Pradeep Kumar Jain and Sons (HUF) Vs Sri Sri Iswar Mahadeb and Ors. (Calcutta High Court)
Summary: The Calcutta High Court dismissed six analogous appeals arising from eviction suits instituted in 2016 and directed transmission of the suits from the Non-Commercial Division to the Commercial Division. The defendants’ defence had been struck off under Section 7(3) of the West Bengal Premises Tenancy Act, 1997, following which applications seeking rejection of the plaints under Order VII Rule 11 CPC were dismissed. The appellants contended that the plaints disclosed no cause of action, that the properties were governed by the Transfer of Property Act and no Section 106 notice had been issued, and that the disputes were commercial disputes under Section 2(1)(c)(vii) of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015. The Division Bench held that questions concerning the applicable tenancy law and waiver of statutory rights required adjudication at trial and did not warrant rejection of the plaints. Both sides agreed that the suits involved commercial disputes. Relying on Laxmi Polyfab Pvt. Ltd. and Patil Automation Private Limited v. Rakheja Engineers Private Limited, the Court held that commercial suits instituted before 11 December 2020 could not be treated as incorrectly instituted merely for non-compliance with Section 12A. Since the present suits were instituted in 2016, their filing was not vitiated. Exercising powers under Section 15 of the Commercial Courts Act, the Court directed transfer of all six suits and connected applications to the Commercial Division for renumbering.
Cases Discussed
- AIR 2021 Cal 190 — Laxmi Polyfab Pvt. Ltd. Vs Eden Realty Ventures Pvt. Ltd. and Another (Calcutta High Court, decided 07.04.2021) — The High Court noted its ruling that suits instituted before 11.12.2020 would not be dismissed for non-compliance with Section 12A because the relevant standard operating procedure for pre-litigation mediation had not been published.
- (2022) 10 SCC 1 — Patil Automation Private Limited and Others Vs Rakheja Engineers Private Limited (Supreme Court) — Supreme Court held Section 12A of the Commercial Courts Act mandatory; the Calcutta High Court applied its ratio read with Laxmi Polyfab to hold that suits involving commercial disputes filed before 11.12.2020 were not incorrectly instituted for want of Section 12A compliance.
- Shri Balaji Industrial Engineering Ltd. Vs Steel Authority of India Ltd.–IISCO Steel Plant, SLP (C) No. 8111 of 2026 (Supreme Court)— The Supreme Court had observed that where a commercial suit is taken up by a Judge sitting in the Non-Commercial Division but that Judge possesses the determination of the Commercial Division, the decision cannot be faulted on that ground.
FULL TEXT OF THE CALCUTTA HIGH COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






