DCIT Vs Swati Menthol & Allied Chemicals Ltd. (ITAT Delhi)
Reopening After 4 Years Invalid Without PCIT Sanction: ITAT Delhi Quashes 148 Notice Against Swati Menthol & Dismisses Revenue Appeal
Assessee, Swati Menthol & Allied Chemicals Ltd., engaged in manufacturing & sale of menthol products, originally filed return for AY 2015-16 declaring income of ₹9.76 crore (normal) & ₹17.04 crore (MAT). Assessment was reopened on 30.03.2021 based on I&CI Wing’s input regarding share capital & share premium of ₹3.01 crore received during the year. Notice u/s 148 was issued after obtaining sanction from the Addl. CIT, Range-1, Moradabad. AO completed reassessment making addition of ₹3,01,50,000 u/s 68 & disallowance of ₹7,14,555.
Before CIT(A), Assessee challenged the jurisdiction of reopening contending that since AY 2015-16 was beyond 4 years from end of AY 2016-17, the approval must be obtained from the PCIT, not Addl. CIT, as mandated by section 151(1). CIT(A) accepted Assessee’s objection & deleted the additions.
Before Tribunal, Assessee raised jurisdiction as part of its cross-objection, relying on the Supreme Court’s order in ITO v. Rinku R. Rai (454 ITR 35) affirming Bombay High Court judgment that Addl. CIT sanction is invalid for reopening beyond 4 years; only sanction from PCIT or higher authority is legally valid. Tribunal examined the record (pages 4–6) & found that notice u/s 148 was indeed sanctioned only by the Addl. CIT.
Tribunal held that:
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





