Summary: The Tax Administration Reform Commission (TARC), in its First Report, recommended comprehensive reforms to improve tax deducted at source (TDS) administration and accelerate direct and indirect tax refunds. It proposed discontinuing mandatory manual submission of TDS certificates before Assessing Officers for refund verification and compensating deductors for their compliance obligations through a small commission deductible as business expenditure. To reduce procedural difficulties, TARC recommended expanding online TDS correction facilities, particularly for rectifying deductee names without repeatedly uploading complete statements. Another important proposal was a TDS passbook system under which tax deducted would automatically appear in taxpayers’ accounts as a running balance available for adjusting their tax liabilities. The Commission also suggested trained return preparers to assist small deductors. Regarding refunds, TARC recommended strict payment deadlines, separate budgetary provisions for direct and indirect tax refunds, and automatic payment of applicable interest through direct bank transfers. It proposed equalising interest rates on refunds and outstanding tax demands to ensure fairness. Refunds arising from favourable appellate decisions should be processed promptly, with taxpayers permitted to adjust outstanding refunds against subsequent advance tax or self-assessment tax liabilities. For indirect taxes, the Commission recommended limiting the application of unjust enrichment principles to cases involving direct passing on of the tax burden. It further proposed time-bound pre-audit verification, risk-based post-audit scrutiny, simplified refund procedures for service exporters and fully electronic processing. These historical recommendations aimed to reduce compliance burdens, strengthen transparency and establish a more taxpayer-friendly administration.
- Tax Deducted at Source
- Removal of Manual TDS Certificate Verification
- Compensation for Tax Deductors
- Online Correction of TDS Returns
- Introduction of TDS Passbook Scheme
- Assistance for Small and Marginal Tax Deductors
- Tax Refunds
- Time-Bound Refunds and Separate Budgetary Allocation
- Automatic Interest and Direct Bank Credit of Refunds
- Equal Interest Rates on Refunds and Tax Demands
- Timely Refunds Following Favourable Appeals
- Restricting Unjust Enrichment Tests in Indirect Tax Refunds
- Time-Bound Pre-Audit and Risk-Based Post-Audit Verification
- Simplified Online Refund Processing for Service Exporters
Tax Deducted at Source
Removal of Manual TDS Certificate Verification
The insistence on manual filing of TDS certificates before AO for verification of refunds claim should be done away with.
Compensation for Tax Deductors
The tax deductor’s duties and obligations in terms of making information compliance and also depositing the deducted amount is onerous and they are not compensated for that. Therefore, some compensation for them should be considered. This can be in terms of a small commission to be deducted as business expenses by them to fulfil their obligations.
Online Correction of TDS Returns
The CPC-TDS should allow correction in the name of the deductees to avoid multiple submissions of TDS forms. Even a single error requires the deductor to submit the entire return afresh. The process of uploading the entire file for one or two corrections is cumbersome and disproportionate to the gravity of the error. This adversely impacts taxpayer services. Subject to the required checks and validations, there is a need to widen the scope of online error rectification service.
Introduction of TDS Passbook Scheme
A passbook scheme for TDS may be adopted with some safeguards. Once TDS is deducted from a payment, TDS should get credited to the taxpayer’s account. This should be like an account with running balance, to be utilized by the taxpayer at his option to set off his tax liabilities.
Assistance for Small and Marginal Tax Deductors
To assist small and marginal tax deductors in preparing and filing their TDS returns, either existing tax return preparers or a separate system of TDS return preparers should be initiated with more training and a better remuneration structure than at present.
Tax Refunds
Time-Bound Refunds and Separate Budgetary Allocation
Refunds should be issued within a strict time frame. There should be a separate budgetary head for refund of direct tax and indirect taxes in the annual budget out of which refunds should be issued so that there is transparency. Adequate allocation should be made by the government under this head.
Automatic Interest and Direct Bank Credit of Refunds
Refunds sanctioned should be paid along with the applicable interest automatically as is done in the case of income tax and not on demand by the taxpayers. As in the case of direct taxes and customs duty drawback, the refund and interest payment should be directly credited to the bank account of the taxpayer.
Equal Interest Rates on Refunds and Tax Demands
The rate of interest on refunds should be the same as the interest charged by the tax department. This would ensure equity between the two interests and would not disadvantage the taxpayer unduly.
Timely Refunds Following Favourable Appeals
Refunds arising after a favourable appeal should be paid in time or the tax payer should be allowed to set-off the advance tax liability or self-assessment tax liability of subsequent years against the refunds due.
Restricting Unjust Enrichment Tests in Indirect Tax Refunds
The test to determine whether there is unjust enrichment in indirect taxes should be limited to cases of refunds where there is direct passing on of amounts claimed as refunds. In any other situation, this concept should not be applied.
Time-Bound Pre-Audit and Risk-Based Post-Audit Verification
Refund claim subjected to pre-audit verification should be issued within a specified time. The post-audit verification of refund claim should be risk-based.
Simplified Online Refund Processing for Service Exporters
An easier and simplified scheme should be introduced for service exporters. The entire refund filing and processing mechanism should be online.
Source: First Report of the Tax Administration Reform Commission (TARC).





details are very good. Incase govt deducts tax as 0nly 0.2% like tds for buisness man and refund like their return. then it will be good.
Dear Sudarshana,
For your recommendations we will have to wait for another change in Government
Will it help if PAN No. of the deductee is furnished in the challan itself at the time of making payment to the credit of Govt.’s Account…Number of challans would be increased but TDS would be instantly shown in 26AS of the deductee after payment
Passbook for TDS. 26AS is as good as a passbook of the direct tax payer. (Income tax).