Siddhartha Singh Vs Assistant Collector First Class/Sub Divisional Magistrate & Ors. (Supreme Court of India)
Summary: The Supreme Court allowed two civil appeals filed by Siddhartha Singh, a practising advocate before the Uttarakhand High Court, seeking expunction of adverse remarks concerning his professional conduct. The appeals arose from interim orders dated 1 December 2020 and 7 December 2021 passed by the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CLMA No. 14165/2018 and WPMS No. 763/2010, respectively. After examining the impugned orders and the circumstances surrounding the observations, the Supreme Court held that neither the advocate’s conduct nor the circumstances warranted the recording of such remarks. It characterised the remarks as unjustified and illegal. The Court relied on its earlier decision in Neeraj Garg Vs Sarita Rani & Ors. (2021) 9 SCC 92, wherein similar observations made by the same High Court Judge against another practising advocate were expunged. The Supreme Court expressed disapproval of the Judge’s tendency to make unwarranted remarks against advocates and found no necessity to re-examine the judicial approach already considered in the earlier judgment. Accordingly, both High Court orders were set aside only to the extent that they related to the advocate’s conduct, and the adverse remarks were expunged. Both civil appeals were allowed, and pending applications were disposed of.
Cases Discussed
- Neeraj Garg Vs Sarita Rani & Ors. (2021) 9 SCC 92 (Supreme Court) – Relied upon for expunging unwarranted adverse judicial observations made against practising advocates by the same High Court Judge.
FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER
1. Leave granted.
2. These civil appeals arise from interim orders dated 01-12-2020 & 07-12-2021 passed by the High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital in CLMA No.14165/2018 and WPMS No.763/2010 respectively.
3. Both these appeals are for expunging certain remarks made by the learned Judge of the High Court about the conduct of the appellant who is a practicing advocate in the High Court of Uttarakhand.
4. We have gone through the orders dated 01-12-2020 & 07-12-2021 and have carefully examined the circumstances in which the observations were made by the learned Judge. Having considered the observations made by the Hon’ble Judge, we are of the opinion that neither the conduct, nor the circumstance warranted recording of the remarks. These remarks are unjustified and illegal. In similar circumstances when comments were made by the same learned Judge against another practicing advocate, this Court intervened and by judgment in “Neeraj Garg vs. Sarita Rani & Ors. (2021) 9 SCC 92” allowed the appeal and set aside all those observations.
5. We disapprove the proclivity of the learned Judge of the High Court in making remarks against advocates for nothing so serious to take note of. In view of the fact that perception of the same learned Judge has already been noticed in Neeraj Garg (supra), we do not need to re-examine the approach adopted by the learned Judge even in this case.
6. In view of the above, we set aside the two orders passed by the learned Judge on 01-12-2020 & 07-12-2021 to the extent that they relate to the conduct of the advocate and expunge the remarks made against the appellant.
7. The civil appeals are allowed accordingly.
*****
1. Leave granted.
2. Civil Appeals are allowed in terms of the signed order.
3. Pending applications, if any, also stand disposed of.





