Rakesh Jayantibhai Patel Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
Loans from father sisters duly proved with PAN, bank statements, land sale deed confirmations; CIT(A) wrongly sustained addition on mere suspicion
Assessee, engaged in AutoCAD design work, filed his return declaring ₹2,91,400. Based on information that he invested ₹20,00,000 in Cruso Granito Pvt. Ltd., the case was reopened u/s 147. Assessee explained that this investment was funded through savings & unsecured loans from his father and two sisters.
AO partly accepted the explanation but treated ₹11,70,000 as unexplained cash credit u/s 68 and taxed it u/s 115BBE. The loans disputed were:
– ₹4,80,000 from father
– ₹4,40,000 from sister Nitaben
– ₹2,50,000 from sister Alpaben
CIT(A) examined the bank accounts & accepted most of the loans but doubted ₹1,30,000 from the father, only because there were some cash deposits (₹49,500 each) in his bank account before giving the loan. CIT(A) held that only ₹1,20,000 could be explained from land sale proceeds already accepted by AO, and sustained an addition of ₹1,30,000 while deleting ₹10,40,000.
Before Tribunal, Assessee submitted full evidence for the father’s loan:
– PAN & Aadhaar of father
– Confirmation letter
– Complete bank statement
– Agricultural landholding (Form 7/12)
– Registered sale deed showing ₹6,00,000 received from sale of land
Tribunal noted that the father’s identity, capacity & genuineness were fully established. Out of ₹10,80,000 loan from father, ₹6,00,000 came from land sale-accepted by AO. The remaining was explained through past agricultural income & normal banking transactions. Tribunal held that CIT(A) rejected ₹1,30,000 only on assumptions, ignoring evidence. Cash deposits of ₹49,500 each do not prove lack of source when the lender has agricultural income, land sale receipts & banking history.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




