Mukesh Mohanlal Vaghela Vs DCIT (ITAT Ahmedabad)
ITAT Ahmedabad: Seized Diaries with Running Ledger Held Conclusive—Additions u/s 69C Sustained; Revenue Succeeds on Interest for AY 2020-21
The Income Tax Appellate Tribunal dismissed a batch of eight appeals filed by the assessee for AYs 2013-14 to 2020-21 and allowed the Revenue’s appeal for AY 2020-21, upholding substantial additions based on seized diaries recovered during search in the Ratnamani Group cases.
The Tribunal held that the handwritten diaries seized from Shri Prakash M. Sanghvi, containing a distinct, continuous running ledger titled “Mukesh Ratnajyot / Mukeshbhai RJ”, constituted reliable and corroborated evidence against the assessee. The ledger showed opening balances, repeated debit/credit entries, interest computation and carry-forward balances over multiple years, clearly establishing a systematic financial relationship. Independent corroboration was found where several diary entries exactly matched the assessee’s disclosed investments and where other entries were corroborated with bank statements of Ratnamani Group entities. The plea that the documents were “dumb” or merely third-party papers was rejected.
The ITAT affirmed that:
- Additions under section 69C based on incremental negative peak theory were valid; denial of telescoping of opening balances of time-barred years was justified.
- The assessee’s argument of double taxation (contending that the same ledger was taxed in the hands of Shri Prakash M. Sanghvi as land-trading receipts) was rejected. The Tribunal held that protective additions in Sanghvi’s case were deleted precisely because substantive additions were made in the hands of the assessee, who was found to be the payer/financier. Receipt and outflow can be taxed in different hands based on roles.
- Section 115BBE was correctly applied wherever additions under sections 69C/69A survived; interest under sections 234A/B/C was consequential.
On interest income, the Tribunal reversed the CIT(A) for AY 2020-21, holding that systematic and continuous interest entries in the seized ledgers evidenced real accrual/receipt, not notional income. Accordingly, the interest addition u/s 56 for AY 2020-21 was restored.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF ITAT AHMEDABAD
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




