Hewlett Packard India Sales Pvt. Ltd Vs Commissioner of Customs (Import) (Supreme Court of India)
Whether Automatic Data Processing Machines(ADP) can be said to be portable or not so as to attract a particular entry for levy of customs duty?
An interesting question arose in this case where the Appellant and Lenovo contended that the ADP imported by it was classifiable under the entry 84715000 as against the department’s classification under the entry 84713010 since they could not be said to be portable. The Supreme Court discussed in detail the meaning of the term portable and also cautioned against use of the term portable in Wikipedia which could not be termed as authentic as it was merely crowd sourced platform for definition and placed reliance on reliance sources like Oxford dictionary of computer science etc and arrived at a conclusion that in order to be portable, the weight was not the only factor rather the ability to carry around easily and suitability for daily transit was determinative factor and when seen in this light the ADP imported by the Appellants being not laptop or similar item was correctly classified under entry 84715000 and thus eligible for concessional manner of calculating duty and thus the assessee’s SLP was allowed.
We must hold that the Concerned Goods are not portable for the reasons that Firstly, the diagonal dimension of the Concerned Goods being minimum of the length of 18.5 inches and the same needs to be transported along with the power cable as well as the applicable stand in most cases if it is to be mounted and; secondly there being no protective case designed by the markets for daily transport for these Concerned Goods. Such requirements make the Concerned Goods unable to be carried around easily during daily transit. We, thus, hold that the Concerned Goods are not ‘portable’.
It goes without saying that since the customs authorities wanted to classify the goods differently, the burden of proof to showcase the same was on them, which they failed to discharge. Hence under the prevalent self-assessment procedure, the classification submitted by the Appellants must be accepted.
This judgement will be helpful in deciphering the meaning of various entries under the Indirect tax law.
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.



