The Air India-Vistara Merger is a major development in the Indian aviation industry. It is a sign of the growing consolidation in the industry, and it is likely to have a significant impact on competition. The CCI was required to assess whether the merger would have any anti-competitive effects. The CCI considered a number of factors, including the market share of the merged entity, the competitive landscape in the aviation sector, and the potential for the merger to lead to higher prices or lower quality of service.
Air India-Vistara Merger & CCI’s Role
The CCI’s role in the Air India-Vistara merger is an important example of how the Competition Act is being used to protect competition in India.The CCI ultimately approved the merger, subject to certain conditions. These conditions included commitments from the merged entity to maintain certain levels of competition, such as by not reducing the number of flights or increasing prices.
This case has created an inquisitiveness towards The Indian Competition Act, 2002 & Competition Commission of India .
Today we’ll delve into the concept of Competition, by asking the rudimentary questions.
What is Competition?
The term “Competition” is not defined in the Competition Act 2002.
Chapter 1 of the joint report A Framework for the Design and Implementation of Competition Law and Policy’ by the World Bank and the OECD, broadly defines the competition as;
“A situation in a market in which firms or sellers independently stride for the buyers’ patronage in order to achieve a particular business objective, for example, profit, sales, or market share. Competition in this context is often equated with rivalry. Competitive rivalry may take place in terms of price, quantity, service, or combinations of these and other factors that customers may value.”
What is the need of Competition ??
The need for competition is a fundamental concept in economics and business, and it has various real-life examples that illustrate its importance. Here are a few examples that demonstrate why competition is essential:
- Lower Prices for Consumers: In the retail industry, competition between stores like Walmart, Amazon, and local supermarkets leads to lower prices for consumers. These companies strive to offer the best deals to attract shoppers, resulting in cost savings for customers.
- Quality Improvement: The competitive smartphone market, with companies like Apple, Samsung, and Google competing fiercely, drives continuous innovation and improvements in features, performance, and design. Consumers benefit from better-quality products.
- Innovation and Technological Advancement: Competition among tech giants like Apple, Google, and Microsoft fuels rapid technological advancements. For example, the race for dominance in artificial intelligence (AI) has led to breakthroughs in voice recognition and AI-driven services, benefiting users.
- Choice and Variety: In the fast-food industry, competition among chains like McDonald’s, Burger King, and Taco Bell ensures a wide variety of menu options. Customers can choose from different cuisines and flavors, catering to diverse tastes.
- Efficiency and Cost Reduction: In the automotive sector, competition between automakers like Toyota, Ford, and Volkswagen drives efficiency and cost reduction. It encourages companies to adopt lean manufacturing processes and produce vehicles with better fuel efficiency.
- Customer Service: In the Telecom industry, competition between mobile service providers leads to improved customer service, better network coverage, and competitive pricing plans. Customers benefit from enhanced communication services.
- Accessibility and Inclusivity: The competition between ride-sharing companies like Uber, Ola and Blu has increased accessibility to transportation services. This is especially beneficial for individuals in areas with limited public transportation options.
- Small Business Growth: E-commerce platforms like Shopify and WooCommerce enable small businesses to compete with larger corporations online. This competition fosters entrepreneurship and allows smaller enterprises to thrive.
- Environmental Responsibility: Competition in the renewable energy sector has led to the development of more efficient solar panels and wind turbines. This, in turn, contributes to reducing greenhouse gas emissions and addressing climate change.
- Healthcare Services: In the health insurance industry, competition among providers encourages the development of various health insurance plans, offering consumers choices that suit their healthcare needs and budgets.
Conclusion
The Air India-Vistara merger highlights how regulatory bodies like the CCI utilize the Competition Act to maintain a healthy competitive environment. Understanding competition is not just crucial for regulatory compliance but also for the thriving of industries and consumer benefits. Stay tuned for our next article, where we will delve deeper into the evolution of competition laws in India and their implications for various stakeholders.
Author Bio
