Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Goods and Services Tax

No re-open assessments if period to retain Books of account expired: HC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2019 taxguru.in 2605
Case Name
MCP Enterprises Vs. State of Kerala (Kerala High Court)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

MCP Enterprises Vs. State of Kerala (Kerala High Court)

Writ petitions are disposed by upholding the retrospective operation of Section 42(3) of the KVAT Act, but declaring that the power to re-open assessments under the said provision cannot be exercised in relation to such assessments where the period for which the assessee concerned is obliged to retain the Books of account under Rule 58(20) of the KVAT Rules has expired. The retrospective operation of Section 42(3) of the KVAT Act will thus stand controlled by the period of limitation aforementioned, and the legality of the notices/orders impugned in these writ petitions shall stand determined by the said declaration.

FULL TEXT OF THE HIGH COURT ORDER /JUDGEMENT

In these batch of writ petitions, the petitioner/assessees impugn the pre-assessment notices/assessment orders issued to them to complete assessments of escaped turnover by invoking the provisions of Section 42(3) of the Kerala Value Added Tax Act [hereinafter referred to as the “KVAT Act”]. It is the common case in all these writ petitions that the period envisaged for re-opening assessments under Section 25 of the KVAT Act had expired by the time the notices for re-opening assessments, invoking Section 42(3) of the KVAT Act, were issued to them. The petitioners therefore contend that in such cases, the Revenue cannot invoke Section 42(3) of the KVAT Act to re-open assessments that have already become final under the KVAT Act.

2. To appreciate the issue raised in these writ petitions, one has to first notice the statutory provisions under the KVAT Act. As per the Scheme of the KVAT Act, the assessment procedure commences with the filing of a return by the assessee. If the return filed by the assessee conforms to the requirement under the KVAT Act and Rules, in respect of the details of turnover to be furnished and the tax to be paid thereon, and there is no query raised by the Revenue within the period prescribed for the same, the assessment to tax is deemed completed as a self-assessment to tax by the assessee under Section 21 of the KVAT Act. If an assessee does not file a return as contemplated by the KVAT Act and Rules or files a defective return, then the assessment is completed on best judgment basis by the Revenue after following the procedure under Section 22 of the KVAT Act. In certain cases, as enumerated under Section 24 of the KVAT Act, an assessment can be completed pursuant to consideration of audit objections in relation to the details furnished by the assessee along with his returns. The assessments completed under Sections 21, 22 and 24 can still be re-opened in terms of 25 of the KVAT Act to assess such turnover as has escaped assessment to tax in an earlier assessment. The power to assess escaped turnover under Section 25 has, however, to be exercised within the period stipulated under the Act for the exercise of such power. The said period was five years from the end of the assessment year concerned till 31.3.2017, and was extended to six years from the end of the assessment year concerned thereafter.

3. Section 42 of the KVAT Act, as it stood till 12.11.2016, read as follows:

“42. Audit of accounts and certification of returns :- (1) Every dealer whose total turnover in a year exceeds rupees forty lakhs shall get his accounts audited annually by a Chartered Accountant or Cost Accountant and shall submit copy of the audited statement of accounts and certificate, in the manner prescribed.

Provided that a co-operative society registered or deemed to be registered under the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, 1969 (21 of 1969), may in lieu of the statement and certificate mentioned above, submit a copy of the audited statement of accounts and certificate issued by the Registrar of Co-operative Societies on or before 31 st day of December of the year succeeding to the year to which annual return relates.

(2) Where any dealer detects any omission or mistake in the annual return submitted by him with reference to the audited figures, he shall file revised annual return rectifying the mistake or omission along with the audit certificate. Where, as a result of such revision, the tax liability increases, the revised return shall be accompanied by proof of payment of such tax, interest due thereon under sub-section (5) of section 31, and penal interest, calculated at twice the rate specified under sub-section (5) of section 31:

Provided that this sub-section shall not apply to a dealer against whom any penal action is initiated in respect of such omission or mistake under any of the provisions of this Act.”

By a notification dated 13.11.2016, the Section was amended to insert a new sub section therein, with retrospective effect from 01.04.2005, the date on which the KVAT Act came into force in the State of Kerala. Sub Section (3) of Section 42, that was inserted, reads as follows:

“(3) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in this Act, if a dealer,

(i) fails to file audited accounts referred to in sub-section (1), or

(ii) fails to file revised annual return rectifying the mistake or omission, along with the audited statement of accounts and certificate or if the variance in the audited statement of accounts with the returns is not satisfactorily explained in the reconciliation statement prescribed, or

(iii) fails to file the annexures, statements, certificates, declarations, including the statutory declarations to be filed under the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 which are required to be filed along with the returns to prove the correctness of the concessional rate of tax, exemptions and exports claimed in the returns, or

(iv) fails to declare any sale, purchase or interstate stock transfer as evidenced from the documents prescribed under section 46 available with the assessing authority in the sales and purchase lists filed along with the returns, the assessment of such dealer for the relevant year for the purpose of section 25 shall be treated as pending and the time limit mentioned thereunder shall not be applicable in such cases.”

Soon after the aforesaid amendment, the Revenue initiated proceedings for re-opening the assessments of those assessees whose turnover was above the limits specified under Section 42(1), notwithstanding that the period under Section 25 of the Act for re-opening the assessments of such assessees had expired. In many cases, the assessments were thereafter completed by including the alleged escaped turnover and subjecting the same to tax. As already noticed, the pre-assessment notices and assessment orders are impugned in these writ petitions.

4. The contention raised on behalf of the writ petitioner assessees, as discernible from the pleadings, can be summarised as under:

> As per the Scheme of the KVAT Act, there is a finality attached to assessment proceedings and there are indicators under Sections 21, 22 24 and 25 of the KVAT Act as to when an assessment can be deemed final. Section 42(3), if interpreted as conferring a power on the Revenue to disregard the finality attaching to assessments, would militate against the Scheme of the KVAT Act. Such an interpretation is therefore to be avoided.

> The amendment inserting Sub Section 3 to Section 42 was brought in through Notification dated 13.11.2016 and was with a view to annul the effect of the judgment dated 5.10.2016 of this Court in S.Najeem and Other v. Commercial Tax Officer and Others, that frustrated the attempt of the Revenue to re-open assessments after expiry of the period of limitation prescribed therefor under Section 25 of the KVAT Act. In the absence of a validating provision, a mere retrospective amendment cannot nullify the declaratory judgment of this Court in Najeem’s case [supra]; [Ref. – Iswara Bhat v. CAIT – [1992 KHC 110]; State of Karnataka and Others v. Karnataka Pawn Brokers Assn. and Others – [2018 KHC 6187]].

> The retrospective operation of Section 42(3) with effect from 01.04.2005 would entail the re-opening of assessments that were completed years ago and in respect of assessment years pertaining to which the assessees do not have the relevant Books of accounts and other records to defend their case against an allegation of escaped turnover. It is contended that under the KVAT Rules, an assessee is obliged to keep his Books of account only for five years and hence the retrospective operation of Section 42(3) can, at any rate, be only to such extent and not beyond that. [ Ref. – Rai Ramkrishna v. State of Bihar – [AIR 1963 SC 1667];

> National Agricultural Cooperative Marketing Federation of India Ltd. and Another v. Union of India and Others – [(2003) 5 SCC 23] & Commissioner of Income Tax (Central)-I, New Delhi v. Vatika Township Private Limited – [(2015) 1 SCC 1]].

> Removing the limitation period for re-opening assessments of registered dealers under the KVAT Act would tantamount to treating them at par with unregistered dealers and those subjected to protective assessments, who are seen as evaders of tax. The provisions would therefore breach the mandate of Article 14 in that it treats unequals as equals for the purposes of assessment. Reference is drawn to Ghanshyam Das v. Regional Assistant Commissioner of Sales Tax, Nagpur – [(1964) 4 SCR 436]; Anandji Haridas and Co. (P) Ltd. v. S.P. Kasture and Others – [AIR 1968 SC 565]; State of Gujarat and Another v. Patel Ramjibhai Danabhai and Others – [(1979) 3 SCC 347]].

It is trite that in cases where there is no limitation period prescribed under a taxing statute for taking action against an assessee, a reasonable period of limitation has to be read into the statutory provision by the Court. In the instant cases, the reasonable period would be the period prescribed under Section 25 of the KVAT Act. [Ref. – [Director of Income-Tax (International Taxation) v. Mahindra and Mahindra Ltd. – [(2014) 365 ITR 560 (Bombay)]; Regional Provident Fund Commissioner v. K.T. Rolling Mills Pvt. Ltd. [(1995) 1 SCC 181]; Union of India and Others v. Uttam Steel Limited – [(2015) 13 SCC 209]; Chhedi Lal Yadav and Others v. Hari Kishore Yadav (Dead) Through Legal representatives and Others – [(2018) 12 SCC 527].

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.