AO has no jurisdiction to examine constitutional validity of any Act

Assessing officer being a statutory authority under the Act is bound to respect all the laws may be made by the Parliament or may be made by the State Legislature. He has no jurisdiction to examine the constitutional validity of any Act or the statute or a subordinate legislation which creates statutory liability upon the assessee to make the payment by way of an expenditure incurred.

Assessing officer has no authority or competence to hold that the privilege fee is not having the character of statutory fee or that the State Legislature or the State Government in exercise of its power by way of a delegated legislation, cannot decide the quantum of fee or the percentage of the revenue on the income earned from the business. Be it recorded that the assessing officer was not exercising the power as that of a constitutional Court nor at any point of time the constitutional validity of the Karnataka Excise Act read with the Rules which include the grant of licence and payment of the privilege fees were under the challenge. It is not the case of the appellant that the assessing officer had any authority, competence or jurisdiction to examine the constitutional validity of the State Legislature or subordinate legislation in exercise of the delegated power.

Under the circumstances, the observations made by the assessing officer in the impugned order so far as privilege fee is concerned can be said to be ultravires to his power under the Act.

In view of the above, if an action of disallowance of the deduction of privilege fee, the expenditure of privilege fee is wholly without jurisdiction and ultravires to his power, it would be the case falling under exceptional category for entertainment of writ power under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

In view of the above, the disallowance of the deduction of privilege fees as expenditure is wholly without jurisdiction and the observations made by the assessing Officer so far as constitutional validity of the relevant Act and the Rules and the power exercised by the State for delegated legislation for fixation of the quantum of fees can also be said as ultravires to his power because he has no power or authority to test the validity of any statutory provision, may be made by the State Legislature or the Parliament.

Please become a Premium member. If you are already a Premium member, login here to access the full content.