A designated area within a nation is known as a specific Economic Zone (SEZ), and these places are given specific economic and regulatory rules in order to draw in foreign investment and promote economic growth. SEZs have been effective in fostering economic growth, but there are worries about how they may affect labour rights. SEZs may have an impact on labour rights through a number of different avenues. In order to draw in foreign investment, SEZs frequently receive exemptions from labour law requirements. This may result in less protection for employees’ rights, including laws governing minimum pay, working hours, and health and safety.
The fact that SEZs frequently enjoy exemption from labour rules and regulations is one of the key issues with them in India. A number of labour laws, including the Industrial Disputes Act, the Contract Labour Act, and the Factories Act, among others, are exempted under the SEZ Act of 2005. Due to this, laws governing minimum salaries, working hours, and health and safety have not been adequately protected for workers’ rights.
Within SEZs, a segmented labour market has emerged because of the exemption from labour rules. Worker exploitation and the degradation of rights may result from SEZ workers being subject to different labour rules and regulations than those outside the zone.
Workers have protested and gone on strike because the rights of workers are not protected in SEZs. For instance, in 2010 employees at Chennai’s Nokia SEZ went on strike to seek improved pay and working conditions. The labourers bemoaned about meagre pay, lengthy workweeks, and unstable employment.
The Indian government has taken action to solve the issue of labour laws within SEZs in response to these worries. Guidelines for the application of labour regulations in SEZs were released by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry in 2013. The rules outline how labour laws and regulations, including as those governing minimum salaries, working hours, and health and safety, should be applied to employees within SEZs.
The rules are not, however, enforceable in all SEZs and are not always followed. The standards have moreover come under fire for not going far enough in defending workers’ rights inside SEZs.
SEZs have the potential to partition the labour market so that those working there are subject to different labour rules and regulations than those working elsewhere. This may result in the exploitation of local workers, who might receive lesser pay and fewer workplace safeguards. Concerns about labour market segmentation exist in the context of India’s Special Economic Zones (SEZs). SEZs have the potential to divide the labour market into segments, with workers inside the zone being subject to different labour laws and rules than those outside the zone. This may result in the exploitation of local workers, who might receive lesser pay and fewer workplace safeguards.
Gender Inequality: SEZs may make labour market gender disparities worse. Within SEZs, women are frequently employed in low-paying, low-skilled positions like assembly line work in factories. In the zone, they could experience prejudice in recruiting and promotions. The gender pay gap is one of the major difficulties that women workers in SEZs deal with. For the same labour, women in SEZs frequently receive lesser pay than males. This is due to the fact that women are overrepresented in low-paying occupations and frequently work as contract employees who lack benefits and job security.
Concerns for the health and safety of women employees in SEZs are another issue. Women’s physical and mental health may suffer because of the excessive hours and inadequate health and safety safeguards seen in SEZs. Women employees may furthermore experience sexual harassment and discrimination at work.
Lack of Unionisation: SEZs may limit employees’ ability to organise unions and engage in collective bargaining for better pay and working conditions. As a result, there may be insufficient worker representation and diminished bargaining leverage. Because they give employees a forum to voice their opinions and take part in decisions affecting their jobs, unions are a crucial component of democratic society.
The right of workers to organise unions and engage in collective bargaining must be maintained if the absence of unionisation in SEZs is to be addressed. This would entail enhancing the enforcement of labour rules and regulations in SEZs as well as modifying labour laws to guarantee that SEZ workers have the same rights as those outside the zones.
Migrant Labour: The reasoning of their vulnerability, migrant workers—on whom SEZs may rely heavily—may be exploited and mistreated. Language limitations, cultural differences, and ignorance of one’s legal rights are other factors that may make migrant workers more vulnerable to exploitation. In SEZs, migrant labourers are frequently employed in labor-intensive, low-skilled jobs like manufacturing and construction. These professions frequently come with minimal job security, low pay, and unfavourable working conditions. Additionally, migrant workers are frequently hired on a contract basis, which limits their access to social protections like health insurance and retirement benefits.
Both favourable and unfavourable effects may result from the influx of migrant workers into SEZs. The supply of labour that migrant labourers bring is beneficial for the operation of SEZs. They also help the areas where SEZs are located to experience economic progress.
On the other side, migrant workers’ insecure job situation leaves them open to exploitation and abuse. On the basis of their language, culture, and country of origin, they could experience discrimination. Governments and policymakers should take action to ensure that SEZs do not jeopardise labour rights in order to allay these worries. This might comprise:
- Ensuring that all workers, regardless of where they are located within the nation, are subject to the same labour rules and regulations.
- Promoting unionisation and collective bargaining inside SEZs.
- Encouraging the advancement of women into higher-paying, more highly trained positions, as well as equal pay for equal effort.
- Protecting migrant workers’ rights, especially by offering them language and legal support and making sure they are not subject to abusive working circumstances.
SEZs may significantly affect labour rights, to sum up. Policymakers must take action to ensure that they do not impair the rights of employees in these zones, even if they can be an excellent instrument for fostering economic growth. Governments can develop SEZs that support both economic growth and the defence of labour rights by enacting the proper laws and regulations. In conclusion, one of the main issues with SEZs in India is labour laws. Even if the government has taken action to address these issues, SEZs need to enforce labour laws and regulations more firmly and consistently. This would make it easier to guarantee that workers’ rights are upheld and that SEZs support India’s sustainable economic growth.
REFRENCES:
1. https://www.labourfile.com/section-detail.php?aid=615.
2. https://academic.oup.com/jiel/article/24/2/341/6219919.
3. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24549102.
4.https://www.researchgate.net/publication/326280791_Labour_and_Labour_Welfare_in_Special_Economic_Zones_in_India_with_Special_Reference_to_Gujarat.
Author Bio
