Chartered Accountants Association, Surat

Ref: CAAS/Representations/2021-22/04

Date: 14/05/2021

Commissioner of Police,
Office of the Police Commissioner,
Police Bhavan,
Surat – 395001

Sub: Disgraceful Actions by Police Department

Respected Sir,

Our Association, Chartered Accountants Association Surat (“CAAS”), works for the betterment of CA Fraternity and improved working conditions of our members.

We appreciate your work relating to law and order with respect to pandemic for more than a year. Your tireless endeavor to protect the citizens of Surat is praiseworthy. We are heartily thankful on behalf of our association in this regard.

We would like to bring to your notice that Chartered Accountants are an integral part of the taxation system. Only due to their timely response in liaison with their clients, the tax assessment and its collection takes place on time. Needless to say such tax money goes on to pay for administrative, development and welfare purposes.

An atrocious environment is created where matters like illegal arrests, detention and mental harassment to ordinary citizens is a new normal. Amidst this environment, officers have now started making arrests without following due legal processes like issue of summons u/s 160 of CrPC, making illegal arrests without making prior inquiries to the satisfaction of the Investigating Officer, illegal detention of individuals without sufficient cause etc.

We regret to inform that now even the Police has started booking members belonging to the respectable fraternity of Chartered Accountants for bonafide actions done by these professionals in their routine course of work on behalf of their clients. In one such incident viz. M/s Sahyog Enterprise Bogus Billing Case (FIR No.11210015210109 dt.07/04/2021, DCB Police Station), one of our member, CA Shri Bharat Rupareliya was made accused in FIR dt.07/04/2021 without following due process of law. He was also subject to tremendous mental and emotional harassment besides the following:

1. Neither was he given summons u/s 160 for CrPC, which is clear deviation of the established law and also a clear violation of Article 22 of the Constitution of India.

2. Nor were the family members of CA Bharat Rupareliya were informed after the arrest.

3. Verbal abuse of staff (including female employees) by the police officials at the office place of CA Bharat Rupareliya during the arrest.

4. Keys of the office of CA Bharat Rupareliya were snatched from employees and despite confiscation of documents required by the Police, the office was locked illegally without official seal from 07/04/2021 8 pm to 09/04/2021 11 am.

5. Illegal detention of CA Bharat Rupareliya under the name of Judicial Custody for more than 1 month (07/04/2021 to 11/05/2021) without any sufficient cause or evidence.

This poses serious question on the working of the Police with respect to the areas of taxation laws like GST over which it does not have direct jurisdiction, still it holds CA legal hostages for days without any evidence or even without any intent to investigate further to obtain those evidence. Later CA is released by the Hon’ble Court of the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Surat for lack of evidence u/s 169 of CrPC (Copy Enclosed). This further raises question as who is responsible for the loss of reputation, man hours, livelihood and over all the stigma on the noble profession. Here it is pertinent to recall the golden words of wisdom of Benjamin Franklin

“It is better 100 guilty Persons should escape than that one innocent Person should suffer”

Our Representation:

We expect more maturity and responsible behaviour from the Police Department when allegations are made on citizens and especially on revered citizens like Chartered Accountants. We also demand an inquiry in the said matter and suitable punitive action be taken against those found guilty, so that no such incidents recur in future on any of our member. Your timely action and response on the said matter would be highly appreciated.

Thanks & Regards,

For Chartered Accountants Association, Surat.

President | Secretary

Ref: Order of Hon’ble Court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Surat on report of Police u/s 169 of CrPC

Download Letter on Alleged Disgraceful Actions by Police Department

More Under CA, CS, CMA


  1. Shukla says:

    Yes .
    Notice was essential under 41 crpc .
    Training to police is needed as Crpc was amended in 2008 and lot of old police officers are not aware about massive amendements .
    169 crpc certainally says that there is no evidence .
    Infsct not only this case , otherwise also police must avoid arbitrary arrest which they arrest without clinching eveidences . Here is much discretion to police and court .There is need of rationalization in arrest and it needs quantified as when to arrest . In a year about 1 cr people are arrested ( 30 to 32 lakhs arrest in ipc fir +22 lakhs arrest in local and state laws , non ipc fir + 11 lakhs arrest in railways + 15 to 20 laks arrest in preventive cases approximatily and remaining unaccounted detention in our criminal justice system just call and made him sit at police station may be wighout reason etc ). Thus here my submission is it is right time to quantify parameters when prrson will be arrested by police and court both .let citizen must know about arrest code like other codes . What is our conviction rate , 30 to 40 % ? If so why to arrest 60 % ? Who is going to give clean chit ? Where they will get job ? Permanant disiability and it is irrepairable .
    State whose duty is welfare , citizen who has made their preamble and civic soviety must think that discretion of either agencies are not good one . Law commission may take up the matter .
    What ever may be exhustive training is needed to all concerned as to strengthened our democracy .

  2. Sharad joshi says:

    Nice representation . It’s not only in Surat. At other places also such instances have been noticed. Few people having contacts in department tries to trouble a member. Our institute should do something but do all Central council have time !

  3. Sonu sidh says:

    This happens to many protestors of CAA and farm laws in gujrat but ca fraternity was always silent.. suddenly when they come under same treatment they realise the “laws”.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Search Posts by Date

June 2021