In re Tata Autocomp Gotion Green Energy Solutions Systems Limited (CAAR Mumbai)
The Authority examined the applicant’s request for an advance ruling concerning the applicability of Entry No. 527B of Notification No. 50/2017-Customs, dated 30 June 2017, as amended by Notification No. 2/2021-Customs. The applicant manufactures batteries or battery packs for electrically operated vehicles and hybrid motor vehicles and imports lithium-ion cells while claiming the concessional Basic Customs Duty (BCD) rate of 5% under Entry 527B. The issues raised relate to four scenarios involving imported lithium-ion cells: (i) cells used as replacements due to defects or warranty conditions, (ii) cells that become obsolete during manufacturing and are later sold as scrap, (iii) cells found defective after import and not issued to production, and (iv) determination of interest liability if benefits are denied.
The Authority noted that classification issues fall under Section 28H(2) of the Customs Act. It examined the legal framework prescribed under the Customs Tariff Act, Chapter Notes, and HSN Explanatory Notes. As per Rule 1 of the General Rules for Interpretation (GRI), classification must be determined by the terms of the headings and relevant notes. Entry 527B allows concessional duty on “lithium-ion cell for use in the manufacture of battery or battery pack of electrically operated vehicle or hybrid motor vehicle,” subject to Condition No. 9, which requires compliance with the Customs (Import of Goods at Concessional Rate of Duty or for Specified End Use) Rules, 2022 (IGCR Rules). These rules govern imports at concessional duty rates and include requirements such as prior intimation, record-keeping, continuity bond, and reporting of usage.
The IGCR Rules, 2022 allow imports at reduced duty rates when goods are used for specified end-use purposes. They also provide mechanisms for handling defective or unutilized goods, including options for re-export or home-consumption clearance with payment of duty and interest. Rule 10 outlines provisions for re-export or clearance of defective or unutilized goods within six months (extendable by three months), while Rule 11 prescribes recovery of duty and interest where conditions are not met.
Regarding Scenario 1, the Authority observed that “manufacture,” as defined under Rule 3(1)(i) of the IGCR Rules, requires the emergence of a new product with distinct nature, character, use, or name. Imported lithium-ion cells used as replacement parts in existing batteries do not result in the emergence of a new product. Although the exemption requires use of cells in the manufacture of battery packs, it does not require sale of the manufactured battery packs. However, the use of cells for replacement of existing batteries does not constitute “manufacture” and therefore does not satisfy the condition of being used “in the manufacture of battery or battery pack.” Consequently, the exemption is not available in Scenario 1. Any unutilized or defective quantity would attract duty and interest under Rules 10(3), 10(4), and 11.
In Scenario 2, the applicant explained that certain cells issued for manufacture become obsolete or damaged during the manufacturing process and are later sold as scrap. The Authority noted that manufacturing processes inherently involve certain losses or rejections, and goods lost in the process are still considered to have been used in manufacture. The phrase “for use in manufacture” indicates that the exemption applies to all inputs put to use in manufacturing, regardless of whether they form part of the final product. However, the IGCR Rules do not provide specific provisions for scrap or waste generated during manufacturing. Rule 10 specifically governs “unutilized or defective goods,” and since scrapped cells do not become part of the final product and no limits for such losses are provided in the rules, these goods are treated as unutilized or defective. Therefore, the exemption benefit is not available, and duty and interest would apply for such quantities under Rules 10 and 11.
The applicant relied on the Samsung Noida CAAR ruling related to inputs scrapped during manufacture of display assemblies. The Authority held that the ruling is not applicable because it relates to different goods and factual circumstances. The applicant also referred to the Allahabad High Court decision in Jhunjhunwala Vanaspati Ltd., which addressed loss during transit; the Authority found it inapplicable because the present issue relates to waste generated during manufacturing, not incidental losses. Similarly, reliance on the Goodluck Garments case concerning excess wastage over input-output norms was held to be irrelevant.
In Scenario 3, the applicant queried the eligibility of cells found defective after import but before being issued to production. The Authority considered such goods as unutilized or defective within Rule 10 and therefore not eligible for the exemption, making them liable to duty and interest.
Regarding Scenario 4, the Authority held that if exemption benefits are denied, interest under Section 28AA applies from the date of import until actual payment of duty.
Thus, across all scenarios, the Authority concluded that exemption under Entry 527B is available only when imported lithium-ion cells are actually used in the manufacture of battery or battery packs resulting in emergence of a new product. Cells used for replacement, those scrapped during manufacture, or those defective before use are treated as unutilized or defective goods and not eligible for the concessional rate, attracting duty and interest as per IGCR Rules, 2022.
FULL TEXT OF THE ORDER OF CUSTOMS AUTHORITY OF ADVANCE RULING, MUMBAI
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



