ACIT Vs Maheswary Granites Private Limited (ITAT Chennai)
ITAT Chennai dismissed the Revenue’s appeal and upheld deletion of penalty of Rs.69,71,783 levied under Section 271AAB(1)(c), holding that the Assessing Officer’s notice under Section 274 read with Section 271AAB was defective because it failed to specify the particular limb under which penalty was proposed. The assessee, engaged in manufacturing and trading granite and marbles, was subjected to search and excess stock of Rs.2.32 crore was found.
After quantum proceedings, the AO imposed penalty at 30% of the alleged undisclosed income. CIT(A) deleted the penalty following the Madras High Court decision in PCIT v. R. Elangovan. Before ITAT, Revenue argued that participation in proceedings cured any technical defect and relied upon, inter alia, Sundaram Finance Ltd., Amtex Software Solutions Pvt. Ltd. and Gangotri Textiles Ltd.
The Tribunal held that Section 271AAB(1) contained three separate contingencies carrying different consequences and therefore the AO was duty-bound to inform the assessee which specific limb was being invoked. Following PCIT v. R. Elangovan, Manjunatha Cotton & Ginning Factory, SSA’s Emerald Meadows and Babuji Jacob, ITAT held that failure to identify the charge deprived the assessee of a proper opportunity to defend itself and violated principles of natural justice. Gangotri Textiles was distinguished because the defective-notice objection there had been raised for the first time before the High Court, whereas Maheswary Granites had specifically raised the issue before CIT(A), which adjudicated it in the assessee’s favour. ITAT therefore found no reason to interfere with CIT(A)’s order and dismissed Revenue’s appeal.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


