Bhagyalaxmi Co-Operative Bank Ltd. Vs Babaldas Amtharam Patel (D) Through Legal Representatives & Others (Supreme Court of India)
Surety Not Fully Off the Hook: Supreme Court Says Guarantor Liable for Original Loan, Not Unauthorized Overdrawals
The Supreme Court in held that where a bank permits the borrower to withdraw amounts far beyond the sanctioned credit limit without the consent or knowledge of the guarantors, the guarantors cannot be saddled with liability for such excess withdrawals. However, the Court clarified that the sureties are still liable for the original sanctioned amount for which they had agreed to stand guarantee.
In this case, the borrower had obtained a cash-credit limit of ₹4 lakh, but allegedly, in connivance with bank officials, withdrew amounts far in excess of the sanctioned limit. The Tribunal had held the guarantors liable only to the extent of ₹4 lakh with interest, whereas the Gujarat High Court held that guarantors must either be liable for the entire amount or not liable at all.
Reversing the High Court, the Supreme Court examined Sections 133 and 139 of the Indian Contract Act and held that Section 133 squarely applied. The Court emphasized that any variance in the contract without the surety’s consent discharges the surety only for transactions subsequent to the variance, and not for the original obligation itself.
The Court rejected the guarantors’ reliance on Section 139, observing that there was no impairment of their eventual remedy against the principal borrower. The mere fact that the bank allowed excess withdrawals did not completely extinguish the guarantee obligation.
Accordingly, the Supreme Court restored the Tribunal’s view and held that the guarantors remained liable only to the extent of the original ₹4 lakh loan along with applicable interest, but not for the excess overdrawn amounts permitted by the bank without their consent.
FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






