Advertisement
Advertisement
Skip to content
Follow Us on
Advertisement
TOP STORIES
Income Tax

Income From AOP Held Non-Taxable in Member’s Hands as It Was Share of Profit: SC

Case Law Details

TaxGuru Citation
2026 taxguru.in 5366
Case Name
Sanand Properties Pvt. Ltd Vs Jt. Commr. of I.T. Range 6 And Ors. (Supreme Court of India)
Appeal Number
Premium Access
Date of Judgement/Order
Premium Access
Subscribe to download.

Already Upgraded? Log in.

Advertisement

Sanand Properties Pvt. Ltd Vs Jt. Commr. of I.T. Range 6 And Ors. (Supreme Court of India)

Supreme Court Holds Reassessment Invalid Because Reopening Was Based on Mere Change of Opinion; Reopening Under Section 148 Quashed Because No New Tangible Material Existed; Income From AOP Held Non-Taxable in Member’s Hands Because It Was Share of Profit; Supreme Court Says Reassessment Cannot Be Used as Substitute for Review of Completed Assessment; Section 147 Reopening Invalid Because Assessing Officer Already Examined Profit Sharing Arrangement; AOP Member’s Share Not Taxable Separately Because AOP Was Already Assessed as Distinct Entity; Supreme Court Upholds Principle That Tangible Material Is Mandatory for Reassessment Proceedings; Reassessment Notice for AY 2007-08 Set Aside Because Revenue Relied on Existing Assessment Records; Clause in AOP Agreement Treated as Profit Sharing Arrangement and Not Revenue Sharing Mechanism; Supreme Court Clarifies That Validity of Reopening Must Be Tested Only on Recorded Reasons.

In, the Supreme Court considered three connected civil appeals concerning reopening of assessments under Sections 147 and 148 of the Income Tax Act, 1961, and the taxability of income received by Sanand Properties Pvt. Ltd. (SPPL) from an Association of Persons (AOP) named Fortaleza Developers.

The dispute arose from an agreement dated 29.04.2003 between SPPL and Raviraj Kothari & Co. for development of residential housing projects through the AOP. The central controversy was whether the amount received by SPPL from the AOP represented a share of profit of the AOP or a share of revenue/gross receipts.

SPPL had filed returns for AY 2007-08 and AY 2008-09, which were scrutinized under Section 143(3). Subsequently, on 11.01.2011, notices under Section 148 were issued to reopen the assessments on the ground that income chargeable to tax had escaped assessment.

The reopening was based on a survey conducted under Section 133A on 23.12.2010 during which several documents were impounded, including the AOP agreement, financial statements of Fortaleza Developers, books of account, development agreements, auditor communications, and standard agreements for sale of residential units. The statement of a director of SPPL was also recorded.

According to the Revenue, these materials showed that the amount received by SPPL from the AOP was not exempt profit share but consideration linked to development rights and constituted 35% of gross sale receipts. The Assessing Officer concluded that such income was taxable in the hands of SPPL and had escaped assessment within the meaning of Explanation 2(c)(iv) to Section 147.

SPPL objected to the reopening, contending that most of the documents relied upon were already part of the assessment record during the original scrutiny proceedings. However, the objections were rejected by the Assessing Officer.

Bombay High Court Proceedings

For AY 2007-08, the Bombay High Court quashed the reopening notice. The High Court relied on the Supreme Court ruling in Kelvinator and held that reassessment cannot be based on a mere change of opinion. It observed that the Assessing Officer was already aware of the arrangement between SPPL and the AOP, including the 35:65 sharing ratio and the income claimed as exempt profit share.

The High Court noted that the relevant documents had already been furnished during the original assessment proceedings and no new tangible material existed except two documents which did not materially advance the Revenue’s case. Since the AOP itself had been assessed separately and its validity was never questioned, the High Court held that SPPL’s share of AOP income could not be taxed again. Accordingly, the reopening for AY 2007-08 was treated as invalid and based merely on change of opinion.

However, for AY 2008-09, the Bombay High Court upheld the reopening. It distinguished AY 2008-09 from AY 2007-08 on the basis that the assessment order of the AOP for AY 2008-09 contained detailed findings regarding the nature of the agreement and concluded that the arrangement was based on revenue sharing.

The High Court observed that the AOP assessment order for AY 2008-09 specifically treated the 35% amount as share in gross receipts rather than share in profits. Since this constituted tangible material available to the Assessing Officer within four years of assessment, the reopening notice for AY 2008-09 was held to be valid.

Reassessment and Parallel Proceedings

Following the High Court decision upholding reopening for AY 2008-09, the reassessment order dated 30.12.2011 was passed. The Assessing Officer held that Clause 7 of the AOP agreement entitled SPPL to 35% of gross sale proceeds and treated the amount as revenue share taxable in SPPL’s hands. The reassessment order also stated that the exemption provisions under Sections 167B and 115JB were not applicable in the manner claimed by SPPL.

Meanwhile, in separate proceedings concerning the AOP itself, the ITAT examined Clause 7 of the agreement and held that the amount received by SPPL constituted a share of profit and not overriding title to revenue. The ITAT further held that the AOP was a separate taxable entity eligible for deduction under Section 80IB(10).

The ITAT reiterated the same interpretation for AY 2008-09 and AY 2009-10, holding that Clause 7 represented a profit-sharing arrangement and not a revenue-sharing mechanism.

The Bombay High Court later affirmed the ITAT’s interpretation in proceedings relating to the AOP. It upheld the finding that the income received by SPPL from the AOP represented share of profits and not revenue. The High Court further observed that there was no surrender of development rights by SPPL in favour of the AOP.

Subsequently, in appeals relating to SPPL itself, the Bombay High Court again upheld the ITAT’s view and held that the amount received by SPPL from the AOP was not taxable separately because it was only a share of profits from the AOP.

Assessee’s Arguments Before the Supreme Court

SPPL argued before the Supreme Court that reopening for both AYs was based purely on change of opinion because all material facts and agreements had already been disclosed during original scrutiny proceedings. The company relied upon disclosures made in the returns and revised returns stating that the AOP income was exempt in the hands of SPPL because tax was payable by the AOP itself under Section 167B(2).

SPPL further contended that the AOP agreement, books of account, appropriation account, and ledger extracts had all been furnished during scrutiny assessment and therefore reassessment amounted to impermissible review of the completed assessment.

It was also argued that the director’s statement recorded during survey merely reiterated facts already known to the Assessing Officer and therefore could not constitute fresh tangible material.

SPPL relied heavily on the findings rendered in the AOP’s own proceedings, where both the ITAT and Bombay High Court had held that Clause 7 represented profit sharing and not revenue sharing. It argued that these findings had attained finality and therefore the very basis for reopening ceased to survive.

The assessee also submitted that there was no material distinction between AY 2007-08 and AY 2008-09, and therefore the reopening notice for AY 2008-09 should also have been quashed just like AY 2007-08.

Revenue’s Arguments Before the Supreme Court

The Revenue contended that Clause 7 clearly provided for SPPL to receive 35% of gross receipts from sale of housing units and therefore the amount constituted revenue share taxable in SPPL’s hands.

The Revenue argued that the actual implementation of the agreement supported this interpretation because the amount received by SPPL approximated 35% of gross receipts and not profits. According to the Revenue, the nomenclature adopted in accounts could not change the substance of the transaction.

The Revenue further argued that the characterization of the payment as profit share was intended to maximize deduction under Section 80IB(10). It maintained that the amount paid to SPPL should have been treated as an expense in the hands of the AOP rather than profit appropriation.

On reopening, the Revenue submitted that discovery of the AOP agreement during survey constituted tangible material justifying reassessment. It also argued that identical reasons were recorded for both AY 2007-08 and AY 2008-09 and therefore the reopening for AY 2007-08 should also have been upheld.

Supreme Court’s Analysis on Reopening

The Supreme Court examined Sections 147 and 148 and reiterated that reassessment requires the Assessing Officer to possess “reason to believe” that income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment.

The Court emphasized that reopening cannot be used as a mechanism for review and that the concept of “change of opinion” acts as an inbuilt safeguard against arbitrary exercise of power. Referring to Kelvinator, the Court observed that reassessment must be based on tangible material having a live nexus with the belief regarding escapement of income.

The Court also clarified that validity of reopening must be judged only on the basis of reasons recorded under Section 148 and not on the eventual outcome of reassessment proceedings.

The judgment further noted that the Assessing Officer must possess some new tangible material before reopening an assessment already completed under Section 143(3). Mere reinterpretation of existing material would amount to impermissible review.

FULL TEXT OF THE SUPREME COURT JUDGMENT/ORDER

Want to Read the Complete Judgment?

You have read the free case summary. Unlock the full judgment, the detailed judicial reasoning and the downloadable PDF, along with every other premium judgment on TaxGuru.

Read on with Premium
Goes straight to payment. GST invoice included.

One subscription covers the entire premium judgment library, not just this case.

Advertisement

Author Info

CA Sandeep Kanoi
Qualification: Graduate, CA in Job / Business, DD
Company: Taxguru Consultancy
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra
Articles Published: 24,561

Join TaxGuru's Network for the latest updates on Income Tax, GST, Company Law, Corporate Laws and other related subjects.

Comments are closed.