M. P. Ganesan Vs The Commercial Tax Officer (Madras High Court)
The issue under consideration is whether the order passed by AO by denying the cross examination request of custom banker as well as bank officials is justified in law?
High Court states that, a perusal of the impugned orders indicates that the directions of this Court in the first round of litigation have not been taken into account in proper perspective in finalizing the assessments. This Court had specifically directed that a proper enquiry be made by the Assessing Officer, which would not only include examination of all materials procured from the Customs and the Income Tax Department, but also on an independent application of mind of those materials and a proper and effective opportunity being extended to the petitioner to substantiate his repeated contention that he is unconnected with the import transactions. However, the Assessing Officer has merely relied on the same materials which were already available on record, to pass the impugned order. The observations of the Assessing Officer indicate the cursory and arbitrary manner in which the assessments have been completed. Moreover, despite a request for cross- examination of the Customs Broker as well as bank officials by the assessee, the Assessing Officer does not even refer to the request, let alone consider the same. High Court thus of the view that the impugned assessments have not been framed in a proper manner. Though they inclined to quash the assessments in full, they have remit the same to the file of the officer to be re-done de novo solely.
FULL TEXT OF THE HIGH COURT ORDER /JUDGEMENT
The petitioner is a proprietor of Tvl.S.R.S. Traders, a dealer in electronic goods and stationery. The background to this matter is as follows:
(i) The petitioner was assessed for the periods 2010-11 and 2011-12 in terms of the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Value Added Tax Act, 2006 (TNVAT Act) on 21.03.2013. The petitioner has filed applications seeking rectification of certain errors in the orders of assessments and these applications came to be rejected on 21.11.2016.
(ii) The orders of rejection came to be challenged before this Court in W.P.Nos.42574 and 42575 of 2017. Upon a detailed consideration of the facts involved, this Court was of the view that the case was a peculiar one in so far as the very basis of the assessment had been challenged by the petitioner.
2. The facts as recorded at the original instance are as follows:
(i) There was an audit inspection in the premises of the petitioner/dealer and two audit slips had been issued during the months of November 2012 and June 2013. The audit slips were to the effect that the petitioner had engaged in high value transactions related to imports of mobile phones, indicating the petitioners’ TIN and PAN numbers. The audit slips contained a direction to the Assessing Officer to take necessary action for finalization of assessment under
the provisions of the TNVAT Act.
(ii) Based on the direction contained in the audit slips, proceedings for assessment were commenced by the Assessing Officer alleging that no returns have been filed reporting turnover from the sale of the imports conducted.
(iii) Since there was no response by the petitioner, the assessments were completed ex-parte. Thereafter the petitioner, upon receipts of the orders of assessment, sought information under the Right to Information Act, obtained copies of the audit slips dated 26.11.2012 and 10.07.2013 and approached the Assessing Authority by way of an application under Section 84 of the TNVAT Act for rectification of the errors allegedly contained in the orders of assessment.
(iv) It also appears that proceedings had been initiated by the Income Tax Department on the basis of similar allegations regarding high value imports carried out by the petitioner.
(v) According to the petitioner, enquiries were conducted by the Income Tax Department with the Kotak Mahindra Bank, Mylapore, Standard Chartered Bank, Rajaji Salai and DCB Bank, Broadway, when it came to light that current accounts had been opened in the name of the petitioner utilising its TIN and PAN numbers and transactions were carried out through those accounts.
(vi) At para 6 of the affidavit filed in support of this writ petition, the petitioner states that the Income Tax Department has exonorated the petitioner in the light of the enquiry conducted by it and since, according to him, the bank accounts as aforesaid, did not relate to the petitioner at all.
(vii) The Petitioner thus filed application in terms of Section 84 before the VAT authorities contending that the name of the petitioners’ concern as well as its TIN and PAN numbers had been misused by a third party.
(viii) Despite the detailed submissions made in the Section 84 applications, the Assessing Officer came to reject the same on 21.11.2016 stating that the petitioner had neither bothered to file objections to the pre-assessment notices nor appeals challenging the assessment orders, no monthly returns had been filed and rejecting the request of the petitioner for the conduct of a detailed enquiry in regard to the transactions based on which the assessments have been framed. Challenging the aforesaid orders under Section 84, the petitioner initiated the first round of litigation in W.P.Nos.42574 and 42575 of 2017.
(ix) Noting the aforesaid facts this Court moulded the relief claimed by the petitioner in the first round, i.e., for a set aside of the orders of rectification under Section 84, proceeding to set aside the orders of assessment itself. At paragraph 6, this Court states as follows:
6. Thus, as already stated above, the case on hand is being a very peculiar case, this Court is inclined to mould the relief, sought for by the petitioner. Accordingly, both the Writ Petitions are allowed, and the impugned orders, dated 21.11.2016 are set aside. Consequently, the ex parte assessment orders, dated 21.03.2013 and 24.12.2013 are also set aside and the matters are remanded to the first respondent at the stage of the show cause notices. The first respondent is directed to ask necessary enquiries with the Customs Department, Income Tax Department and the Banks, viz., Kotak Mahindra Bank, Mylapore, Standard Chartered Bank, Rajaji Salai and DCB Bank, Broadway, where, transactions have been effected, and after receipt of the requisite information, the first respondent is directed to issue fresh show cause notice to the petitioner, and thereafter proceed with the matter in accordance with law. Considering the peculiar facts and circumstances, the second respondent is directed to disclose the information secured by them as and when a request is made by the first respondent. No costs. Consequently, connected Writ Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.
3. Pursuant to order dated 04.07.2017, the Assessing Authority issues notices dated 27.06.2019, the operative portion of which are as follows:
…….
Thiru. M.P. Ganesan, Proprietor of Tvl.S.R.S. Traders, dealers in Electronic and Stationeries, doing business at No.41, Bharthipuram, Main Street, Shenoy Nagar, Chennai – 600 030 were assessed on a total and taxable turnover of Rs.11,73,55,009.00 for the year 2010-11 under TNVAT Act 2006 and orders passed in the reference cited.
………..
…………
As per the direction of the Hon’ble High Court Order/direction, enquiries made with the Branch Manager, Kotak Mahindra Bank, Mylapore Branch, DCB Bank, Parrys Corner Branch, Standard Chartered Bank, Rajaji Salai and the Principal Commissioner of Customs, New Customs House, Meenmbakkam. Chennai and obtained the detailed report of holding Current Account and Import, etc. as detailed below:
1.Kotak Mahindra, Mylapore Branch letter dated 16.03.2019.
(a) Application filed for opening of Platina Current Account on 20.11.2010.
(b) Current Account No.413011022599 was opened.
(c) The place of business has been verified by Mr.C.V.Raja, Sales Manager, ID. 12561.
(d) Photo identity has been verified.
(e) Pan car, Ration Card, Sales Tax (TNVAT Act) Registration Certificate and signature of the proprietor of the company has been verified with reference to originals.
2. Standard & Chartered Bank, Rajai Salai Branch
(a) Application filed for opening of Current Account on 11.04.2011.
(b) Current Account No.42705479702 was opened.
(c) Customer met in person at Office on 04.11.2011 at 11.00 AM.
(d) The place of business has been verified by Mr.Hemos, EMP. ID.1355207.
(e) Pan card, Ration Card, Sales Tax(TNVAT Act), Registration Certificate and signature of the proprietor of the company has been verified with reference to originals.
3. DCB Bank Limited, Parrys Corner Branch.
(a) Application filed for opening of Current Account on 29.06.2011.
(b) Nominated by the Proprietor is Tmt.G.Muthurani, Spouse.
(c) Current Account No.09721300000550 was opened.
(d) The place of business has been verified by S.Hemalathan, Manager Development, ID No.H.43.
(e) PAN Card and Ration Card and signature of the proprietor of the company has been verified with reference to originals by Thiru C.v.Raja.R.V.09586. The dealer has made Credit/Debit transactions with the above Banks using current accounts as detailed below.
1. Kotak Mahindra, Mylapore Branch.C.A/c.413011022599,
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






