PCIT Vs Sun Pharma Sikkim (Gujarat High Court)
Summary: The Gujarat High Court considered the Revenue’s connected Tax Appeal Nos. 183 and 184 of 2020, concerning assessment years 2010-2011 and 2011-2012. Both challenged the Ahmedabad Bench Tribunal’s common order dated 16.05.2019 concerning M/s Sun Pharma Sikkim’s deduction under section 80IE of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessee, a partnership firm constituted by deed dated 15.01.2009, manufactured and sold pharmaceutical products. The judgment records an assignment of the Sikkim unit’s plant, machinery and other assets on 16.01.2009 at a net value of Rs.41,61,35,690/-. It filed nil-income returns for both years after claiming the deduction. The Assessing Officer denied eligibility on the grounds of reconstruction or splitting of an existing business and use of old machinery; alternatively, the officer sought to reduce eligible profits by allocating expenses and other items between related Sun Pharma entities. The Commissioner (Appeals) accepted the deduction and rejected the disputed allocation. The Tribunal dismissed the Revenue’s appeals, partly allowed the assessee’s appeal for 2010-2011 on the scrap issue, and dismissed its appeal for 2011-2012.
On eligibility, the Court reviewed section 80IE, the authorities’ findings about the formation of the Sikkim undertaking, and the evidence concerning transferred machinery. The Commissioner (Appeals) had examined bills and related material, obtained a remand report, and concluded that the Assessing Officer’s treatment of machinery valued at approximately Rs.14.98 crore as old was unsustainable. The Tribunal agreed that the Revenue had failed to show that old machinery exceeded 20% of total plant and machinery. The High Court stressed the absence of an inquiry of original suppliers about when machinery was supplied and found no reason to disturb the concurrent factual findings. It declined to admit the eligibility questions in Appeal 183 (A) and (B) and Appeal 184 (A) and (C).
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


