Ramathal & Ors. Vs K. Rajamani (Dead) (Supreme Court of India)
The Supreme Court, in Ramathal & Ors. Vs K. Rajamani (Dead), examined the validity of property transfers executed through a Power of Attorney allegedly obtained by fraudulent misrepresentation. The dispute concerned land situated in East Ayakudi Village, Tamil Nadu, belonging to the plaintiffs, who had authorised Rajamani to develop the property into smaller plots and obtain necessary government approvals. However, taking advantage of their illiteracy and simplicity, Rajamani allegedly incorporated additional clauses authorising him to sell, mortgage, gift and otherwise transfer the property. On the very day the Power of Attorney was registered, he executed two sale deeds transferring 100 cents of land to his father and brother for a total consideration of ₹12,000, substantially below the guideline value. The Trial Court dismissed the plaintiffs’ suit, but the First Appellate Court found fraudulent misrepresentation and decreed the suit. The Madras High Court reversed that decision in second appeal, holding that the doctrine of non est factum had neither been specifically pleaded nor framed as an issue.
The Supreme Court considered the scope and application of the doctrine of non est factum, which permits a person to challenge a document signed under a fundamental mistake regarding its nature or character. Referring to Bismillah v. Janeshwar Prasad, Ningawwa v. Byrappa and Saunders v. Anglia Building Society, the Court explained the distinction between fraudulent misrepresentation concerning the character of a document, which renders the transaction void, and misrepresentation concerning its contents, which ordinarily makes it voidable. The Court found that the plaintiffs had sufficiently pleaded the circumstances constituting non est factum and had established their case through documentary and oral evidence. Rajamani’s conduct in immediately transferring the property to close relatives at an undervalued consideration, the delayed payment of deficient stamp duty, and the absence of reliable documentary evidence establishing payment of sale consideration supported the First Appellate Court’s findings. The Court further held that a transaction found to be void does not require a separate decree of cancellation, and subsequent transfers made under an invalid Power of Attorney cannot acquire legal validity.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.





