Prabhas Kumar Vs Radico (GSTAT Ghaziabad)
Summary: The GST Appellate Tribunal dismissed the State Tax Department’s appeal in Prabhas Kumar Vs Radico at the admission stage because the disputed tax of ₹6,29,505 was below the prescribed ₹20 lakh monetary limit and the Revenue failed to establish any applicable exception. Radico, an SEZ unit in Noida, was the respondent. The supplied order records that the first appellate authority had set aside an assessment order under Section 74 of the UPGST Act, 2017. The Department sought admission of its appeal and consideration on merits. The Tribunal examined Section 120, Uttar Pradesh Circular No. 2425008 dated 5 July 2024 and the continuing litigation framework under Circular No. 252/2026-27/State Tax dated 22 May 2026. It held that where the dispute concerns tax together with interest and penalty, only the aggregate disputed tax and cess count towards the monetary threshold. Accordingly, the combined demand could not be used to overcome the limit.
The Tribunal further held that the burden of identifying and establishing an exception rested on the Revenue. General approval or authorisation by the Commissioner was insufficient: reliance on the residual exception required a specific, reasoned opinion concerning the particular case, with a discernible basis. The statutory right of appeal remained subject to the conditions governing its exercise and the binding departmental litigation policy. Maintainability therefore had to be examined before merits. The appeal was dismissed at the threshold, expressly without affirming or rejecting the correctness of the first appellate order on the underlying tax dispute. Cases Discussed
Want to Read the Complete Judgment?
You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.
Already subscribed? Log in
One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.






