee went on appeal before the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal.
4. A perusal of the order of the Tribunal shows that it followed the decision of the Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in the case of DCIT v. Japan Airlines reported in [2005] 92 TTJ 687, which held that the payment made by the airline company could not be construed as payment of rent. Thus the Tribunal agreed with the Delhi Bench of the Tribunal in the case of DCIT v. Japan Airlines reported in [2005] 92 TTJ 687 and held that the payment made for landing and parking charges and on navigation did not answer the description of ‘rent’ to go for TDS under Section 194 I of the Income Tax Act. However, the Delhi Tribunal held that the charges would attract under the provisions of Section 194 C of the Income Tax Act, a line of reasoning, which was also accepted by the Tribunal of the Madras Bench in the assessee’s case. The assessee had also accepted the liability under Section 194 C of the Income Tax Act.
5. As far as navigation facilities were concerned, the assessee did not make a serious dispute, in other words, it conceded that it was in the nature of charges paid for getting technical services, apart from using the equipments for the purpose of communication between the aircraft and the air traffic controller, thus, Section 194 J was held applicable.
6. In the light of the decision thus arrived at, the Tribunal thought it fit to remand the matter back to the Assessing Authority to work out the interest payable till the date on which the International Airport Authority had paid the tax in respect of the amount received from the assessee, particularly with reference to the liability under Section 194 C of the Income Tax Act. Aggrieved by this, the present appeals have been filed by the Revenue.
7. Learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Revenue placed heavy reliance on the definition of ‘rent’ as found in Section 194 I Explanation of the Income Tax Act and placed reliance on the decision of the Delhi High Court reported in [2010] 325 ITR 298 (Delhi) (Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Japan Airlines Co. Ltd.), wherein the Delhi High Court reversed the order of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal. While so reversing the decision of the Tribunal, the Delhi High Court applied the decision of the Delhi High Court reported in [2006] 287 ITR 281 (United Airlines v. CIT), wherein it was held that when the wheels of an aircraft coming into an airport touches the surface of the air-field, use of the land of the airport immediately begins. Consequently, the Delhi High Court accepted the case of the Revenue, thereby confirmed the order of assessment.
8. Considering the identical nature of facts prevailing in the present case, learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Revenue submits that the decision therein may be applied herein too. He, however, pointed out that the decision of the Delhi High Court reported in [2010] 325 ITR 298 (Delhi) (Commissioner of Income-Tax v. Japan Airlines Co. Ltd.) is pending in appeal before the Apex Court in Special Leave to Appeal (Civil) No.4102 of 2009 and the matter was directed to be listed on 7th October, 2009. On verification, it is learnt that the appeal is still pending on the files of the Apex Court. Referring to the decision of the Delhi High Court reported in [2006] 287 ITR 281 (United Airlines v. CIT), learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Revenue reiterated the contentions on the lines held by the Delhi High Court and thus submitted that in the light of the decisions of the Delhi High Court on the very same issue, the Tax Case (Appeals) be allowed.
9. Countering the submissions made by the Revenue, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the assessee took us through the decision of the Delhi Bench of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal in the case of DCIT v. Japan Airlines reported in [2005] 92 TTJ 687, as well as to the decision of the Delhi High Court in the case of Japan Airlines and pointed out that the Delhi High Court while reversing the order of the Tribunal had applied the decision of the Delhi High Court reported in [2006] 287 ITR 281 (United Airlines v. CIT) wherein the Delhi High Court had considered the definition of ‘rent’ without considering the nature of services offered by the International Airport Authority of India on the landing and parking of the air craft. Taking us through the definition of ‘rent’, he pointed out that the definition is an exhaustive definition and that considering this reference to the preceding enumeration, namely, lease, sub-lease or tenancy, the reference to any other agreement or arrangement as appearing in the definition has to be understood applying the principle of ejusdem generis; that the said arrangement or agreement has to be in respect of use of any land or any building as under a tenancy or lease, that the payment received qualified to be treated as ‘rent’. He pointed out that even though the Delhi High Court had referred to the definition of ‘rent’, it had not taken note of the facts as are projected in the present case that there is no use of any land as in the case of tenancy or lease, that all that the airlines had paid was only for the services rendered by the Airport Authority in providing the facilities for landing including the navigational facility and the payment is measured with reference to the various parameters, which are given by the International Airport Authority in its various circulars. Thus raising the question as to whether the various facilities offered and the charges fixed therefor on the basis of weight for the use of the facility would fall for ‘use of the land’ and the charges in the definition of ‘rent’, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the assessee took us through the decision of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Delhi Bench in the case of Japan Airlines, which had considered the various aspects of the services rendered to the airlines and pointed out that the Delhi High Court in the decision reported in [2006] 287 ITR 281 (United Airlines v. CIT) had not considered any of these aspects while dealing with the issue as to whether the charges would fit in with the definition of ‘rent’. On the other hand, the Delhi High Court in the decision reported in [2006] 287 ITR 281 (United Airlines v. CIT) had merely interpreted the provision of law to come to a conclusion that when the wheels of an aircraft coming into an airport touches the surface of the air-field, there is an use of the land immediately, so too on the parking of the aircraft in the airport, there is use of the land; hence, parking and landing fee would be treated as rent. Thus following the said decision, the Tribunal’s decision in the case of Japan Airlines was reversed.
10. Objecting to this line of reasoning, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the assessee submitted that on the issues raised, particularly with reference to the nature of services rendered, the decision requires a fresh consideration by this Court and that the decision referred to above cannot be applied straightaway to reject the assessee’s contention herein. In the light of the various facilities offered by the Airport Authority of India for landing and parking, unless the facility offered fits in with the definition of ‘rent’, the case of the assessee could not be brought within the four corners of taxation for the purpose of applying Section 201(1) and 201(1A) of the Income Tax Act.
11. Heard learned Standing Counsel appearing for the Revenue and the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the assessee and perused the materials placed before this Court.
12. We agree with the contention of the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the assessee and with respect, we express our disagreement to the decision of the Delhi High Court. The facts are not in dispute.
13. ‘Rent’ is defined under Explanation (i) to Section 194 I of the Income Tax Act, as follows:
“194 I Any person, not being an individual or a Hindu undivided family, who is responsible for paying to any person any income by way of rent, shall, at the time of credit of such income to the account of the payee or at the time of payment thereof in cash or by the issue of a cheque or draft or by any other mode, whichever is earlier, deduct income-tax thereon at the rate of –
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






