Tirupati Shopping Centre Premises Co-operative Society Ltd. Vs Shabayesha Construction Company Pvt. Ltd. (Bombay High Court)
Summary: The Bombay High Court, in Tirupati Shopping Centre Premises Co-operative Society Limited v. Shabayesha Construction Company Private Limited, Writ Petition (Stamp) No. 9105 of 2021, decided on 22 April 2021, dismissed a housing society’s challenge to an arbitral order rejecting its jurisdictional objection under Section 16 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The Division Bench held that a deemed conveyance certificate issued under Section 11 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963 (MOFA), does not conclusively adjudicate the title of the parties or prevent arbitration of independent contractual claims. The Court distinguished between rights in rem and subordinate rights in personam, holding that claims for specific performance of a memorandum of understanding, development-related contractual obligations and monetary damages could be adjudicated by an Arbitral Tribunal where the parties had agreed to arbitration. The Court also applied the restrictive principles governing constitutional interference with interlocutory arbitral orders and imposed costs of ₹50,000 on the society for pursuing a writ petition that unnecessarily obstructed the arbitral proceedings.
The underlying controversy arose from agreements for sale executed by Shabayesha Construction Company Pvt. Ltd. with purchasers of units in a shopping centre at Santacruz West, Mumbai. The petitioner society alleged that the developer had failed to execute the required deed of conveyance, despite its obligation under the flat purchase agreements and MOFA. Its first application for deemed conveyance, filed in 2016, was dismissed on 22 February 2017 because an occupation certificate had not been issued. The society thereafter filed a fresh application on 3 March 2018. By an order dated 10 August 2018, the Competent Authority allowed the application and issued a certificate for unilateral deemed conveyance in respect of land measuring 1,718.2 square metres. In doing so, the authority rejected the developer’s objections concerning unsold premises, basements, parking spaces and the balance FSI/TDR. The developer did not separately challenge that deemed conveyance order.




