Mere CA certificate do not establish bonafide of Assessees claim

In the present case, we note that Tribunal has proceeded on the premise that the claim for deduction under Section 80IA of the Act was duly supported by the Chartered Accountant’s Certificate and prescribed forms signed by the Chartered Accountant. For claiming deduction under Section 80IA of the Act, filing of certificate and forms signed by the Chartered Accountant is mandatory and a requirement of law. All returns, where deduction under Section 80IA is claimed, must have such certificates and forms. Mere filing of the said forms/certificate cannot absolve and protect an assessee who furnishes in-accurate particulars. If the explanation and the reasoning of the Tribunal is accepted, then in all cases where a form/certificate is furnished by the Chartered Accountant but a wrong claim of deduction is made, no penalty under Section 271(1)(c) can be imposed. Merely because the assessee complies with the statutory procedural requirement of filing the prescribed form and certificate of the Chartered Accountant, cannot absolve the assessee of its liability if the act or attempt in claiming the deduction was not bonafide.

HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

ITA 480/2012, ITA 481/2012

Date of Decision: 29^th July, 2013

CIT Vs. HCIL KALINDEE ARSSPL

ORDER

SANJIV KHANNA, J. (Oral)