Amee Govindbhai Patel Vs ITO (ITAT Ahmedabad)
Accommodation Entry Theory Fails – Repayment of Loans Saves Assessee- ITAT Ahmedabad- No Benefit, No Addition – ITAT Deletes Rs.55 Lakh Bogus Loan Addition
The case arose from information shared by Investigation Wing regarding one Amit J. Shah, an entry operator, who admitted to providing accommodation entries through 133 bank accounts of Indian Bank, Patan. It was alleged that Assessee was a beneficiary & received unsecured loans through these channels. AO reopened the assessment & made addition of Rs.55,00,000 treating loans from 7 parties as unexplained.
Before Tribunal, Assessee submitted that amounts received as loans from said parties were duly returned through account payee cheques. Confirmations, ITRs & bank statements of lenders were produced. It was argued that since the loans were repaid, there was no benefit & no escapement of income. Moreover, AO had wrongly invoked s.69A (unexplained money) whereas the issue, if at all, related to s.68. It was further argued that reopening itself was bad in law as AO formed belief without applying mind & on borrowed satisfaction, despite having information that loans were repaid.
Tribunal observed that both Investigation Wing’s report & Assessee’s submissions clearly showed loans were received & subsequently repaid to same parties by RTGS. If money was immediately returned, Assessee could not be treated as beneficiary of accommodation entry. Once repayment is established, no addition is warranted. Reliance was placed on Gujarat HC in CIT (Rajkot) Vs Ayachi Chandrashekhar Narsangji (TA 992/2013) which held that no addition u/s 68 can be sustained where credits are subsequently repaid. Tribunal also referred to Gujarat HC in Amee Mahasukhlal Parekh Vs ITO (SCA/18254/2022) holding that reopening is invalid if information already shows no escapement due to repayment. Accordingly, Tribunal held both on merits & on law that reassessment u/s 147 was invalid & addition u/s 69A unsustainable. The appeal of Assessee was allowed in entirety.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.




