Case Law Details
Vageesh Umesh Jaiswal Vs State of Gujarat (Gujarat High Court)
The whole object of issuing a show-cause notice is to make the recipient of the notice understand what the authority is trying to convey and what are the nature of the allegations. In the case on hand, when there are allegations of bogus billing, it was expected of the authority to at least furnish some information about such bogus billing. At this stage, Mr. Sharma submitted that along with the show-cause notice, there is always few documents attached which would indicate what the authority wants to convey about the bogus billing. It has been stated on oath not only in the memorandum of the writ application but even in the reply to the show-cause notice that except the show-cause notice, nothing else was furnished or nothing was attached to such show-cause notice.
A show cause notice has great significance in the adjudication proceedings for the mandatory compliance of the principles of natural justice . Show cause notice is a mandatory requirement for raising any demand under the Act, 2017 except payment of interest u/s 50 and assessment of non filer of returns u/s 62 of the act. The SCN is the foundation on which the adjudicating authority has to build up its case. It is the document served on the taxable person asking him to explain with reason as to why a particular course of action should not be taken against him. It must be a speaking and well reasoned document. The issue of SCN is not only to make aware the taxable person against whom the action is intended to be taken but must contain brief facts of case and grounds relied upon for the proposed action and language in precision, the reading of which makes the person concerned understand the case that he has to defend. It should not be issued on assumptions and presumptions. The allegations and findings in the SCN should be supported by some documentary evidences.
Input tax credit cannot be blocked under Rule 86A of GST Rules for more than a Year
At this stage Mr. Joshi pointed out that the input tax credit was also blocked in exercise of the powers under Rule 86A of the Rules. Let us assume for the moment that at the relevant point of time, the authority was justified, but the order has outlived its statutory life period of one year. In such circumstances, the blocking of the input tax credit also comes to an end.
Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.
