R S Jhaveri & Co Vs ACIT (ITAT Pune)
₹6 Crore Received Under Bona Fide Family Settlement Not Taxable; Non-Interference Clause Is Merely Incidental: Pune ITAT
In R.S. Jhaveri & Co. v. ACIT, the assessee-firm received ₹6 crore under a family settlement for relinquishing its interest and control over the agency business of Dillinger GTS Ventes, France in favour of another family group. Of this, ₹5.25 crore was received in AY 2014-15 and ₹75 lakh in AY 2016-17.
The Assessing Officer treated the compensation as taxable business income, invoking section 28(va). Alternatively, he proposed taxation as income from other sources or as capital gains arising from a slump sale under section 50B.
The Pune ITAT examined the Memorandum of Understanding and held that it represented a bona fide family settlement intended to resolve disputes and achieve an equitable separation of family businesses. Amounts received under such a family arrangement cannot be treated as taxable income.
The Tribunal further held that:
- Section 50B was inapplicable, as no undertaking was transferred as a going concern.
- Section 28(va) was also inapplicable, since the transaction was not predominantly a non-compete or restrictive-covenant arrangement.
- Clauses restraining the two family groups from interfering with each other’s businesses were merely incidental provisions intended to ensure peaceful implementation of the family settlement.
- Such clauses could not alter the true character of the transaction.
Accordingly, the Tribunal directed deletion of the additions of ₹5.25 crore for AY 2014-15 and ₹75 lakh for AY 2016-17.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.


