Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Corporate Law

Second SLP Not Maintainable After Review Failure Due to Earlier Dismissal: SC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 7289
Case Name
Kangra Central Cooperative Bank Limited Vs Kangra Central Cooperative Bank Pensioners Welfare Association (REGD.) & Ors. (Supreme Court of India)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Kangra Central Cooperative Bank Limited Vs Kangra Central Cooperative Bank Pensioners Welfare Association (REGD.) & Ors. (Supreme Court of India)

The Supreme Court considered a Special Leave Petition (SLP) filed by Kangra Central Cooperative Bank Limited challenging the dismissal of its review petition by the Himachal Pradesh High Court. Before examining the merits of the dispute, the Court first addressed a preliminary objection raised by respondent no. 1 regarding the maintainability of the SLP under Article 136 of the Constitution.

Respondent no. 1 argued that the petition was not maintainable because the original judgment of the Single Judge of the Himachal Pradesh High Court dated 15 May 2012 had already been affirmed by the Division Bench and thereafter challenged before the Supreme Court through SLP (C) No. 16819 of 2024. That SLP had been dismissed on 23 September 2024. Subsequently, the petitioner filed a miscellaneous application seeking recall of the dismissal order. The application was later withdrawn on 20 December 2024 with liberty to approach the High Court through a review petition. According to respondent no. 1, no liberty had been granted to approach the Supreme Court again if the review petition failed. It was further contended that once the earlier challenge had been dismissed, the matter attained finality between the parties and could not be reopened through a fresh proceeding.

The petitioner opposed the objection. It argued that none of the courts had examined its contentions fully on facts and law. The petitioner maintained that it was entitled to a substantive consideration of its case. It also submitted that the law permits a review petition before the High Court even after dismissal of an SLP by the Supreme Court without adjudication on merits. Reliance was placed on judicial precedents to support the proposition that dismissal of an SLP does not necessarily bar review proceedings before the High Court.

The petitioner further submitted that if the impugned judgment remained undisturbed, it could have serious financial consequences for the cooperative bank. It argued that the financial burden could jeopardize the bank’s future operations and adversely affect its customers. According to the petitioner, the bank had the authority to reconsider pension-related schemes and policies in light of financial constraints. It also asserted that the financial liability arising from the dispute substantially exceeded the amounts available to meet such obligations.

The Court sought clarification regarding the number of persons who would be affected and the estimated financial burden. Respondent no. 1 stated that the matter concerned no more than 141 pensioners and 45 spouses of deceased pensioners and that the liability would be approximately ₹30–35 crore. The petitioner, however, estimated the liability at around ₹250 crore.

The Supreme Court declined to enter into the merits of the pension dispute. It observed that the question of maintainability had to be decided first. The Court noted that respondent no. 4, the trust involved in the matter, had supported the petitioner-bank and stated that it was not in a position to pay more than the benefits currently being paid.

The Court then examined the procedural history of the litigation. It noted that the dispute had reached the Supreme Court on three separate occasions. In August 2022, the Court had restored the relevant Letters Patent Appeal to the Division Bench of the High Court for consideration on merits. Thereafter, in February 2024, the Division Bench allowed the appeal filed by respondent no. 1. The petitioner challenged that order before the Supreme Court through an SLP, which was dismissed on 23 September 2024. The Court’s order recorded that there was no reason to interfere with the High Court’s decision while keeping the question of law open.

Following the dismissal of the SLP, the petitioner filed a miscellaneous application seeking recall of the order. That application was withdrawn with liberty to approach the High Court by way of review. The High Court subsequently dismissed the review petition on 30 April 2025.

The Supreme Court examined various precedents dealing with the effect of dismissal of SLPs, review jurisdiction, and the doctrine of merger. It acknowledged that the legal principle permitting review after dismissal of an SLP by a non-speaking order was well settled. The Court referred to decisions including Kunhayammed v. State of Kerala and Khoday Distilleries Ltd. v. Sri Mahadeshwara Sahakara Sakkare Karkhane Ltd., which establish that dismissal of an SLP without granting leave does not result in merger of the High Court judgment into the Supreme Court’s order.

The Court also considered the decision in Manisha Nimesh Mehta, where it had been held that a review petition before the High Court remained maintainable despite dismissal of an SLP because leave had not been granted and therefore the doctrine of merger did not apply.

However, the Court found the facts of the present case materially different. It relied heavily on earlier decisions such as Bussa Overseas and Properties Private Limited v. Union of India, T.K. David v. Kuruppampady Service Cooperative Bank Limited, Upadhyay and Co. v. State of Uttar Pradesh, and the recent decision in Satheesh V.K. v. Federal Bank Limited.

The Court noted that these decisions establish a principle that where a party has already challenged a judgment before the Supreme Court and that challenge has failed, the party cannot obtain a second opportunity to challenge the same judgment unless specific liberty has been granted. The Court emphasized that a review petition may be maintainable before the High Court after dismissal of an SLP, but if the review petition is rejected, the unsuccessful party cannot ordinarily return to the Supreme Court to challenge either the review order or the original judgment unless the Court had expressly granted such liberty.

The Court observed that the petitioner’s earlier SLP had been dismissed on 23 September 2024. Subsequently, the miscellaneous application seeking recall had been withdrawn with liberty only to approach the High Court in review. No liberty had been granted to return to the Supreme Court if the review petition failed.

The Court also examined the High Court’s review order. It noted that part of the High Court’s reasoning suggested that it felt constrained by the earlier dismissal of the SLP. The Supreme Court remarked that such an observation was unnecessary because once liberty to seek review had been granted, the High Court was free to exercise its review jurisdiction independently.

Nevertheless, the Court found that the High Court had also independently concluded that there was no infirmity or illegality in the judgment sought to be reviewed. According to the Supreme Court, this aspect was sufficient to sustain the review order. Since the review jurisdiction is limited and circumscribed, the High Court’s conclusion that no ground for review existed could not be interfered with.

The Supreme Court further explained that if the petitioner had succeeded in review, it would not have been an aggrieved party and therefore would have had no occasion to approach the Supreme Court again. Conversely, if review had resulted in a new judgment adverse to respondent no. 1, the latter could have challenged the review order because the original judgment would then cease to exist. However, where review was dismissed and the original judgment remained unchanged, allowing another SLP would effectively provide the petitioner with a second opportunity to challenge a matter that had already attained finality.

The Court stressed that it was not sitting in appeal over its earlier order dated 23 September 2024. It held that the petitioner could not be permitted to re-agitate the same issues before the Supreme Court after the earlier SLP had been dismissed and the review petition had failed.

Referring extensively to the decisions in Upadhyay and Co., T.K. David, Bussa Overseas, and Satheesh V.K., the Court held that entertaining such a petition would be contrary to public policy and inconsistent with the principle of finality of litigation. It reiterated that while a party does not require liberty to file a review petition after dismissal of an SLP by a non-speaking order, the same party cannot return to the Supreme Court after failure of the review petition unless specific liberty to do so had been granted.

The Court also addressed submissions regarding a pending reference before a larger Bench on related issues. Relying on Union Territory of Ladakh v. Jammu and Kashmir National Conference, it reiterated that a mere reference to a larger Bench does not suspend the operation of existing law. Courts are required to follow the law as it presently stands unless specifically directed otherwise.

Having accepted the preliminary objection, the Supreme Court held that the Special Leave Petition was not maintainable and dismissed it in limine without entering into the merits of the underlying pension dispute.

Before concluding, the Court exercised its powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to clarify a factual aspect of the dispute. At the request of the petitioner, it directed that the liabilities and claims against the petitioner-bank would be confined to 141 pensioners and 45 spouses of deceased pensioners, making a total of 186 persons. The Court expressly stated that this direction was being issued in the peculiar facts of the case to avoid further litigation and would not constitute a binding precedent.

Accordingly, the preliminary objection was upheld, the SLP was dismissed as not maintainable, certain interlocutory applications were allowed, and the Court clarified that its factual direction limiting the affected beneficiaries would not alter its legal conclusions regarding maintainability.

FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.