Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

GST Demand of ₹3.09 Crore Set Aside for Ignoring Taxpayer’s Reply: Delhi HC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 19278
Case Name
Balaji Medical and Diagnostic Research Centre Vs Union of India & Ors. (Delhi High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Balaji Medical and Diagnostic Research Centre Vs Union of India & Ors. (Delhi High Court)

Summary: The Delhi High Court, in Balaji Medical and Diagnostic Research Centre Vs Union of India & Ors., set aside a GST adjudication order dated 27 December 2023 raising a demand of ₹3,09,18,988, including penalty, under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, holding that the Proper Officer had failed to consider the taxpayer’s detailed reply before confirming the demand. The dispute arose from a show-cause notice dated 23 September 2023 concerning under-declaration of output tax, excess claim of Input Tax Credit (ITC), under-declaration of ineligible ITC and ITC claimed from cancelled dealers, return defaulters and tax non-payers. The petitioner submitted a detailed reply on 23 October 2023, providing explanations and disclosures under each disputed head. However, the adjudicating authority rejected the reply through a general observation that the submissions and GST portal data had been examined but were not found satisfactory. The petitioner challenged the order as cryptic and arbitrary, contending that its explanations had not been examined on merits. The High Court observed that merely declaring a detailed reply unsatisfactory without discussing its contents or providing reasons demonstrated non-application of mind. The Proper Officer was required to consider the taxpayer’s submissions and form a reasoned opinion rather than mechanically confirming the proposed demand.

The High Court further held that if the Proper Officer considered the explanation inadequate or required additional documents, the authority should have specifically communicated those requirements and provided the petitioner an opportunity to furnish clarifications. The record did not indicate that any such opportunity had been granted. Consequently, the Court set aside the adjudication order dated 27 December 2023 and remanded the matter for fresh adjudication. It directed the Proper Officer to intimate the petitioner regarding any additional documents or particulars required, permit submission of the necessary explanations and supporting records, and thereafter reconsider the show-cause notice after granting an opportunity of personal hearing. The authority was directed to pass a fresh speaking order in accordance with law within the period prescribed under Section 75(3) of the CGST Act. Importantly, the Court clarified that it had neither examined nor expressed any opinion on the merits of the rival contentions, and all rights and arguments of both parties remained reserved. The petitioner’s challenge to Notification No. 9 of 2023 concerning the initial extension of time was also expressly left open. Thus, the judgment reinforces that GST adjudication authorities must meaningfully consider taxpayers’ replies and provide reasoned findings before confirming demands, particularly where detailed explanations have been submitted against multiple allegations.

FULL TEXT OF THE JUDGMENT/ORDER OF DELHI HIGH COURT

1. Petitioner impugns order dated 27.12.2023, whereby the impugned Show Cause Notice dated 23.09.2023, proposing a demand against the petitioner has been disposed and a demand of Rs. 3,09,18,988.00 including penalty has been raised against the petitioner. The order has been passed under Section 73 of the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (hereinafter referred to as the Act).

2. Learned counsel for Petitioner submits that a detailed reply dated 23.10.2023 was filed to the Show Cause Notice, however, the impugned order dated 27.12.2023 does not take into consideration the reply submitted by the petitioner and is a cryptic order.

3. Perusal of the Show Cause Notice shows that the Department has given separate headings under declaration of output tax, excess claim Input Tax Credit [“ITC”], under declaration of ineligible ITC and ITC claim from cancelled dealers, return defaulters and tax non-payers. To the said Show Cause Notice, a detailed reply dated 23.10.2023 was furnished by the petitioner giving full disclosures under each of the heads.

4. The impugned order, however, after recording the narration, records that the reply uploaded by the tax payer is not satisfactory. It merely states that “And whereas, in response to the DRC-01, the Taxpayer submitted his reply in Form DRC-06. The reply of the registered person as well as data available on GST Portal have been checked / examined and the submission of the Taxpayer was not found satisfactory.” The Proper Officer has opined that the reply is unsatisfactory.

5. The observation in the impugned order dated 27.12.2023 is not sustainable for the reasons that the reply filed by the petitioner is a detailed reply. Proper Officer had to at least consider the reply on merits and then form an opinion whether the reply was not satisfactory. He merely held that the reply is not satisfactory which ex-facie shows that Proper Officer has not applied his mind to the reply submitted by the petitioner.

6. Further, if the Proper Officer was of the view that reply was not satisfactory and further details were required, the same could have been specifically sought from the petitioner. However, the record does not reflect that any such opportunity was given to the petitioner to clarify its reply or furnish further documents/details.

7. In view of the above, the order cannot be sustained, and the matter is liable to be remitted to the Proper Officer for re-adjudication. Accordingly, the impugned order dated 27.12.2023 is set aside. The matter is remitted to the Proper Officer for re-adjudication.

8. As noticed hereinabove, the impugned order records that petitioner has not furnished the requisite details. Proper Officer is directed to intimate to the petitioner details/documents, as maybe required to be furnished by the petitioner. Pursuant to the intimation being given, petitioner shall furnish the requisite explanation and documents. Thereafter, the Proper Officer shall re-adjudicate the Show Cause Notice after giving an opportunity of personal hearing and shall pass a fresh speaking order in accordance with law within the period prescribed under Section 75(3) of the Act.

9. It is clarified that this Court has neither considered nor commented upon the merits of the contentions of either party. All rights and contentions of parties are reserved.

10. The challenge to Notification No. 9 of 2023 with regard to the initial extension of time is left open.

11. Petition is disposed of in the above terms.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,894

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.